Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion Main / GrandfatherClause

Go To

You will be notified by PM when someone responds to your discussion
Type the word in the image. This goes away if you get known.
If you can't read this one, hit reload for the page.
The next one might be easier to see.
YPS88 Since: Nov, 2017
Aug 1st 2023 at 3:08:27 AM •••

Should we really count pieces that haven't continued into an era where their tropes have been discredited? The Epic of Gilgamesh not dropping cliched elements is obviously not gonna, because the original was finished several millenia ago, within a time where these weren't discredited yet. Star Trek shows which use the Planet of Hats Trope were still made in eras after this trope was discredited, which definetly IS noteworthy

DongwaChan Since: Feb, 2019
Jul 25th 2022 at 10:56:58 AM •••

Would it be okay to add some new examples of trope names to the Web Original section?

YoriIroy Always serious, 'cause someone has to be Since: Mar, 2014
Always serious, 'cause someone has to be
Feb 19th 2021 at 4:52:54 PM •••

Question about this example:

  • The first Yakuza was dubbed, wasn't the biggest hit, and the rest have remained undubbed. While there were plans to dub the third game, the franchise became popular enough to warrant dubs for spinoffs, and the 7th game is a Soft Reboot, every mainline game has been sub only, and probably will remain sub only.
Is the 7th game not a mainline game? I didn't want to make assumtions.

I can't draw
serialkillerwhale Since: Feb, 2012
Apr 27th 2014 at 5:01:13 AM •••

Would the "My friends play it" reason so many people don't migrate from World Of Warcraft (And to a lesser extent, other MM Os) count? If it weren't for the fact that it exists and has existed for so long and manages to exist, World Of Warcraft (no matter how much I praise it) wouldn't be the juggernaut it is today without it's community and very community-oriented devs.

serialkillerwhale Since: Feb, 2012
Apr 27th 2014 at 5:01:13 AM •••

Would the "My friends play it" reason so many people don't migrate from World Of Warcraft (And to a lesser extent, other MM Os) count? If it weren't for the fact that it exists and has existed for so long and manages to exist, World Of Warcraft (no matter how much I praise it) wouldn't be the juggernaut it is today without it's community and very community-oriented devs.

MithrandirOlorin Since: May, 2012
Dec 28th 2013 at 7:31:13 AM •••

"Nowadays, it would be unacceptable for the Arch-Enemy of a superhero to be anything but equal or greater in power than the hero." I don't think this is true, the idea that the Villain who's Brian rather then brawn is the greatest threat remains what audiences prefer to see whether they admit it or not. hell TDK made The Joker less of a physical threat then he usually is in the Comics.

Greener223224 Greener223224 Since: Apr, 2013
Greener223224
Sep 8th 2013 at 10:33:40 PM •••

Does the British royalty count as this or an Artifact?

...Burn...
JoePGuy Since: Jan, 2012
Jan 12th 2013 at 9:21:08 PM •••

Hey - not meaning to step on anybody's toes, but I excised the bit about why Chekhov's accent was poorly done (by Koenig) in the original Trek. The description of his bad accent was that he "replaced v's with w's rather than vice-versa" - but that's actually not a poorly-done Russian accent.

For one thing, it's a well-known foreign accent phenomenon sometimes called "overcompensation," where speakers of a foreign tongue know they'll have a tendency to mispronounce certain things based on their own native tongue (like "V" instead of "W" for Russian speakers of English), and self-consciously (accidentally) do the reverse (i.e., pronouncing a "W" in place of a "V").

For another, I can vouch for this phenomenon first-hand: my wife is Russian-born, an excellent speaker of English (she was a translation major at university), and occasionally does precisely this! (So do many of her friends who I speak with.)

So, no slam intended, but while I agree that Koenig's accent left something to be desired, the swapping of the "V" and "W" sounds wasn't a good reason why.

Didn't want to try to fit all of that into the edit justification and not make it clear.

Edited by JoePGuy Hide / Show Replies
Thecommander236 Since: Aug, 2011
Jan 12th 2013 at 9:33:54 PM •••

So basically Chekhov was a native Russian who was trying too hard to speak English. Got it.

Don't make me destroy you. @ Castle Series
JoePGuy Since: Jan, 2012
Jan 13th 2013 at 6:44:29 AM •••

Yeah, basically! Where were you when I was trying to condense that to an edit justification?

Though I'd still largely agree that Walter Koenig's accent wasn't stellar, which is why I wouldn't just cut the whole reference.

Thecommander236 Since: Aug, 2011
Jan 13th 2013 at 11:31:50 AM •••

So basically it was Chekhov playing a Russian who was trying too hard too speak English, but his accent was a failure even in that regard. And to get more meta, Walter Koenig is playing as Chekhov playing as a fake Russian trying too hard to speak English and failing at it. :D

Don't make me destroy you. @ Castle Series
TippyToeZombie Since: Mar, 2011
Dec 15th 2011 at 8:22:05 AM •••

Does anyone else think that Pluto should be subject to the Grandfather Clause?

I am the Tippy Toe Zombie I like to Limbo Often I fall on people's heads
artman40 Since: Jan, 2001
Jul 2nd 2010 at 3:41:01 PM •••

Can there meta examples be added like TV Tropes ones?

Hide / Show Replies
Citizen Since: Jan, 2001
Jul 2nd 2010 at 8:46:36 PM •••

Since TV Tropes is mentioned in the description, sure. If you're sure about your examples, make a separate folder for TV Tropes at the bottom of the list.

Top