Recap / The Twilight Zone (1959) S2E3: "Nervous Man in a Four Dollar Room"

Left to right: John Rhoades and Jackie Rhoades.

Rod Serling: This is Mr. Jackie Rhoades, age thirty-four, and where some men leave a mark of their lives as a record of their fragmentary existence on Earth, this man leaves a blot, a dirty, discolored blemish to document a cheap and undistinguished sojourn amongst his betters. What you're about to watch in this room is a strange, mortal combat between a man and himself, for in just a moment, Mr. Jackie Rhoades, whose life has been given over to fighting adversaries, will find his most formidable opponent in a cheap hotel room that is in reality the outskirts of the Twilight Zone.

Air date: October 14, 1960

Jackie Rhoades (Joe Mantell) is a cowardly and insecure gangster waiting in the four dollar hotel room he calls home for a call from his boss George (William D. Gordon). George then enters, and after mocking Jackie several times, hands him a gun and orders him to kill a bartender who won't pay for "protection" money. Jackie says that while he's done a fair share of criminal acts, he's never killed anybody in his life. George angrily tells him to have the job done by 2:00 or else he'll be killed before he leaves.

Jackie nervously considers the gun, and eventually decides that he has no choice. Suddenly, his reflection starts talking and moving on its own, acting as a stronger-willed version of Jackie. The reflection mocks Jackie for being a total loser and an unassertive coward his whole life. It goes on to remind Jackie that he had been given multiple chances to be a better person, but he always allowed himself to be pressured into doing the wrong thing, which led him to join George's gang instead of graduating and getting a real job. The reflection then laments about Jackie's crush Janie Reardon, and how Jackie blew his chance to be with her, before telling him that if he doesn't stand up and quit the gang, he'll either be killed or spend the rest of his life as a pathetic lackey. Jackie can't muster up the courage to quit the gang, so the reflection tells him that it'll be taking over. Terrified, Jackie rips the mirror off the wall and tries to escape, but finds mirrors everywhere as the reflection gets larger and larger...

At 2:30, George comes back to the room and yells at Jackie for not killing the bartender, threatening him with his own gun. Jackie suddenly casually knocks the gun out of George's hand, then beats him up and throws him out of the room. He calls the desk clerk and checks out, referring to himself as "John Rhoades". He looks into a mirror, where it's revealed that Jackie and the reflection have switched places. "John" tells Jackie that he's going out into the world and finally making something out of their life. Seemingly content, Jackie wordlessly agrees.

Nervous Tropes in a Four Dollar Room:

• Be Careful What You Wish For: In the beginning, George ridicules Jackie by saying that he's going to get some guts if he's going to kill the bartender. At the end of the episode, Jackie (or rather "John") has those guts, just enough to stand up to George and send him running.
• Bottle Episode: The entire episode takes place in Jackie's hotel room and the nearby hallway.
• Chromosome Casting: The episode does not feature any women onscreen.
• Cigarette of Anxiety: Jackie tries to light one up, only to find he has no matches. His reflection does, and offering one to him is how the two meet for the first time.
• Cool Old Guy: While nameless and off-screen, the old bartender who stands up to George and his gang is essentially this. George and his men expect that supplying his jukebox automatically entitles them to his services, but he isn't taking flack from them and spits in their eye instead. The whole reason George wants Jackie to kill him is solely because he suspects this man could potentially inspire others to stand up to him and his gang.
• Dare to Be Badass: John calls Jackie out on his lackluster, criminal lifestyle, and tells him that he can be better than what he has been.
  John: Jackie! Jackie, let me out! I wanna take over! I gotta take over! I want a decent job, some friends!
  Jackie: I got a job! I got friends! I got everything I want!
  John: You got nothin'! You got nothin' but pain inside! You got no friends! You got nothin'! You ARE nothin! It's time to BE something!
• Death of Personality: The reflection completely overrides Jackie's mind, though both it and Jackie himself are satisfied with the change.
• Did Not Get the Girl: One of the unhappy results of Jackie's lifetime of poor choices was when he was in a relationship with Janie Reardon. But instead of settling down with her, he chose to continue working for street gangs and was sent to jail. By the time he was released, Janie had already moved away and married someone else.
• Happy Ending: Rare for a Twilight Zone episode. "John" Rhoades stands up to George and turns a corner into his new life.
• The Mafia: Jackie is a gangster associated with local crime boss George. He typically performs minor jobs such as breaking and entering and the occasional mugging. Since the police are well aware that Jackie doesn't handle big jobs, George tells him to kill the old bartender in order to throw them off the scent.
• The Man in the Mirror Talks Back: Jackie's reflection spends the whole episode belittling the real deal. At the end, he takes over and vows to turn their life around.
• Meaningful Rename: When the reflection takes over Jackie's mind, he starts calling himself "John", signifying that at this very late date, he's finally going to start taking responsibility for his own life.
• Minimalist Cast: This episode only features two actors: Joe Mantell and William D. Gordon (who appears in two scenes).
• Morton's Fork: Jackie's situation: either he doesn't kill the bartender and gets killed by George, or he kills the bartender and gets killed by the police.
• Never My Fault: Jackie laments how his life has been one long uphill climb with nothing to show for it. He was first dared as a child by some boys to steal from a teacher, then was sent to a reform school when he was caught shoplifting, then was sent to jail after disobeying his parole officer, then lost his girlfriend to another man when he got sent to prison again. His reflection is the first to point out that a great deal of this misfortune was a result of his own poor life choices.
• The One That Got Away: Janie Reardon, who fell in love with someone else while Jackie was in prison.
• Peer Pressure Makes You Evil: Jackie became the lowlife he is in large part to peer pressure, as some kids dared him to steal from a teacher when he was a boy.
• "The Reason You Suck" Speech: An episode-long one given from a reflection to its reflector.
• Rage Against the Reflection: An inversion, as the reflection is annoyed with the man.
• The Slacker: Jackie's reflection alleges that all of Jackie's troubles have been his own fault.
• Split-Personality Takeover: The reflection, aka "John", takes over Jackie's life, which he does in the end. It's a Happy Ending as "John" is a better, stronger person, and Jackie himself is actually quite fine with it, though he's stuck in a mirror.
• Talking to Themself: Jackie spends the whole episode talking to his sapient reflection.
• Take a Third Option: George gives Jackie an ultimatum: kill the bartender or be killed. "John" exercises a third option by beating the crap out of George when he comes to take revenge.
• That Man Is Dead: Jackie's name change signifies that he's no longer the same person.
• Took a Level in Badass: Jackie goes from fearfully going along with everything George says, to defying him, beating him in a fight, and resigning from his gang.
• Verbal Tic: Jackie adds "George" at the beginning and end of sentences, usually when talking to or about his boss.

---

Rod Serling: Exit Mr. John Rhoades, formerly a reflection in a mirror, a fragment of someone else's conscience, a wishful thinker made out of glass, but now made out of flesh and on his way to join the company of men. Mr. John Rhoades, with one foot through the door and one foot out of the Twilight Zone.