Alex walks in and greets Todd, who plays back some messages, and Alex hears a message from a girl, Megan Murphy, whom he had a 7-day fling with and who happens to be in New York and wants to hook up. They and Wiseman discuss the situation, with Alex mentioning that Megan's father relocated to Kenya.
That evening, Alex prepares for his date with Megan (which was arranged offscreen). Wiseman takes some laundry to the laundromat, including some "sexy sheets". before he leaves, a woman named Casey Parker (Natalia Cigliuti) arrives to start work as a temp worker to help Alex with his music web site and meets the three men. Alex and Wiseman then leave.
Alex meets Megan (Jennifer Morrison) at a restaurant and finds out she had actually taken his 7th grade swim medal. However, during his din ner date he finds that Megan is a habitual liar, including claiming she had invented Pokémon. Meanwhile, Wiseman is on a date with a woman named Jolene (Valerie Geffner), who turns out to have a very short temper.
After Alex and Wiseman meet in the restroom, they hatch a plan to retrieve Alex's medal. After some hijinks and more lies by Megan, Wiseman retrieves the medal, and Alex feigns choking so that they leave the restaurant.
Meanwhile, back at the apartment, Todd and Casey watch Antique Roadshow, and soon play a game of "Strip Antique Roadshow", ith the loser removing an article of clothing if they guess something wrong about the items displayed. Soon, Todd is only wearing shorts, while Casey still has a shirt and trousers. After Casey loses a round, she removes her light purple shirt, only to reveal a sleeveless white blouse underneath.
The show ends, with neither of them being fully undressed. Casey hides in a side room as Alex and Wiseman come back, who tell Todd abotu their respective dates. Casey says goodbye to them and leaves, but not before Todd tosses her shirt back to her.
