YMMV / Silent Library

• Hilarious in Hindsight: When Jimmy Fallon and the Roots appear, one familiar face who couldn't make it is keyboard meister James - who ends up going through something very similar when they do "Thank-You Notes", and Jimmy goads him into corpsing every single time.
• Just Here for Godzilla: Celebrity appearances drive much of the nostalgia for the show, with the most popular official episode uploads on YouTube being for WWE wrestlers, Jimmy Fallon and the Roots, and the Jersey Shore cast. Much of the press in 2020 for the official episode uploads focus on the rock acts featured on the show like All Time Low. The actual format still has its fans, with various YouTubers like the Sidemen putting on their own version of the show.
• Unintentional Period Piece: For the MTV version: Having peak Bieber Fever Justin Bieber, the cast of Jersey Shore, and of the era sports and wrestling stars on the show already puts the show firmly in the 2010s. But even more so is the sheer amount of 2010s pop punk and "neon pop" acts like All Time Low, 3OH!3, Never Shout Never, The Ready Set, Hey Monday (featuring future season 3 winner of The Voice Cassadee Pope), Forever the Sickest Kids, and more.