YMMV / Allysin Kay

• Americans Hate Tingle: The Canadian fans did not respond to her during matches with Candice LeRae in SMASH Wrestling or against Seleziya Sparx in Alpha 1 Wrestling. However, as Sienna, she got a big pop for her return at SMASH 100, September 17, 2017, against Allie (Cherry Bomb).
• Crazy Is Cool: She brings a machete to the ring AND is a great wrestler.
• Crowning Moment of Awesome: At 713 days, she broke the record for the single longest reign as AIW Women's Champion.
• Draco in Leather Pants
  • There were more than a few of her fans who somehow saw Allysin Kay as an avenging hero fighting the machinations of SHINE's corrupt boss lady Lexie Fyfe. While Daffney Unger and Ivelisse Velez also got similar interpretations, it was a little more justified in their cases. Note that this was before Kay's Heel–Face Turn.
  • At the start of her match with Veda Scott at AIW #TGIF, February 7, 2014, she did the "Pinkies Up" catchphrase and pose, and the commentators acknowledged that she had a fan base despite not being the "stereotypical babyface."
• Fridge Brilliance: In hindsight, the fact that Made In Sin had suddenly taken enough interest in Jazz to keep after her in spite of their Kong phobia should have raised some red flags, but since it simply happened next to SHINE rather than the promotion proper, another WWN member or even SHIMMER, no one thought to connect them to Rain until it was too late.
• Heartwarming Moment: In the Eye Scream example on the main page, she pointed out how her winning her MMA debut was even more special because her youngest brother competed on the card that night and they both won their fights via Rear Naked Choke.
• Les Yay Shipping: On Archive of Our Own, she gets Shipped mostly with Original Characters. Mia Yim's pretty popular too though.