Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / FourTemperamentEnsemble

Go To

[002] StarformDCX Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
to:
As pointed out in one of the older entries on the the discussion page, a lot of the stuff on this page is from non-serial works, and therefore cannot contain characters being written \\\"out of character\\\" or \\\"holding the idiot ball\\\'\\\'. Also, the trope in its description is explicitly negative, which seems like it should be YMMV, if not Darth Wiki. To make the page comply with its own description, a lot of examples will have to be cut. In its current form, this page is AuthorTract, but [[TheSameButMoreSpecific treated as always a bad thing]].

Personally, I find it absurd to treat all instances of a story having a political/social message as a bad thing (which is what this page in its current form largely does, given the number of non-serial examples). A lot of these works are read in large part because of these messages.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
to:
As pointed out in one of the older entries on the the discussion page, a lot of the stuff on this page is from non-serial works, and therefore cannot contain characters being written \\\"out of character\\\" or \\\"holding the idiot ball\\\'\\\'. Also, the trope in its description is explicitly negative, which seems like it should be YMMV, if not Darth Wiki. To make the page comply with its own description, a lot of examples will have to be cut

Personally, I find it absurd to treat all instances of a story having a political/social message as a bad thing (which is what this page in its current form largely does, given the number of non-serial examples). A lot of these works are read in large part because of these messages.
Top