Susie has to scramble when Oscar's parents arrive on the island for a campers VS counselors softball game.
- Baseball Episode: Where the game isn't actually that important.
- Didn't Think This Through: In a panic, Susie quite literally claps the magic of the island off, completely sure she can turn it back on later. She can't.
- Missing the Good Stuff: Oscar's parents end up missing much of the game - including their son's one good play - shooting video of what they think is an osprey.
- Mood Whiplash: 99% of the episode is a comical softball game, where the campers fail miserably to not do magic in front of Oscar's parents. And then the end hits. With Susie unable to turn magic back on, every creature who existed because of it disappearing, and the tornado heading back for the island.
- Not So Above It All: Susie keeps reprimanding everyone for using magic during the game and risking being exposed. But when Susie is up to bat and she accidentally throws it at Mildred, she turns it into a flock of bats to save her sister. The ensuing chaos is caught on video by Oscar's parents, leading Susie to turn off magic and doctor the video after they both fainted.
- Year Inside, Hour Outside: Susie reveals that while the campers have been on the island for 4 months, only a week has passed in the outside world.
