Update to the above: The thread decided to cut it, and the cut request was processed recently.
Edited by GastonRabbit Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.
Feels like some of the stuff put under Star Wars: The Last Jedi feels more like Decon-Recon Switches than Indecisive Deconstructions, but not 100% sure.
Edited by MotiveFan Hide / Show Replies
A Decon-Recon Switch needs to present an actual acknowledgement of the deconstruction and its challenge and overcome it. Luke failed Ben but nobody around him knows that he did, Leia doesn't and so on and he's passed as a hero without facing actual in-story consequences for his actions.
MagBas
I am guessing in nominate Indecisive Deconstruction to the ymmv banner in the "Pages that Need the YMMV banner" thread in "Long time/Perpetual" in the forums. First, where is the fine line mentioned in the description? As determine that a work "didn't go far enough?" The own description uses "Basically, there are many questions that can be raised about what counts as a deconstruction." Second, the first of the three subtypes, "Unintentional Deconstruction", is pure Audience Reaction, the second of the three subtypes, "Partial Deconstruction", mentions that it is debatable, and the last of the three subtypes, "Attempted Deconstruction", mentions some examples with "arguably".
Hide / Show Replies
To whom it may concern: I added a post about this page to the Trope Repair Shop a while ago, if anyone would like to chime in.
To be perfectly honest, I've had some concerns about this page for a while—but I'd like to discuss them before I start deleting entries left and right.
The thread is here: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=1557111941033736000
Edited by TheMightyHeptagon Hide / Show Replies