Robin decides that now's a good time to tell everyone his Superhero Origin, but the other Titans get bored and decide to tell their own stories.
- Dark and Troubled Past: All of the Titans claim that they have one in their backstories, such as Raven's uncle dying (of old age instead of to a criminal), and Cyborg's adoptive parents falling on hard times and losing their farm.
- Projected Man: At the end of Beast Boy's story, it turns out he's not actually a Green Lantern, but a projection created by a Green Lantern, who then fades away to Robin's shock and everyone else's misery.
- Superhero Origin: Robin tries to tell his, but gets swept aside by the Titans who tell wildly different ones based on other superheroes. Raven is Spider-Man, Cyborg is Superman, Starfire is Batman and Beast Boy is Green Lantern.