As a WMG subpage, all spoilers are unmarked as per policy. You Have Been Warned.
- Unless, of course, Mordecai killed Atlas of his own volition. Asa Sweet might have offered him a better job in return for killing his rival; the flashback scene where Mordecai gave Mitzi his gun in front of the cafe might have been him saying "I killed your husband. Consider this as my resignation." It'd be a cold, bastardly thing to do and that's right up Mordecai's alley.
- Or or or! Atlas wasn't really a, let's say protagonist, and Mordecai had a good reason for killing him. He stayed mum about his reasons to protect the Lackadaisy and Mitzi et al, and resigned because of it.
- But didn't Rocky state that he lied about Mitzi having Atlas killed?
- What does Rocky really know about it? He was the Lackadaisy's fiddler until things got bad.
- There's an even amount of "for" and "against" for this one.
- "Lackadaisy Confession" comes very close to jossing it. Mordecai seems to actually be looking into the cause of Atlas's death, which he suspects Marigold of being involved with. Of course, he could really just be trying to cover up his own crime, but it doesn't seem likely.
- However, if this was the case, why wouldn't the series say that he committed suicide in the beginning of the comic? The story deliberately gives Atlas's death, an air of mystery.
- Alternately: Atlas' death was staged to look like a suicide, complete with note, (forged or written under duress on pain of killing his loved ones?) such that it convinced both Mordecai and Mitzi of its validity, stoking Mordecai's resentment and Mitzi's shame that Mitzi didn't see it coming, or that her alienation was its proximal, or explicitly detailed cause. Hence Mordecai's messy departure and her sincere, regret-fueled redevotion to Atlas' legacy. The era's suicide stigma and their shared grief would explain their mutual evasiveness. Mordecai already treated Mitzi rather like a disfavoured stepmother, so the loss of Atlas with her as the ostensible cause would be Mordecai's breaking point.
- It is true that Zib holds some degree of distain towards Atlas for knowing he'd stay to work at Lackadaisy just because Mitzi was there.
- Jossed. In "Lackadaisy Confessional" Mordecai tells Gracie that Mitzi wasn't living with Atlas at the time of his death, and that she didn't shoot him.
- Maybe not but, however, some bits and pieces hint that she had a hand in it, if not just aware of any key points about it.
- Confirmed. In "Lackadaisy Confessional", Mordecai reveals that Mitzi was living apart from Atlas at the time of his death, and that she did not pull the trigger.
- Everyone has a theory on who did it, but very few on why. Possibilities:
- Atlas was killed because he knew too much.
- Possibly having to do with the above Wild Mass Guess.
- Atlas is Faking the Dead: the crime scene photo is obscured and the only other image we see is a closed casket. He does have contacts in the mortuary world (the Arbogasts).
- Mordecai was the “killer”; A case of if you’re so evil, kill your boss, helping him to become The Mole.
- Mitzi feels guilty because she feels she is the reason Atlas went out that night, an argument or something similar.
- It was a Thanatos Gambit by Atlas. The Faking the Dead theories still apply.
- It was an accident.
- It was a mercy kill. We don't know much about Atlas, but we do know that he was getting up in years before his death (at least significantly older than his wife). Maybe he was sick or some such?
- Atlas was killed because he knew too much.
- Atlas was killed by someone else (who is for other theories) but Mordecai killed his killer. Mordecai considers his debt to Atlas repaid in this fashion, and so leaves for more gainful employment elsewhere. Whoever the killer was, it was someone close to him, and Mitzi feels that revealing whoever it was would finish Lackadaisy's demise.
The cult was active in the St. Louis area before the events of the comic. The Savoys pressured Atlas into joining their organization, and when he refused, they assassinated him. When Mordecai discovers that the cult killed his mentor, he'll carry out a Roaring Rampage of Revenge.
- Rocky. He has had an unrequited romance with Mitzi, and would view Atlas as his rival. With Rocky being a Cloudcuckoolander, he may not even realize what he actually did. In addition, his behavior to Wick, his romantic rival, comes across as deadly.
- Calvin. He is a Marigold Mole, and was tasked to infiltrate Lackadaisy.
- Their relationship only appeared to be on the rocks to outsiders. Atlas knew someone was gunning for him and sent Mitzi away to keep her out of the line of fire. Mordecai gave Mitzi a gun for self-defense.
- Marigold and Lackadaisy had problems with some "Sicilians" as mentioned in flashback. I wouldn't be surprised if Al Capone is trying to muscle in on their territory. They are the ones who have Asa so spooked that he's cleaning up loose ends.
- I think that Rocky convinced Freckle to join him in some shenanigans and Rocky got busted by Aunt Nina because of something Freckle did (or didn't) do. Freckle didn't make the call, he just was the direct cause - which Rocky never discovered.
- When he's talking to Ivy after being injured, Rocky basically says he admitted to something that he didn't do - something bloody - so that Freckle could continue being the Good Son. I think that Freckle's Axe-Crazy tendencies got somebody killed or seriously hurt, and Rocky took the blame for it.
- I'm not so sure; the way Rocky phrased it, he said the incident had an author, but that he signed his name, specifically avoiding confirming nor denying if he was truly responsible. Perhaps he was partially responsible, but he stepped up and took full blame to make sure Freckle got none.
- Actually, that would be Jossed, as Tracy said Calvin's dad of "something mundane".
- Do be fair, though, what counts as "mundane" in a city of gangsters and bootleggers?
- Prolly disease or accident, after all, back then wasn't known for its workplace, housing, or road safety and some diseases weren't treatable until the 40s (Rocky's mama, Sophie, died of TB).
- Actually, that would be Jossed, as Tracy said Calvin's dad of "something mundane".
Word of God is that Serafine is a poseur rather than an authentic Voodoo practitioner. Mordecai will find ways to poke holes in the rituals she uses to captivate her devotees, such as provoking a chwal to show that s/he isn't really possessed by Maitre Carrefour, or providing evidence that the Savoys have abused the devotee's trust. Mordecai will have his revenge when the devotees turn on the Savoys.
- Naw, that was Jossed, actually, he seemed terrified during the whole ritual.
When Serafine forcibly lacerated Mordecai's chest, it wasn't because he refused to join her cult. All Maitre Carrefour devotees receive a scar in the shape of a wheel with eight spokes, willingly or unwillingly.
Zulie created the cult so that she could control a lucrative criminal enterprise through superstition and religious devotion. She passes herself off as an ordinary devotee of the cult to deflect attention away from herself. Behind the scenes, she's calling the shots. She employs Serafine to masquerade as the cult's leader because Serafine's theatrical skill and familiarity with Voodoo are perfect for attracting followers ... and so that Serafine, not she, will be the chief target if enemies attack the cult.
Serafine and Nico were never orphaned as children, never sent to a Catholic orphanage, and never adopted by Maman Eulalie after running away from the orphanage. They concocted the story to gain sympathy from their followers and provide Voodoo credentials for the Maitre Carrefour cult. In reality, they were raised by their biological parents, with whom they still keep in touch. Someone will undermine the Maitre Carrefour cult by alerting devotees to the fact that the Savoy's parents are still alive.
The Maitre Carrefour cult sustains itself by selling drugs and is seeking a new market in St. Louis. Archie was silently staring into space for the entirety of the fete scene because he was high on one of the cult's products. At the end of volume 2, Mordecai was groggy because the cult used one of the drugs at its disposal to incapacitate him during his involuntary scarification. Serafine might consume a hallucinogen or deliriant when she wishes to channel Maitre Carrefour.
The Savoys plan on using their cult to murder the old guard of the Marigold gang, including Asa Sweet, and take over the speakeasy. Serafine wants to recruit Mordecai into the cult so that they can use him to undermine the Marigold gang from within.
Fish is a member of the Maitre Carrefour cult, and his girlfriend is one of the young women who attended the Savoy's fete. Fish's submissive, fearful personality would make him very easy for the cult to control. The cult arranged for such an incompetent man to infiltrate the Marigold gang so as to weaken it from within. Fish is one of several weak links installed in the organization so as to weaken it and make it easier to conquer.
Viktor's estranged wife and daughter are never named. What if Zulie was his estranged daughter? The story could be leading to a heartbreaking reunion between the two.
- Jossed. Viktor's daughter is named Alena, and she bears no resemblance to Zulie.
They're each the trump card for the Lackadaisy and Marigold gang. They're both psychotic when handling a weapon. And who would suspect a little cutie like Calvin could take down Mordecai? Eventually they will wind up fighting each other, and Calvin will probably win.
- Tracy practically confirmed this this on her Tumblr, saying "Odds that they will cross paths are very good odds."
Wick seems to be a perfect victim for the chopping block, but what if instead of being killed, he is tricked by Asa into funding his speakeasy without knowing, such as Asa not telling him what the money is really for. Wick does seem the naive type who wouldn't suspect anything wrong.
- His secretary Lacey, however, is not...which could put her on the chopping block as well, if she comes to know too much.
- On this page, Mordecai tells us about the Marigold acting like there’s a thorn in their side despite the lack of competition in town. It also shows us a flashback where the guy that Mordecai killed with the hatchet is attempting to escape. Serafine calls him a mouthpiece, which is old time slang for a criminal lawyer. Now, why would a speakeasy go after a lawyer, especially one that has no idea what it was he did wrong?
- On this page, Dom Drago, who works with the Treasury Department, asks Zib if he is on the Marigold’s payroll, then states that he’s not going to bust Zib because he has “bigger fish to fry”. It is implied that he works for the Bureau of Prohibition (which was part of the Department of the Treasury) but never actually stated.
- For those unaware, the Department of the Treasury collects taxes, supervises national banks and thrift institutions and investigates and prosecutes tax evasion.
- Dom even states that he is going to "pretend for now that [Zib is] a good little tax payer not a sax player".
- On this page, Bobby Bastion notes that the Marigold, now their exclusive buyer, has been doing “some aggressive spring cleaning” and keeping an eye on the Arbogasts more than usual. Indeed, you see them skulking around not more than a few pages later.
- On a historical sidenote: Al Capone (notorious gangster and bootlegger) was arrested, not for homicide but for tax evasion. This succeeded, in part, by the investigation by the US Department of the Treasury (including the Treasury's Bureau of Internal Revenue [IRS] and the Bureau of Prohibition).
Dom Drago's notes mention a "G.G.", which strongly implies that he was in contact with Gracie. Gracie was providing information on the Marigold gang to law enforcement, but he wasn't the only member of the criminal underground to do so. What if the Marigold's "aggressive spring cleaning" involves killing stool pigeons who could get the whole operation in trouble with the law?
For added drama, what if the Maitre Carrefour cult has an informant among their ranks? Now that Serafine and Nico are working for the Marigold gang, and now that Serafine is forcing Mordecai to join the cult, an informant could help law enforcement make a case connecting the cult to Marigold. Both groups could go down in flames if the traitors aren't discovered.
Many of the character's backstories involve Chicago. The return address on Alena's letters is in Chicago, suggesting that Viktor's previous home was in Chicago. According to Bobby, Mordecai was "riding a getaway train toward Chicago or Detroit" when he first encountered Atlas. The fact that Atlas encountered both men in or near Chicago suggests that he was conducting business there in the years before his death.
The story is leading up to a major event or an encounter with a crime syndicate in Chicago, which may have had something to do with Atlas' death.
- Viktor: A retired badass who has been wounded several times and has a heartwarming relationship with the local Genki Girl? He might as well have a bullseye on his back.
- But does it really seem likely to have the handicapped badass who physically suffers the most killed?
- Mordecai: Yes, we know he is one of the most skillful killers in the whole comic, but that's exactly the point. No one would expect him to die.
- He does seem to be discovering something curious, even ominous.
- Wick: The guy is just too darn nice to live.
- Or the events of October 1929 would only give him one choice.
- Zib: The guy is way too smooth. Plus, his dying would have a major effect on fellow characters, leading to loads of Character Development.
- I agree. His death would lead to a load of repercussions, and I could see him dying as a way to move the plot forward.
- I would disagree. His dying would serve little to no plot purpose on its own. Perhaps it would be a symptom of a greater abandonment of Lackadaisy's past, but frankly, I think it's unlikely that Zib would be the victim of Tracy's pen.
- Little to no plot purpose...yet.
- Given his recent development and focus, including his realizing that they're circling the drain and it's a matter of going down with the ship or not... yeeeeah, I'm worried for him too.
- Aunt Nina: Not necessarily through violence, but losing her would hit poor Freckle hard.
- Strongly disagree. I mean, can you really see this happening?
- Also, didn't Tracy say one of the main characters would die? Aunt Nina isn't a main character at all.
- Ivy: God, I hope not, but... killing this cutie would break the hell out of Calvin, not to mention just about everyone else.
- Rocky: You talk about somebody nobody expects to die? How about the Crazy Enough to Work master of the Indy Ploy? The guy we've been following from the start? The one who gets in waaaaayyyy over his head time after time, yet always seems to weasel his way out?
- Mitzi. She seems to be slipping somewhat, mental-health-wise, and her attempts to keep the speakeasy running are starting to border on obsession. She even scares Zib with the lengths she is willing to go to just to keep a necklace her husband gave her. My bet is that she's going to die a tragic death, and that will be the end of the Lackadaisy.
- Nah. It doesn't seem likely both the Lackadaisy spouses (Atlas and Mitzi) would end up dead.
- That's why it would make such an impact. Plus, something like this would catapult either Ivy or Rocky into a potential leadership role in the business, much like Mitzi herself was forced to step up when Atlas died. Both of these characters are developing in interesting ways recently...they might be being build up for the catastrophe that would be Mitzi somehow being incapacitated.
- Lacey. It's a perfect business strategy; Wick wouldn't be able to financially function without her. Killing her off would probably enable somebody to get their paws on his money without his even knowing about it, possibly bankrupting him in the process. Let's just hope that the person potentially killing her is not involved with the Lackadaisy crew.
- Nothing like a little one-sided tension between colleagues, eh?
- At one point Nicodeme blows a kiss to Mordecai to mess with him, so it seems neither sibling is above doing this since Mordecai is so straight laced they'd naturally find him fun to mess with.
- When Elsa tells Ivy about how Viktor protected her family, we see a flashback of Viktor loading a shotgun on the Arborgast's front porch, as Elsa looks on intently. It's not difficult to interpret Elsa's gaze as romantic.
- OP here, and Elsa and Bobby are officially married, so if there is anything going on, its not exactly kosher.
- They also have some Unresolved Sexual Tension going on.
- It’s said that Viktor turned against his own country to fight for the good old U.S of A, maybe Elsa had something to do with that?
- They also have some Unresolved Sexual Tension going on.
- ...But he didn't really love her. He only married her because he needed her for something (a spy, a coverup, a worker, something like that). It'd make her devotion to him all the more tragic.
- This would fit nicely with a pattern it was implied Atlas had in the past - he would help people in dire straits to make them indebted to him and then employ them in the speakeasy in some capacity since they already feel indebted to him.
- Because why the fuck not?
- Word of God states that Mordecai's asexuality is either his natural orientation or self-imposed. If the latter is the case, Mordecai may be capable of feeling attraction, but he suppresses it in favor of celibacy. When the Savoys introduced Mordecai to the Maitre Carrefour devotees, Zulie seemed very fond of him. What if her charms could convince him to reconsider his celibate lifestyle?
- Alternatively, Zulie was deliberately asked by Serafine or Nicodeme to try and seduce Mordecai to get him into the cult more easily. It's hard to tell what her real opinions of him are - she can be seen fiercely glaring at him in one panel when he disparages the cult, so she could be acting up her flirtation towards him for pragmatic reasons.
- Don't look at me that way, you were all thinking it.
- Nah. Her last four boyfriends have had names starting with "C".
- Maybe his real name will begin with C, and he'll just have Hobbes as a nickname. Or vice-versa, like Calvin's nickname is Freckle.
- Are you serious.
- Why the hell not.
- In "Lackadaisy Confessional", readers learn that Mitzi and Atlas' marriage had "visibly deteriorated", and that she was living apart from him at the time of his death. Mordecai is clearly in mourning for Atlas and tells Gracie, "I worked closely with him." Gracie remarks that Mordecai is "not really the cake eater type". What if Atlas' marriage fell apart because Mitzi learned that he was romantically involved with Mordecai, who still mourns for his paramour?
- Not really sure if this applies, but in the recent pages we learn that apparently Mordecai wasn't much older (if not the same age) as Ivy is now when he started working with Victor.
- No, that totally applies. He got mixed up in the underworld at a young age (prolly to help support his family, or after he suddenly found himself without them somehow). However, there was probably a defining incident/series of incidents that pushed him over the edge. (Bobby also mentions the theory that he has a bullet fragment in his brain, which would fit.)
- Alternately, Bobby was half-right. Mordecai had himself a "wonky streak" (Acquired Brain Injury) carved in his already OCD, slightly crime-hardened brain by fever and encephalitis courtesy of the 1918 flu pandemic, at 19, (a critical neurodevelopmental period even for an older teen) which not only resulted in what the author terms the "traumatic excision of his interpersonal skills" (already meagre to start) but also probably exacerbated any alexithymia that caused them, and I'm guessing, left one or more of his beloved sisters dead. I can't help but notice his childhood picture with an infant that would be Ivy's age by now, especially after the events of the Pilot Movie.
- Well, from what we see in flashbacks, he was a little odd but not by much and, according to Tracy, he was first got involved in the underworld when he was 13.
- Somewhat Jossed. He was with his family, though, his family wasn't well off. As far as how he was as a kid, Tracy puts it, Mordecai was "nerdy, sullen and desperately in need of personal space, but not profoundly maladjusted". Tracy never said why/how he got a job in the criminal underworld.
- Well, there were imitation jewels back then, so it's plausible
- Jossed. Tracy's said the story will have a time skip between Volume Two and Three, and that the comic will end "before Prohibition ends, but after The Great Depression begins."
- Pretty much Jossed. He's seen using both hands in the finished page.
After receiving a head injury at Arbogast farm, Rocky's mental state is fragile. His mental health will rapidly deteriorate until he becomes too violent and delusional to employ at the Lackadaisy. If he doesn't end up in a prison cell or a psyche ward, someone in the criminal underworld will be forced to put him down.
- Alternatively, it actually makes him more competent, to the point that he becomes a highly efficient, if still slightly-off-his-rocker enforcer with an effectiveness rivaling Mordecai. This of course makes him a threat to Marigold and he becomes their number one target, while also causing further drama as his newfound sociopathic tendencies threaten to further alienate him from his friends at Lackadaisy.
She'll either think it something similar to the "protective" rune she scarred onto Mordecai, or believe him possessed by something in a similar vein she sees herself possessed by Maitre Carrefour. Either way, it'll evoke a reaction from her. Judging by the way the scar and resulting crack on Rocky's noggin has been highlighted so far, it will definitely play some sort of part in the future other than contributing to Rocky's Sanity Slippage.
There's no denying that the bonk on the noggin messed Rocky up pretty bad and did more than just give him a scar on his forehead, but there's something....off about the post-Haymaker Rocky, as if he isn't even the same person any more. Given the severity of the injury and the emotional baggage the poor guy is lugging around it isn't surprising, but only time will tell how much the injury affected poor Rocky...
Rocky's behavior post-Haymaker (confusion, erratic behavior, weakness, apathy) is consistent with a subdural hematoma. Which means Rocky is a ticking time bomb as the pressure builds on his brain and a serious liability for the team being so far away from anyone that can and would be willing to help him.
- Possibly confirmed going by the symptoms but he seemed to be okay when he made that phone call.
And maybe even be on the opposing side. Also, why not draw a parallel between the Heller siblings and the Savoy siblings?
A long shot, but it might happen:
- Freckle is spiritually broken for the rest of his life under the weight of a tortured conscience, a kind of living death.
- Ivy ends up arrested/in jail, bringing shame on her family and putting a black stain on the rest of her life.
- Mitzi scrapes through with/without the speakeasy, but spends the rest of her days mourning Atlas.
- Wick's time "runs out".
- Mordechai comes apart (nervous breakdown?)
- Viktor survives but continues to disintegrate physically.
- Zib disappears into the either.
- Rocky drowns in the Mississippi, either by his hand or somebody else's.
- To add to this theory, Butler has also designed 'human versions' of nearly every main character in the comic.