Reincarnation Romance: Carl Rodriguez and Felicity Dawes wholeheartedly believe they are tragic lovers reborn. As usual, Crabtree believes them and Brackenreid calls bullcrap.
Star-Crossed Lovers: Tristan Colville and Jane Gleat. They were secret lovers, but her arranged fiancé attacked Tristan and Jane killed him in defence of Tristan. She confessed to the police, and was hanged.