Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / NoEndorHolocaust

Go To

[016] SYLOH Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Should we rename this trope \
to:
Should we rename this trope \\\"Endor Holocaust Denial\\\"?
After all, something that says that there was No Holocaust is a \\\"Holocaust Denial\\\"
Something that says there was No Endor Holocaust should be an \\\"Endor Holocaust Denial\\\"
Wordplay, People!
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Should we rename this trope \
to:
Should we rename this trope \\\"Endor Holocaust Denial\\\"
After all, something that says that there was No Holocaust is a \\\"Holocaust Denial\\\"
Something that says there was No Endor Holocaust should be an \\\"Endor Holocaust Denial\\\"
Wordplay, People!
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Should we rename this trope \
to:
Should we rename this trope \\\"Endor Holocaust Denial\\\"
After all, something that says that there was no Holocaust is a \\\"Holocaust Denial\\\"
Something that says there was No Endor Holocaust should be an \\\"Endor Holocaust Denial\\\"
Wordplay, People!
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The additional first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that section back in from \
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The additional first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from \\\"The classic... to ...goodbyes\\\" if you have no problem with that.

+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article, so that section mentioned above does not split them up.

+ I\\\'ll add the laconic definition as you suggested.

->[+~ I mentioned the MillionToOneChance sentence was a bit of a thesis / editorial gloss / lighthearted analysis and not central to the trope definition, so that sentence can be left out for now and rephrased later.+]

->[+~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case now.+]

->[+~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over this.+]

->[+x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore only applies when capture is involved, so it doesn\\\'t really have to be listed here.+]

->[+~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be an inversion. Not willing to fight over this sentence.+]
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The additional first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that section back in from \
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The additional first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from \\\"The classic... to ...goodbyes\\\" if you have no problem with that.

+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article, so that section mentioned above does not split them up.

+ I\\\'ll add the laconic definition as you suggested.

->[+~ I mentioned the MillionToOneChance sentence was a bit of a thesis / editorial gloss / lighthearted analysis and not central to the trope definition, so that sentence can be left out for now and rephrased later.+]

->[+~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case now.+]

->[+~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over this.+]

->[+x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore only applies when death traps are involved, so it doesn\\\'t really need to be listed here.+]

->[+~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be an inversion. Not willing to fight over this sentence.+]
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The additional first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that section back in from \
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The additional first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from \\\"The classic... to ...goodbyes\\\" if you have no problem with that.

+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article, so that section mentioned above does not split them up.

+ I\\\'ll add the laconic definition as you suggested.

->[+~ I mentioned the MillionToOneChance sentence was a bit of a thesis / editorial gloss / lighthearted analysis and not central to the trope definition, so that sentence can be left out for now and rephrased later.+]

->[+~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case now.+]

->[+~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over this.+]

->[+x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore usually applies to this trope by default, so it doesn\\\'t really need to be listed here.+]

->[+~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be an inversion. Not willing to fight over this sentence.+]
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The additional first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that section back in from \
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The additional first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from \\\"The classic... to ...goodbyes\\\" if you have no problem with that.

+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article, so that section mentioned above does not split them up.

+ I\\\'ll add the laconic definition as you suggested.

->[+~ I mentioned the MillionToOneChance sentence was a bit of a thesis / editorial gloss / lighthearted analysis and not central to the trope definition, so that sentence can be left out for now and rephrased later.+]

->[+~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case here.+]

->[+~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over this.+]

->[+x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore usually applies to this trope by default, so it doesn\\\'t really need to be listed here.+]

->[+~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be an inversion. Not willing to fight over this sentence.+]
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The additional first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that section back in from \
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The additional first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from \\\"The classic... to ...goodbyes\\\" if you have no problem with that.

+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article, so that section mentioned above does not split them up.

+ I\\\'ll add the laconic definition as you suggested.

->[+~ I mentioned the MillionToOneChance sentence was a bit of a thesis / editorial gloss / lighthearted analysis and not central to the trope definition, so that sentence can be left out for now or rephrased later.+]

->[+~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case here.+]

->[+~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over this.+]

->[+x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore usually applies to this trope by default, so it doesn\\\'t really need to be listed here.+]

->[+~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be an inversion. Not willing to fight over this sentence.+]
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that section back in from \
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The additional first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from \\\"The classic... to ...goodbyes\\\" if you have no problem with that.

+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article, so that section mentioned above does not split them up.

+ I\\\'ll add the laconic definition as you suggested.

->[+~ I mentioned the MillionToOneChance sentence was a bit of a thesis / editorial gloss / lighthearted analysis and not central to the trope definition, so that sentence can be left out for now or changed.+]

->[+~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case here.+]

->[+~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over this.+]

->[+x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore usually applies to this trope by default, so it doesn\\\'t really need to be listed here.+]

->[+~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be an inversion. Not willing to fight over this sentence.+]
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that section back in from \
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from \\\"The classic... to ...goodbyes\\\" if you have no problem with that.

+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article, so that section mentioned above does not split them up.

+ I\\\'ll add the laconic definition as you suggested.

->[+~ I mentioned the MillionToOneChance sentence was a bit of a thesis / editorial gloss / lighthearted analysis and not central to the trope definition, so that sentence can be left out for now or changed.+]

->[+~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case here.+]

->[+~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over this.+]

->[+x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore usually applies to this trope by default, so it doesn\\\'t really need to be listed here.+]

->[+~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be an inversion. Not willing to fight over this sentence.+]
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that section back in from \
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from \\\"The classic... to ...goodbyes\\\" if you have no problem with that.

+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article, so that section mentioned above does not split them up.

->[+~ I mentioned the MillionToOneChance sentence was a bit of a thesis / editorial gloss / lighthearted analysis and not central to the trope definition, so that sentence can be left out for now or changed.+]

->[+~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case here.+]

->[+~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over this.+]

->[+x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore usually applies to this trope by default, so it doesn\\\'t really need to be listed here.+]

->[+~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be an inversion. Not willing to fight over this sentence.+]
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that section back in from \
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from \\\"The classic... to ...goodbyes\\\" if you have no problem with that.

+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article, so that section mentioned above does not split them up.

->[+~ I mentioned the MillionToOneChance sentence was a bit of a thesis / editorial gloss / lighthearted analysis and not central to the trope definition, so that sentence can be left out for now or changed.+]

->[+~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case here.+]

->[+~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over it.+]

->[+x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore usually applies to this trope by default, so it doesn\\\'t really need to be listed here.+]

->[+~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be an inversion. Not willing to fight over this sentence.+]
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that section back in from \
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from \\\"The classic... to ...goodbyes\\\" if you have no problem with that.

+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article, so that the section mentioend above does not split them up.

~ I mentioned the MillionToOneChance sentence was a bit of a thesis / editorial gloss / lighthearted analysis and not central to the trope definition, so that sentence can be left out for now or changed.

~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case here.

~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over it.

x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore usually applies to this trope by default, so it doesn\\\'t really need to be listed here.

~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be the inverse. Not willing to fight over this sentence.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that section back in from \
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from \\\"The classic... to ...goodbyes\\\" if that\\\'s OK.

+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article, so that the above paragraph does not split them up.

~ I mentioned the MillionToOneChance sentence was a bit of a thesis / editorial gloss / lighthearted analysis and not central to the trope definition, so that sentence can be left out for now or changed.

~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case here.

~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over it.

x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore usually applies to this trope by default, so it doesn\\\'t really need to be listed here.

~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be the inverse. Not willing to fight over this sentence.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that section back in from if that\'s OK.
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from \\\"The classic... to ...goodbyes\\\" if that\\\'s OK.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article.
to:
+ we move the PrepareToDie explanation to the same spot as the other disambigs, or put all disambigs down near the bottom of the article, so that the above paragraph does not split them up.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
~ I don\'t care if the \
to:
~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case here.

~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over it.

x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore usually applies to this trope by default, so it doesn\\\'t really need to be listed here.

~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be the inverse. Not willing to fight over this sentence.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\'ll put that paragraph back in if that\'s OK.
to:
+ No problems with the paragraph describing various ways the trope can be invoked. The new first paragraph you added should remove any confusion on the description. I\\\'ll put that section back in from if that\\\'s OK.
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
~ I don\'t care if the \
to:
~ I don\\\'t care if the \\\"named after\\\" sentence is included. Those are useful in tropes with long example sections, which isn\\\'t the case here.

~ TakeYourTime applies if the villain issues the threat without the hero in custody and the hero is then able to proceed on his or her course without any corrections. But I won\\\'t fight over it.

x BondVillainStupidity is basically \\\"villain puts the hero in a trap of some sort and walks away without checking.\\\" That trope is universal for all death trap situations and therefore usually applies to this trope by default, so it doesn\\\'t really need to be listed here.

~ I would tend to think YouWillBeSpared is an aversion of the trope, whereas the villain stating that he doesn\\\'t plan on surviving the hero\\\'s demise (ThanatosGambit) would be the inverse. Not willing to fight over this sentence.
Top