Follow TV Tropes

Following

YMMV / One Tree Hill S5E09 "For Tonight You’re Only Here to Know"

Go To

  • Unintentionally Unsympathetic: Lindsey, due to her fight with Peyton. At one point, Lindsey threatens Peyton by bringing up her being shot and nearly dying in the school shooting, whilst Peyton goes on to mock Lindsey for being a spoilt Daddy's Girl who just gets given whatever she wants - triggering Lindsey's trauma from her father's death. Whilst it is entirely fair to say Peyton took things too far, and the episode acknowledges this by having her apologise to Lindsey for the comments, Peyton had no prior knowledge of the matter; Lindsey, comparatively, was well aware of Peyton nearly dying in the school shooting as the incident was covered in Lucas' book - something the episode reiterates - and doesn’t apologise for her comment.

Top