Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion Main / FantasticFaunaCounterpart

Go To

You will be notified by PM when someone responds to your discussion
Type the word in the image. This goes away if you get known.
If you can't read this one, hit reload for the page.
The next one might be easier to see.
CaptainCrawdad Since: Aug, 2009
Jan 14th 2023 at 6:32:06 PM •••

Removed:

  • The numerous times anteaters have evolved is an excellent example of how convergent evolution works: many unrelated mammals have independently evolved narrow snouts, powerful curved claws and long sticky tongues for feeding on ants and termites and breaking into their hives: these include the true anteaters of South America (distant relatives of sloths), the aardvarks of Africa (a distant relative of elephants and manatees), the pangolins of Asia (scaly mammals thought to be related to carnivorans more than anything else), the echidnas of Australia (egg-laying monotremes), and the numbats (marsupials). The sloth bears of India also evolved some anteater-like traits (large curved claws to break anthills, elongated snouts), though they are not as specialized as the others, and still complement their diet with more typical bear-like food like fruit, honey and carrion.
  • The most common large, herding plains herbivores in Africa are antelopes. In Australia, however, this niche is instead filled by kangaroos. Antelopes and kangaroos also fill similar niches to deer in wooded environments, and kangaroos were often compared to deer in the journals of the first Europeans to visit Australia.
  • The aye-aye lemur is in a way a Madagascan equivalent of a woodpecker, as it bores through bark with its sharp incisors to feed on grubs and insects that tunnel in the wood.
  • The mongoose can be seen as this to the weasel: both are long-bodied small predators adapted to chasing small prey down their burrows. However, they belong to completely different branches of the carnivoran family tree: while weasels are more closely related to dogs, mongooses are more closely related to cats.
  • Hummingbirds fill the niche of flying nectar-feeders in the American continent, which is filled by large insects, primarily moths, in other parts of the world. In the deserts of North America, certain kinds of bat fill this role instead, and have developed long, sticky tongues very similar to a hummingbird's to feed on nectar.
  • Baboons, mandrills and drills fill a similar niche as wolves and other canids, and are essentially the primate equivalent of wolves. This is especially apparent with their skull shape, which is essentially a primate skull stretched out into a caniform shape.
  • Cranes, storks, and herons are three distinct groups of birds that all evolved long legs, necks and bills due to their similar habitat and diet (wading birds living in wetlands, mostly eating small vertebrates). Each family is more closely related to certain smaller waterbirds than to one another — cranes to crakes and coots, storks to boobies and cormorants, and herons to ibises and pelicans.
  • With jaguars native to the Americas, tigers native to Asia, and lions native to Africa, and all being the feline apex predators of their respective continents, they can be seen as Fantastic Fauna Counterparts/Palette Swaps of each other.
  • Certain prehistoric animals filled niches that modern animals now occupy:
    • A notable case are the pterosaurs, who convergently evolved many similarities with birds of today, such as ones that sieved food from water like a flamingo, or ones with throat pouches like pelicans for catching fish. The azdarchids, a group of very large pterosaurs adapted for moving around on land, filled a niche very similar to that now held by cranes, storks and herons, just scaled up to the size of a giraffe.
    • Chalicotheres were prehistoric, knuckle-walking, odd-toed ungulates that were essentially horses trying to be gorillas (or from a certain perspective, a literal Donkey Kong). They also filled the same ecological niche in the Old World as giant ground sloths did in the New World, being large, slow-moving, knuckle-walking herbivores with big claws on their front limbs.
    • The long-necked, long-legged Paraceratherium was essentially a rhino adapted to fill the niche of the sauropod dinosaurs, and giraffes later adopted many of these same traits.
    • Aquatic vertebrates have repeatedly developed a number of similar traits — in particular, sharks, ichthyosaurs, and dolphins are habitually used in science textbooks to show convergent evolution. Similarly, the elongated primitive whale Basilosaurus was essentially a mammalian mosasaur.
    • Prionosuchus, a large Triassic amphibian, greatly resembled a crocodile and likely filled their niche as aquatic ambush hunters ages before the true crocodiles evolved.
    • Many Mesozoic mammals and protomammals are very similar to modern species. Examples include the aquatic Castorocauda that had a paddle-like tail similar to a beaver, the gliding Volaticotherium that glided like a flying squirrel, or the stocky dinosaur-eating Repenomamus that are similar to honey badgers of today.
    • The shape of Tyrannosaurus skulls and close relatives indicate that it was something of a precursor for all modern land predators, with it being one of the earliest predators to have binocular vision, which was so good that it even surpassed that of modern hawks. In a way, that makes all modern carnivores (canids, bears, and felids) FantasticFaunaCounterparts of the tyrannosaurs, who could be considered a prototype of modern land predators.
  • African wild dogs can be seen as an African equivalent to gray wolvesnote . They are both intelligent social canines with rivalries with big cats (mountain lions for wolves, lions for African wild dogs.) They have similarities in pack structure, with packs being centered around a monogamous pair, and older offspring either dispersing or staying to help raise younger siblings. African wild dogs hunt antelope, which are superficially similar to the deer wolves hunt. You can also argue that spotted hyenas have some similarities to wolves, especially the extinct dire wolf, although they are not actually canines.
    • Mammalian carnivores resembling dogs have evolved so many times in the fossil record that it probably deserves a term like carcinization (caninization?), with mesonychids (carnivorous ungulates), creodonts (primitive mammal carnivores), Tasmanian tigers (marsupials), amphicyonids (the "bear dogs") and hyenas both modern and extinct being examples of animals that assumed a form uncannily similar to true canines. Even baboons and mandrills have a similar skull shape. Even the gorgonopsids and therocephalians, primitive mammal-relatives (therapsids) from before the time of the dinosaurs, were rather dog-like in size and body proportions.
  • Carcinisation is a very specific convergent evolution phenomenon where crustaceans just keep taking on crab-like shapes, whether true crabs or not.
  • Due to them being the only big cats that live in social groups, lions are basically the feline equivalent of wolves.
  • It's been theorized that it's possible for some alien life to look superficially similar to Earth life because of convergent evolution. We already see this on Earth with some animal species looking similar to other species they are not closely related to. Starfish Aliens are also probably a thing also. It's not a either/or thing.

These are all just real animals that resemble other animals, not a fictional animal invented along the lines of a real animal.

MrStranger616 Since: Feb, 2020
Nov 21st 2020 at 1:06:54 PM •••

They do this in Penn Zero Part Time hero. There's a four-legged hammerhead shark in one episode, which appears in another episode, and is revealed to talk!

Hide / Show Replies
Snicka Since: Jun, 2011
Nov 21st 2020 at 2:34:21 PM •••

What kind of mundane animal is the four-legged shark the equivalent of?

MrStranger616 Since: Feb, 2020
Jan 10th 2021 at 6:53:39 PM •••

I dunno, a normal shark and a crocodile! And the seagulls in the same dimension of three eyes.

Snicka Since: Jun, 2011
Jan 11th 2021 at 2:33:18 AM •••

The trope is not that "weird fantasy animals appear in a work", it's "fantasy animals are treated as the exact equivalent of mundane animals".

MrStranger616 Since: Feb, 2020
Jan 20th 2021 at 1:11:05 PM •••

Well they're still weird! And aren't unicorns usually treat as an equivalent to horses?

Snicka Since: Jun, 2011
Jan 20th 2021 at 10:43:27 PM •••

It depends. Do they show unicorns being ridden by people? Do they show horse-like behaviour like bucking or whinnying? If they do, they are the equivalents of horses. If they are, say, mystical sages spouting wisdom instead, then they are not.

MrStranger616 Since: Feb, 2020
Feb 1st 2021 at 2:04:40 PM •••

Hey, the page says doesn't always have to have a real life counterpart to qualify! Read the page before commenting! Also, why wouldn't unicorns do that? Even if they are sages, they could still do that as a FurryReminder.

Edited by MrStranger616
Snicka Since: Jun, 2011
Feb 2nd 2021 at 4:17:06 AM •••

...Dude, I launched this trope and wrote the description, so believe me that I know what I am talking about. The trope is not "Fantastic Fauna", it's "Fantastic Fauna Counterpart". The page says "To qualify for this trope, it is not a requirement for every species in the setting to have a real-world counterpart [...] As long as there is at least one species that plays the role of an obviously different real-life species, it counts". It does not say that "to qualify, the species does not necessarily have to have a real-life counterpart" - quite contrary.

Edited by Snicka
MrStranger616 Since: Feb, 2020
Feb 4th 2021 at 10:57:12 AM •••

Okay, I'm sorry, I misunderstood. But what about three-eyed seagulls? That's an alien version of a normal animal.

Snicka Since: Jun, 2011
Feb 4th 2021 at 11:20:27 AM •••

No worries; it's not well-known who lauched which trope anyway. :)

The three-eyed gulls may be borderline examples. The real idea behind this trope is that "this show has butterflies/pterodactyls/dragons/etc. that live by the sea and make gull-like screeches, making them the counterparts of seagulls".

MrStranger616 Since: Feb, 2020
Aug 20th 2021 at 9:16:57 PM •••

I understand. Weird, or alternate animals filling the roles of normal ones. Although, reptiles and insects are the last things I think of when thinking of seagulls. Half the time it might usually be cases of Call a Rabbit a "Smeerp" or vice versa.

MrStranger616 Since: Feb, 2020
Feb 1st 2021 at 2:02:04 PM •••

Do mythical creatures that turn out to be garbled descriptions of real animals count?

MrStranger616 Since: Feb, 2020
Jan 10th 2021 at 7:03:28 PM •••

Might be subject to "Binomium ridiculus"

Unnerving_Posterior Since: Feb, 2019
Aug 1st 2019 at 8:38:21 AM •••

Can we get a screenshot of the dog-like worms from Spongebob?

Hide / Show Replies
Snicka Since: Jun, 2011
Aug 1st 2019 at 10:05:21 AM •••

I haven't watched Spongebob, but Mr. Doodles is an example.

EDIT: the link is broken, but look him up.

Edited by Snicka
MrStranger616 Since: Feb, 2020
Top