Discussion Main / DependingOnTheWriter

Linking to a past Trope Repair Shop thread that dealt with this page: Definition Problem, started by Ghilz on Apr 27th 2011 at 1:09:37 AM

Changes in no particular order:

• Jenny Everywhere moved to Web Original subpage
• Nuzlocke Comics moved to Web Comics folder
• Jungle Cruise moved to Theme Park folder
• Uncle Sam entry wasn't an example, that's interpretation by the viewers.
• "This creative writing assignment" violates Weblinks Are Not Examples, and was commented out pending someone providing context. The subpoint about the Dave Barry book should also be its own bullet point on the Literature subpage, with additional context so it can stand as its own example instead of a subpoint (which breaks indentation, anyway).

Can we turn the folders into their own pages with links?

The Steven Universe entry in Western Animation looks like extremely unprofessional complaining and something that belongs in YMMV. I know that a lot of Reddit users have this "uh lapis has no personality" mentality, but I don't think that what the entry says about Lapis is in any way objective or cut-clear. I've seen lenghty posts advocating tha Lapis' chracater is well writen, after all.

We no longer use "Type X" as example format here. Please edit this entry to remove said format.

• Conan The Barbarian is always an Anti-Hero, but what kind of anti hero very much depends on the Author. Howard himself wrote him mostly as a Type IV, subsequent authors as anywhere from Type II to Type V, the Marvel Comics mostly as a Type II and the Movies as a Type III while the cartoon Conan The Adventurer had him as a straight hero.

In the Exalted entry: "Word Of God has since cleared up what the creators intended to get across, but it's still a hotly-debated subject. " Shouldn't we say what that actually was? I know we have a "don't complain about it- edit" policy, but I (obviously) don't know what "it" ended up being. So I'd be grateful (in the very limited internet way) if someone could fill it in. Thank you.