WARNING: Spoilers are unmarked.
Season 1
- George the demon approaching Kristen in pilot is both creepy and predatory.
- If that weren't enough, George attempts these same tactics on one of Kristen's daughters.
- Eric nearly succeeding in his attempt to drown his baby sister.
- Some seriously disturbing images are seen by the girls while playing the Augmented Reality game.
- Townsend corrupting a Hollywood Homely teen who had bad luck with the ladies into a full-blown terrorist incel. Subverted all the way to a Funny Moment when the kid stocks up on all his guns, but accidentally blows his own brain out before he manages to blow out anyone else's. Then again, there's enough foreshadowing beforehand that it probably wasn't accidental.
- Girls at a Catholic school becoming infected with an Ear Worm, a song that they can't stop singing or get out of their heads to the point where two of them jam sharp objects in their ears to get the sound to stop.
- Leon's wife giving birth to an honest-to-God ghoul in a cornfield.
- A woman pregnant with fraternal twins, with her son devouring her daughter while both are in-utero.
Season 2
- The team put some spyware on Leland's laptop, but Ben discovers while observing him that Leland can seemingly see him while on the laptop, and his evil laugh and distorted smile into the camera is downright terrifying.
- Ben accidentally discovers that playing the Elevator Game in a particularly apartment building brings the player to a forgotten sub-basement, and traps them there. Forever. Ben finds the bodies of a previous couple who died there because they both independently played and won. The experience traumatizes him so much that he starts seeing his rapist, the succubus Abbey, during the day, when she had previously existed only as a nightmare.
- Kristen's run in with a ghost haunting the same apartment complex. The ghost is only the upper portion of the dead woman, having been supposedly cut in half by the elevator, and she drags herself along by her hands, making the most god-awful noises with her fingers.
