In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
The Van der Linde Gang
- John Marston, God of Retired Outlaws (Just A Tired Old Sinner) as an Demigod in the Halls of Anti-Heroism (House of Ambiguity) and Other Criminals (House of Crime and Transgressions)
- Arthur Morgan, God of Convenient Terminal Illness (Arthur Callaghan, Tacitus Kilgore, King Arthur, Yankee Numbskull, Black Lung, The Big Dog) as a Demigod in the Hall of Diseases (House of Health and Diseases)
- Jack Marston, God of Children Turning Out Like Their Parents as a Lesser God in the Hall of Offsprings (House of Family and Relatives)
- Dutch van der Linde, God of Disgraced Inspirational Figures (Hoagy Macintosh, Aidan O'Malley, Archibald Smith, Yankee) as a Demigod in the Hall of Influential Figures (House of Legacy and Influence)
- Micah Bell III, the Deified Psycho Party Member ([The] Rat, Hothead, Snake, Sickness) as a Demigod in the Hall of Groups and Teams (House of Communities and Solitude)
Additional Characters
- Nigel West Dickens, Snake Oil Salesman to the Gods (N.W.D., Mr. West Dickens) as a Demigod in the Halls of Commercial Archetypes (House of Commerce) and Other Criminals (House of Crime and Transgressions)
- Seth Briars, God of Grave Robbing (Seth of the Dead) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Thieves (House of Crime and Transgressions)
- Landon Ricketts, God of Retired Gunslingers as a Lesser God in the Hall of Combat Occupations (House of Jobs and Profession)
