The final two are stuck on a pirate ship and are later forced to either answer each question on eliminated contestants correctly, or do a twisted version of a challenge from earlier in the season. Meanwhile, Chef and Chris bicker endlessly about their experiences working with each other.
Tropes:
- Butt-Monkey: Duncan, who wasn't able to answer questions about each contestant, has to repeat each and every challenge in the season, most of them with a twist (like instead of him jumping on a horse, the horse jumps on HIM).
- Call-Back: To most challenges of the season.
- Description Cut: When Duncan guesses what colour Courtney's thinking of wrong (blue), we cut to her saying that she was thinking of "Burnt Sienna".
- Feud Episode: Happens between Chris and Chef.
- Hidden Depths: Beth is shown to be a very good listener in this episode, having listened to everybody talking and being able to answer the questions and not having to do the tasks. She also helps Chris and Chef to stop arguing.
- Like an Old Married Couple: Most of Chris and Chef's interactions in this episode.
- Odd Friendship: Beth and Duncan develop one in this episode, mostly towards the end.
- Out with a Bang: Chef says he's doing this in this episode, by cooking Beth and Duncan a delicious breakfast.
- Pop-Culture Pun Episode Title: The title is a play on the film Mutiny on the Bounty.
- Series Continuity Error:
- Despite breaking up with him two episodes earlier, Beth mentions Brady twice and talks as if said breakup never happened by calling him her boyfriend.
- When Duncan and Beth go through the door, they come out on the left side of the Aftermath studio. However in past episodes, guests come out of the waiting room and enter on the left side without going through the set. It is possible that the waiting room can disconnect from the aftermath studio, and it even seemed to appear separately from the studio in "Rock n' Rule".
- This also leads questions as to why the Lame-o-sine is shown driving off into the distance after someone is eliminated.
- This might be solely for the movie-themed aspect of the season.
- The animatronic monster from ‘’Monster Cash’’ is referred to as if it were the alien from ‘’Alien Resurr-eggtion’’ (which was just Chef in an alien costume).
- Shout-Out:
- Chris makes a reference to the kids' game "Chutes and Ladders" when he wonders "Who will climb the golden ladder to Glorytown and who will slide down the stinky slide to Loserville?"
- Chris mentions the Oscars when Chef says that he is getting a new job.
- Chef refers to The Newlywed Game when he asks the question "What was the weirdest place Geoff and Bridgette made out in?"
- To Be Continued: This is the only episode to have a "To be continued..." notice as it has a tie right before the finale episode.
