While at an old record store, Peter and the guys recount tales of three rock legends: Jim Morrison, Muddy Waters, and Elton John.
Tropes:
- Call-Back: "Surfin' Bird" is brought up once again.
- Deal with the Devil: Muddy Waters sold his soul for enhanced musical ability. And then Peter (disguised as Elvis Presley) steals his songs and takes all the credit.
- Earthy Barefoot Character: Lois as Jim Morrison's hippie girlfriend is always shoeless.
- Sudden Downer Ending: Muddy Waters' story ends rather sadly.
- Vignette Episode: An episode made into three stories about famous musicians with the characters playing the musicians.
