YMMV / Scooby-Doo (2002)

• Alas, Poor Scrappy: Even ardent haters of Scrappy have noted that he comes off as Unintentionally Sympathetic when ousted from Mystery Inc. and further criticized just how mean-spirited the film's vilification of him is.
• Ass Pull: The revelation that Scrappy is the main villain. Not a bad idea for a twist in of itself, especially since Scrappy’s status as a hated character would make it rather fitting. The problem is that it comes right out of nowhere. The movie never explains how Scrappy acquired the resources and the technological and magical knowledge to operate such a complicated con, with him somehow building a human-like robot that manages to trick everyone in the cast and getting ahold of an ancient demonic artifact able to absorb human souls and power-up the holder. This isn't even getting into how exactly did he get back to civilization after being abandoned in the desert.
• Base-Breaking Character: Fred. Similar to the other characters, he's made into a much bigger jerk, with it hard to find his narcissism all that charming when he's the least useful member of the team. Additionally, Freddie Prinze Jr. is typically seen as the most questionable casting choice of this adaptation's Mystery Inc. However, he does have his fans who find his egotism over the top to the point of being hilarious. Also, despite the admittedly questionable casting, his overall performance was actually good. The fact that the majority of the movie's funniest scenes involve him in some way earned him some favor.
• Big-Lipped Alligator Moment: A cut scene had Velma get drunk from a tiki drink and then break out into song atop a piano, serenading (presumably both her crushes) Fred and Daphne with "Can't Take My Eyes Off of You" for no reason.
• Broken Base: The film's depiction and treatment of Scrappy-Doo. If you never liked the character, his portrayal as a villain and being defeated by Mystery, Inc., in the end, is a very satisfying Take That, Scrappy! scenario. If you're one of the characters' fans (or even some of his haters), you'll likely find it off-putting to see his negative qualities ramped up and the way he's treated by Scooby and the others in the flashback scene coming off as blatantly out-of-character, in addition to the dubiousness of Scrappy wanting to kill his uncle when the cartoons clearly showed him as thinking his uncle is the best thing since sliced bread. And if you belong to a third, admittedly smaller group, the entire thing just Crosses the Line Twice and it's impossible not to laugh at how stupid it is.
• Cant Unhear It: For fans of this film and the second one, they tend to hear Sarah Michelle Gellar as Daphne, Neil Fanning as Scooby-Doo, Freddie Prinze Jr. as Fred and Linda Cardellini as Velma. Shaggy's actor Matthew Lillard is a definitive example because he got to voice Shaggy in the cartoons after Casey Kasem retired from the role.
• Crosses the Line Twice:
  • Shaggy and Scooby's out-of-nowhere burping and farting contest. So juvenile, so unnecessary... but so funny!
  • For a small portion of the fanbase, Scrappy's Flanderized obnoxiousness and the revelation he was the villain came across as so ridiculously over the top it became hilarious.
• Cult Classic: Though it received mixed reviews from fans and critics alike, it's loved in its own right by fans of early 2000s pop culture.
• Demographically Inappropriate Humor: Given that the film was originally meant to be a lot more adult-oriented before being retooled to the more family-friendly PG, there are still some suggestive jokes in the final cut.
  • Shaggy mentions, "But you don't need to know what Voulez-vous coucher avec moi? means to love that song!" — in French, that phrase translates to "Do you want to sleep with me?"
  • Daphne heavily implies that the Luna Ghost kept trying to grope her.
  • In an early scene, Scooby and Shaggy are hanging out at a beach in their van, laughing, whilst smoke comes out of the van's roof. It turns out they're really just making eggplant burgers, but the burgers in question feature some rather unusual condiments including chocolate and hot sauce. To add to the stoner references, "Pass the Dutchie" is blaring in the background.
  • Fred explains to Velma that he is a man of substance and "dorky chicks like [Velma] turn [Fred] on".
  • When Mary Jane introduces herself, Shaggy says "Like, that's my favorite name!", referencing how Mary Jane is sometimes used as a nickname for marijuana.
  • Right before the gang kicks Scrappy out of the group, he outright tells Fred, "You don't have the scrote for this job, Pally!"
  • Velma got drunk after she had too much of a tiki drink while talking to Brad about Scrappy getting kicked out.
  • When Fred switches bodies with Daphne, he states "Hey... I can look at myself naked!", and immediately afterwards, he looks down the front of her dress and grins. Later, Fred-in-Daphne's-body can be seen in the background groping her own body, and Shaggy-in-Velma's body can be seen trying to look up her own skirt.
  • Fred's soul told Shaggy that someone spiked his root beer last night and wanted to be talked down.
  • In a scene from a trailer, Fred asks Scooby/actually Scrappy "Did somebody spike your dog bowl?"
• Designated Hero: Fred, Shaggy, Daphne, Velma, and Scooby are pretty unlikable in this movie due to getting hit with Adaptational Jerkass. When Fred, Daphne, and Velma spend much of the movie bickering, Shaggy suggests letting Fred and Velma get eaten after they're abducted by monsters, and the gang (in a flashback) casually abandons Scrappy in the middle of the desert where he could have easily died (yeah, he did pee on Daphne and act annoying, but that was still uncalled for), it's hard to feel anything but contempt for them.
• Director Displacement: Many people thought of this as a James Gunn film rather than a Raja Gosnell film because of the writer's far more prolific career in recent years.
• Ensemble Dark Horse:
  • The Luna Ghost. He's a Starter Villain who has less than five minutes of screen time, but his cool design and "powers" make him quite memorable, and he'd be right at home among villains from cartoons. He eventually made an appearance in Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated as one of the Crystal Cove Spook Museum's costumes.
  • Melvin Doo, the only other guy on Spooky Island that shares a surname with Scooby and returns as a Brick Joke, ended up finding popularity on TikTok for his gag appearance.
• Fan Nickname: A lot of fans call this film "Scooby-Doo: Spooky Island" to help differentiate itself from the actual franchise.
• Fan-Preferred Cut Content: James Gunn's original script was much more faithful to the original cartoon. It also served as an origin story for how the gang met, complete with Gunn's trademark offbeat humor. There are also deleted scenes showing Daphne encountering a possessed Velma, and Shaggy witnessing Daphne's soul getting extracted too that explain oddities in the finished film — after the former, Daphne just leaves a locker room looking panicked, and the latter has Shaggy inexplicably knowing to find Daphne's soul in the vat too.
• Friendly Fandoms: It has one with Kangaroo Jack and Osmosis Jones for being WB films that were retooled from adult-oriented films to family-friendly ones.
• He Really Can Act: Matthew Lillard's performance as Shaggy has been heavily praised by critics and the audience for nailing the character so much that he was chosen to be Casey Kasem's successor for the cartoons.
• It's the Same, Now It Sucks!: A chief complaint amongst older fans of the franchise is that the basic premise of the film recycles several elements from the 1998 Scooby-Doo on Zombie Island: A disbanded Mystery Inc. is brought together to solve a new mystery, the heroes are lured to a mysterious island by a character with ulterior motives, and the Big Bad's plan involves draining the soul/life out of their victims. The live-action adaptation also lifts a few jokes directly from the older film, such as Shaggy and Scooby having an exaggerated reaction upon eating peppers, or a protagonist pulling a monster's face in ridiculous ways before realizing that it's not a mask.
• It Was His Sled: Scrappy-Doo being the villain is the most well-known aspect of the film since its release.
• Jerkass Woobie: Scrappy is an obnoxious twerp who has a big ego, but he's such a hated character that you just wanna hug him at times. And despite him being the villain, he was left to die in the desert by Scooby and the rest of the gang, and a few viewers did want to see him be a hero again. It doesn't help that he never appeared again after the movie, and some fans of the series really do miss him.
• Just Here for Godzilla: Even people who hate this film have admitted that Matthew Lillard was perfectly cast as Shaggy.
• Memetic Molester: The Luna Ghost because it is heavily implied that he groped Daphne.
• Nightmare Retardant: Scrappy-Doo in his giant One-Winged Angel form looks scary enough, but his voice sounds a little less like a giant monster and more like a teenage bully trying too hard to sound intimidating. And when he's defeated, he lets out a high-pitched scream even before he shrinks down to his normal size.
• One-Scene Wonder: Voodoo Maestro only appears in two scenes, but his presence is fondly remembered for being a hilarious Cuckoosnarker and his funny dynamic with Daphne.
• Older Than They Think:
  • Some reviewers claimed that, given how the villain Scrappy Doo uses an amulet to become an One-Winged Angel, this is the first Scooby-Doo story in which the main villain actually has supernatural powers, even though Scooby-Doo on Zombie Island already featured that five years prior. And even then, it was done previously in the 80s with The 13 Ghosts of Scooby-Doo and some of the TV movies from that time.
  • Plenty of reviews talk about how fresh, surprising, and unprecedented Daphne's transformation into a martial artist is. Scooby-Doo and the Cyber Chase introduced that aspect of her character a whole year earlier, albeit only in a single scene.
• One True Threesome: Fans prefer to ship Fred/Daphne/Velma all together as a "throuple" in fanfiction due to the actor's chemistry and some Les Yay between Daphne and Velma.
• Retroactive Recognition: Isla Fisher as Mary Jane.
• Rooting for the Empire: Due to the Scooby Gang abandoning Scrappy in the middle of the desert for merely being a nuisance, and due to the Gang being bigger Jerkasses than before, there were a good number of viewers hoping Scrappy defeated the Gang and got his revenge.
• Special Effects Failure: Even in 2002, computer graphics weren't quite there in rendering a cartoony character like Scooby in live action, and could only go as far as giving his exaggerated design hyper-realistic features. Even for an $80 million feature film, all of the CGI characters look more like something out of a PS1 game. To give one an idea of just how much technology has advanced since, the two made-for-TV prequels, released towards the end of the decade, had better CGI.
• Squick:
  • Scooby making Scrappy sneeze and get covered in his snot.
  • Also, this comment from Fred when he winds up in Daphne's body:
  "Heeeeeeeeeeeeey... I can look at myself nakeeeeeeeeeeeeeeed!"
  • Scrappy peeing on Daphne.
• Strangled by the Red String: Despite a few token gestures, Fred and Daphne's romantic relationship really only amounts to just a few...moments. It's clearly based on the fan speculation that they were an item in the original cartoons, but it's barely more developed than that mere Fanon. Aside from Velma's (possibly drunk) recollection of the two sitting next to each other looking romantic-like, Fred openly lusting after Daphne when he switches bodies with her, and them sharing a rather abrupt kiss which ends just as abruptly, Fred and Daphne's romantic chemistry is rather... nonexistent, to put a word on it.
• Suspiciously Similar Song: "Bump In The Night" sounds like a carbon copy of Michael Jackson's "Thriller."
• Take That, Scrappy!: For Scrappy haters, this film is actually very satisfying and cathartic to watch.
• Took the Bad Film Seriously: The actors, especially Matthew Lillard, clearly commit to the film's goofy aesthetic, and their dedication makes it all the funnier.
• Uncertain Audience: The film is intended to be an Affectionate Parody of the franchise, but it takes a lot of liberties with the personalities of the characters, either making them into something they aren't (Fred is a narcissistic jock, Daphne is a ditzy valley girl) or emphasizing their negative traits (Velma is a slightly smug know-it-all, Shaggy is more cowardly and gluttonous than ever). This odd mix of Flanderization and Took a Level in Jerkass makes it seem like the filmmakers didn't understand the source material and thus didn't know how to make fun of it well. For younger fans who didn't watch the cartoons, they'll be lost by the film's continuity nods to the cartoons and the characters being jaded and bitter after years of working together, and older fans will recognize the problems with the characterization and story and be turned off by them. And either way, the franchise was almost always about fake monsters, here the group ends up fighting real monsters.
• Unexpected Character: Scrappy-Doo's appearance was quite a surprise to viewers and fans given the franchise had pretty much ignored up to this point. Him turning out to be the villain was even more of a shock.
• Unintentionally Sympathetic: Regardless of how one might feel about Scrappy as a character, you can't blame him for wanting to kill Mystery Inc. after they abandoned him in the middle of nowhere just for being a minor nuisance. If they really wanted to be rid of him, they could've just waited until they got back to civilization.
• Unintentionally Unsympathetic:
  • The gang just abandon Scrappy in the middle of the desert. Annoying as he could be, the others always considered him part of the gang. Especially in Scooby's case, considering they're family. Not only is this grossly out of character for all involved, it comes back to bite them in the arse later.
  • In general, the gang comes across as rather unsympathetic here due to being Adaptational Jerkasses. One rather blatant example is when Shaggy, after Fred and Velma are captured by monsters, replies to Daphne's announcement that they're going to save them by suggesting that he, Daphne, and Scooby make a break for it and let them get eaten. Cartoon Shaggy might be a coward, but he's not the type of character that would abandon his friends. He doesn’t go through with it, but still.
  • Nobody is giving live-action Scrappy a pass for peeing on poor Daphne, but the fact that Fred is the one calling him out of that (and is later) shown happily groping Daphne as soon as he has the opportunity (and doesn't show any remorse over it, even when she's clearly upset and demanding that he stop) makes Fred come off as a severe hypocrite who actually agreed that Daphne was territory...and was angry because he wanted Daphne to be his territory.
• Viewer Name Confusion: Some people who don't know much about the cartoon think Velma's name is Thelma.
• Vindicated by History: The movie was initially panned when it first came out, but after Matthew Lillard took on the role of Shaggy, the hatred died down considerably, as people came to agree that whatever faults lied in the direction and characterizations, the movie had a considerable amount of genuinely hilarious moments, and the casting and costuming choices are still among the most respected of all live-action remakes. This aspect has become a lot more appreciated since Disney bombarded the theaters with live-action remakes widely regarded as unnecessary with progressively more divisive casting decisions.
• Visual Effects of Awesome:
  • The Luna Ghost's glow is one of the few CGI effects that isn't dated at all.
  • A retroactive example. James Gunn revealed in 2017 that part of the changes made to the movie to make it more for kids was that the female stars' cleavage was digitally removed with CGI, which many people found surprising since it's pretty much unnoticeable in the film.
• What Do You Mean, It's for Kids?: A lot of the grosser jokes and sexual content in the movie make sense when you realize it was originally going to be an R-rated self-parody. The edgier content was dialed back just enough to earn it a "hard" PG. This is also why the sequel was comparatively more child friendly. It doesn't help that James Gunn is known for adult works such as Tromeo and Juliet and The Suicide Squad.

---