YMMV / Immersion

• Nightmare Fuel:
  • A bit, in the Mario Kart episode; during Michael's second lap, Burnie and Gus notice that he's more confident this time and going faster. Then, when he turns onto the straightaway, he picks up even more speed, and Gus and Burnie start sounding a little worried, Burnie even noting that Michael is going too fast. Then, some dramatic music kicks in as Michael turns and approaches the last pile of bananas, Burnie and Gus start freaking out and motioning for him to stop... and Michael hits the bananas, spins out, and flies off the track in his kart. Thankfully, though, he's fine.
  • The Five Nights At Freddys episode, full stop. Even with the second body around, manning the controls is still a nightmare and while you're not getting stuffed into animatronics, the four are very scary. The Ursa Grimm needs no enhancements - it's already a fright in its native canon! Mr. Diddles' paper bag is all stiched up and looking very angry (and apparently bloodied). Pongo goes human size, has an eye dangling out of his head and now bares sharp teeth and the chicken...
• Squick: The Surgeon Simulator episode - blood, guts, being squirted with blood, Michael eating a stomach salad...
• They Changed It, Now It Sucks!: Not majorly but a lot of comments on the Metal Gear Solid episode were solely about how much they missed Michael and Gavin as the labrats.
• They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: The Open World arc based on Fallout. At the start, Burnie and Gus hype up how they've set up a large open world, full of NPCs and sidequests, that Gavin and Michael had to traverse through while finding hidden weapons and items. They also had to locate a transmission code that would get them into Vault 619, their ending point. And lastly, they're given twelve hours to do this. Seems like it'll be a multi-episode arc with tons of different quests... but instead, it lasts two episodes that are roughly ten minutes each, they only do one sidequest that also gives them the transmission code we thought they'd have to hunt for, they only get into two battles (three if you count the radroaches they ran away from, four if you count the ambush from Meg that they also ran from), and they only encounter four NPCs outside of battles^* Coe, McCormack, Ghoul Gus, and Barbara, the last of whom only existed to give them a way to cure their crippled limbs that they got about five seconds prior. For a test about Open World games, they seemed to be forced onto a very linear path, and the only times they had choices, they either didn't matter^example If they killed McCormack they'd find the transmission code on him; by not killing him, he just gives it to them or their choices were pretty obviously laid out to force them into something^example When Ghoul Gus appears, he offers weapons and help in exchange for some rum; their choices are to go along with it, refuse, or kill him, and Gus has at no point been rude or suspicious - even then, Gus didn't do much besides provide a throwaway joke with Gavin making him "wait" then "follow" over and over. It's unknown how much of this is the fault of the creators for how they set it up, or Michael and Gavin's fault for not exploring as much as any actual Fallout player would.