When Ray brings a new girlfriend to the Man Cave and reveals that he told her his secret identity and is getting married, Henry and the gang suspect there's more to her than meets the eye.
Tropes:
- Alternate Identity Amnesia: Henry doesn't remember anything he did after the love muffins' effects were reversed. Zigzagged with Ray, who only remembers eating the muffins and falling for Gwen.
- The Bad Guy Wins: Not only does Gwen manage to escape, but she finds out Captain Man and Kid Danger's secret identities.
- Bitch in Sheep's Clothing: Gwen to a T. She not only mind controls Ray, but finds out his secret identity as Captain Man and escapes with the information.
- Blackmail: Gwen resorts to this in order to escape the Man Cave.
- "Could Have Avoided This!" Plot: If Ray had suspected the muffins were causing him to be susceptible to Gwen, the episode's event's wouldn't have happened.
- Fourth-Date Marriage: A love-induced Ray plans to marry Gwen within only three hours of meeting her.
- Idiot Ball: Ray and Henry have no excuse to not use their lasers to destroy Gwen's phone, and it didn't occur to either of them to erase her memory either.
- Love Potion: Gwen infused her muffins with this; whoever eats them will fall in love with the first person they kissed. It caused Ray to fall for her, and she almost did the same to Henry when Jasper interfered.
- Small Role, Big Impact: Piper only appears in one scene, harassing Jasper for using her curling iron. However, her appearance is what leads to the muffins' antidote; when Henry got mad, it reversed the effects.
