In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
Red Team
- Staff Sergeant Sarge, God of Monikers That Are Actually Real Names (S-Dog, Colonel Sarge) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Naming Convention (House of Naming and Epithets)
- Private First Class/Sergeant/Minor Junior Private Negative First Class/Captain Dexter Grif, God of Blood Sports (Gruff, Griff, Dirtbag, That Yellow Guy, Sarge's Number 7 Man) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Physical Sports (House of Sports)
- Private First Class/Captain Richard "Dick" Simmons, Patron Saint of Butt Kissers as a Lesser God in the Hall of Obedience Mindsets (House of Loyalty and Servitude)
- Franklin Delano Donut, God of Questionable Sexual Preferences (Private Biscuit, Commander Poppin Fresh, Pinkie, Major Cinnamon Bun, Corporal Cor-Sandwich, Admiral Buttercrust, Princess Bubblegum) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Romantic Orientation (House of Love and Affection)
- Lopez La Pesado, God of Gratuitous Spanish (Lopez the Heavy) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Language (House of Quirks)
Blue Team
- Leonard L. Church, God of Frustrated Resignation (Alpha) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Miscellaneous Philosophies (House of Philosophy)
- Lavernius Tucker, God of Pregnant Dudes and Pointing Out Suggestive Lines (T-Pain, and an assortment of other Ebonic names- by Asuna, Meta 2.0) as a Lesser God in the Halls of Life and Creation (House of Life and Vitality) and Phrases (House of Quirks)
- Michael J. Caboose, God of Teamkilling (Captain Caboose, the Vehicle Destroyer, Teamkilling F*cktard, the Beast, Cabose) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Acts of Treason (House of Betrayal and Treachery)
- Agent Texas, the Goddess Who Is Doomed to Fail (Tex, Bitchpants McCrabby, Allison, Beta) as an Intermediate Goddess in the Hall of Destinies (House of Prophecy and Fate)
- Agent Washington, The Relatively Strong God (Wash, David, Recovery One) as a Lesser God under Power Levels and Appearance (Power and Abilities)
- Epsilon, God of Rebirth by Memory (Leonard Church, Alpha 2.0) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Manners of Revival (House of Life and Vitality)
- Agent Carolina, Goddess of Chameleon Camouflage as an Intermediate Goddess in the Hall of Disguises (Costumes)
Others
- Medical Super-Private, First Class Frank "Doc" DuFresne, God of Flip-Flop Psyches (Doc, O'Malley, Omega) as a Demigod in the Hall of Split Personalities (House of Personality)
- The Meta, God of Power Programs (Agent Maine, Sigma) as a Lesser God in the Halls of Digital Personas (House of Machinery and Technology) and External Power Sources (House of Power and Abilities)
- Locus, God of Intergalactic Pirates (Monster, Samuel Ortez) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Piracy (House of Crime and Transgressions)
- Felix, God of Fake Friendship (Sunkist McScouty, Pumpkin Patrol, Isaac Gates) as a Lesser God in the Halls of Tainted Friendship (House of Friendship and Camaraderie) and Selfishness (House of Pride and Egotism)