Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Manga / SoulEater

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
* Not sure how ThisTroper feels about this series now. I really fell in love with Daikichi\'s and Rin\'s dynamic as a ParentalSubstitute Manchild and a mature-but-still-a-kid {{Kuudere}} little girl, so the idea that that is sort of twisted out sideways by the end is... well, difficult to process, not alone accept. [[spoiler: I mean, yes, she isn\'t his \'\'actual blooded\'\' daughter, but at the same time, she\'s still his blood-relative being his \'\'\'\'\'aunt\'\'\'\'\'! Now, don\'t get me wrong: incestuous relationships don\'t {{Squick}} me per se, but it largely depends on the context, age gap, if there is one, and the characters\' relationship structure. [[OuranHighSchoolHostClub Hikaru and Kaoru\'s]] Twincest is mostly played for laughs, while [[{{Saiyuki}} Cho Hakkai falling for his sister]] is played straight but also \'\'acknowledged\'\' as being potentially creepy in other peoples\' eyes. The whole [[MayDecemberRomance 24 year age difference]] with the aforementioned pair is another tricky factor to consider.]]
to:
* Not sure how ThisTroper feels about this series now. I really fell in love with Daikichi\\\'s and Rin\\\'s dynamic as a ParentalSubstitute Manchild and a mature-but-still-a-kid {{Kuudere}} little girl, so the idea that that is sort of twisted out sideways by the end is... well, difficult to process, not alone accept. [[spoiler: I mean, yes, she isn\\\'t his \\\'\\\'actual blooded\\\'\\\' daughter, but at the same time, she\\\'s still his blood-relative since she\\\'s his \\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'aunt\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'! Now, don\\\'t get me wrong: incestuous relationships don\\\'t {{Squick}} me per se, but it largely depends on the context, age gap, if there is one, and the characters\\\' relationship structure. [[OuranHighSchoolHostClub Hikaru and Kaoru\\\'s]] {{Twincest}} is mostly played for laughs, while [[{{Saiyuki}} Cho Hakkai falling for his sister]] is played straight but also \\\'\\\'acknowledged\\\'\\\' as being potentially creepy in other peoples\\\' eyes. The whole [[MayDecemberRomance 24 year age difference]] with the aforementioned pair is another tricky factor to consider.]]
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
* Not sure how ThisTroper feels about this series now. I really fell in love with Daikichi\'s and Rin\'s dynamic as a ParentalSubstitute Manchild and a mature-but-still-a-kid {{Kuudere}} little girl, so the idea that that is sort of twisted out sideways by the end is... well, difficult to process, not alone accept. [[spoiler\
to:
* Not sure how ThisTroper feels about this series now. I really fell in love with Daikichi\\\'s and Rin\\\'s dynamic as a ParentalSubstitute Manchild and a mature-but-still-a-kid {{Kuudere}} little girl, so the idea that that is sort of twisted out sideways by the end is... well, difficult to process, not alone accept. [[spoiler: I mean, yes, she isn\\\'t his \\\'\\\'actual blooded\\\'\\\' daughter, but at the same time, she\\\'s still his blood-relative being his \\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'aunt\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'! Now, don\\\'t get me wrong: incestuous relationships don\\\'t {{Squick}} me per se, but it largely depends on the context, age gap, if there is one, and the characters\\\' relationship structure. [[OuranHighSchoolHostClub Hikaru and Kaoru\\\'s]] Twincest is mostly played for laughs, while [[{{Saiyuki}} Cho Hakkai falling for his sister]] is played straight but also \\\'\\\'acknowledged\\\'\\\' as being potentially creepy in other peoples\\\' eyes. The whole [[MayDecemberRomance 24 year age difference]] with the aforementioned pair is another tricky factor to consider.]]

From what I\\\'ve seen, the fandom is largely divided about the ending. I was wondering: Is there anyone whose found a satisfying middle-ground?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
* Not sure how ThisTroper feels about this series now. I really fell in love with Daikichi\'s and Rin\'s dynamic as a ParentalSubstitute Manchild and a mature-but-still-a-kid {{Kuudere}} little girl, so the idea that that is sort of twisted out sideways by the end is... well, difficult to process, not alone accept. I mean, yes, she isn\'t his \'\'actual blooded\'\' daughter, but at the same time, she\'s still his blood-relative being his \'\'\'\'\'aunt\'\'\'\'\'!
to:
* Not sure how ThisTroper feels about this series now. I really fell in love with Daikichi\\\'s and Rin\\\'s dynamic as a ParentalSubstitute Manchild and a mature-but-still-a-kid {{Kuudere}} little girl, so the idea that that is sort of twisted out sideways by the end is... well, difficult to process, not alone accept. [[spoiler\\\" I mean, yes, she isn\\\'t his \\\'\\\'actual blooded\\\'\\\' daughter, but at the same time, she\\\'s still his blood-relative being his \\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'aunt\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'! Now, don\\\'t get me wrong: incestuous relationships don\\\'t {{Squick}} me per se, but it largely depends on the context, age gap, if there is one, and the characters\\\' relationship structure. [[OuranHighSchoolHostClub Hikaru and Kaoru\\\'s]] Twincest is mostly played for laughs, while [[{{Saiyuki}} Cho Hakkai falling for his sister]] is played straight but also \\\'\\\'acknowledged\\\'\\\' as being potentially creepy in other peoples\\\' eyes. The whole [[MayDecemberRomance 24 year age difference]] with the aforementioned pair is another tricky factor to consider.]]
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
Now, don\'t get me wrong: incestuous relationships don\'t {{Squick}} me per se, but it largely depends on the context, age gap, if there is one, and the characters\' relationship structure. [[OuranHighSchoolHostClub Hikaru and Kaoru\'s]] Twincest is mostly played for laughs, while [[{{Saiyuki}} Cho Hakkai falling for his sister]] is played straight but also \'\'acknowledged\'\' as being potentially creepy in other peoples\' eyes. The whole [[MayDecemberRomance 24 year age difference]] with the aforementioned pair is another tricky factor to consider.
to:
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
* Not sure how ThisTroper feels about this series now. [[spoiler: I really fell in love with Daikichi\'s and Rin\'s dynamic as a ParentalSubstitute Manchild and a mature-but-still-a-kid {{Kuudere}} little girl, so the idea that that is sort of twisted out sideways by the end is... well, difficult to process, not alone accept. I mean, yes, she isn\'t his \'\'actual blooded\'\' daughter, but at the same time, she\'s still his blood-relative being his \'\'\'\'\'aunt\'\'\'\'\'!
to:
* Not sure how ThisTroper feels about this series now. I really fell in love with Daikichi\\\'s and Rin\\\'s dynamic as a ParentalSubstitute Manchild and a mature-but-still-a-kid {{Kuudere}} little girl, so the idea that that is sort of twisted out sideways by the end is... well, difficult to process, not alone accept. I mean, yes, she isn\\\'t his \\\'\\\'actual blooded\\\'\\\' daughter, but at the same time, she\\\'s still his blood-relative being his \\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'aunt\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'!
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
Now, don\'t get me wrong: incestuous relationships don\'t {{Squick}} me per se, but it largely depends on the context, age gap, if there is one, and the characters\' relationship structure. [[OuranHighSchoolHostClub Hikaru and Kaoru\'s]] Twincest is mostly played for laughs, while [[{{Saiyuki}} Cho Hakkai falling for his sister]] is played straight but also \'\'acknowledged\'\' as being potentially creepy in other peoples\' eyes. The whole [[MayDecemberRomance 24 year age difference]] with the aforementioned pair is another tricky factor to consider.]]
to:
Now, don\\\'t get me wrong: incestuous relationships don\\\'t {{Squick}} me per se, but it largely depends on the context, age gap, if there is one, and the characters\\\' relationship structure. [[OuranHighSchoolHostClub Hikaru and Kaoru\\\'s]] Twincest is mostly played for laughs, while [[{{Saiyuki}} Cho Hakkai falling for his sister]] is played straight but also \\\'\\\'acknowledged\\\'\\\' as being potentially creepy in other peoples\\\' eyes. The whole [[MayDecemberRomance 24 year age difference]] with the aforementioned pair is another tricky factor to consider.
Top