[001]
Harrowing
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Then we should probably remove it from Yukari's character profile on the Persona 3 page as well: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Characters/Persona3SEES
to:
Then we should probably remove it from Yukari\'s character profile on the Persona 3 page as well: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Characters/Persona3SEES
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
Basically, I'm trying to look at it without looking at confidant/social link stories or outside materials, which usually differ from the game and from one another--there's every chance a Persona 5 anime will do things differently from the manga, for example, just like what happened with Persona 3 and 4's manga and anime adaptations. In-game in Persona 5, Makoto gets several classic
to:
Basically, I\'m trying to look at it without looking at confidant/social link stories or outside materials, which usually differ from the game and from one another--there\'s every chance a Persona 5 anime will do things differently from the manga, for example, just like what happened with Persona 3 and 4\'s manga and anime adaptations. In-game in Persona 5, Makoto gets several classic \"anime romantic comedy\" moments with the protagonist; Ann really doesn\'t. Sojiro does ask her if she\'s single on the protagonist\'s behalf, but that\'s about it. (I mean, part of that could just be down to Ann not really having a ton to do in the story after Makoto is introduced, so I could see an argument that Makoto has those scenes just because she gets more screen time than the others.)
But I\'m having a hard time seeing your argument here that Makoto has no romantic scenes outside of her confidant. Sure, she has no scenes where she directly expresses a romantic interest in the protagonist, but neither did Yukari. She does, however, have scenes that, were this an anime, would look like they were teasing an eventual romantic pairing. That\'s my whole point: I think you might be looking at things too literally and relying too much on a non-canon, non-game adaptation.
But I\'m having a hard time seeing your argument here that Makoto has no romantic scenes outside of her confidant. Sure, she has no scenes where she directly expresses a romantic interest in the protagonist, but neither did Yukari. She does, however, have scenes that, were this an anime, would look like they were teasing an eventual romantic pairing. That\'s my whole point: I think you might be looking at things too literally and relying too much on a non-canon, non-game adaptation.
