In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Anthony "Tony" Chu, God of the Consumption of Inedible Substances as a Lesser God in the Hall of Consumption (House of Food)
- Gertrude, The Goddess of Beings Trapped in Another World as an Intermediate Goddess in the Hall of Otherworldly and Unorthodox Locations (House of Locations and Settings)
- Markus Grayson, Patron Saint of Capepunk (Mark Grayson, Invincible, Captain Guy-With-A-Hole-Punched-In-Him) as an Intermediate God in the Halls of Superheroism (House of Heroism) and Narrative Genres (A to M) (House of Narrative)
- Nolan Grayson, God of Feeling Guilty About Performing One's Duty (Nowl-An, Omni-Man, Emperor Nolan, Spencer Samson, The Azure Avenger, Supra-Man, The Uptight Viltrumite, Big Bad Daddy, Mighty Mustache) as a Greater God in the Hall of Regret and Shame (House of Despondency)
- Albert "Al" Francis Simmons, God of Nineties Anti Heroes (Spawn, The Guardian, Sad Man, Hells' Pawn, King of the Dead, Omega Spawn) as a Greater God and one of The Dark Guardians in the House of Ambiguity
- Malebolgia, Hellish Lord of Demonic Hierarchies as a Greater God in the Hall of Demons (House of Otherness)
- The Violator, Unholy Monster Clown as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Villainous Jobs (House of Villainy)