Given how the podcast has been going on for almost six years, it's not that surprising that numerous stories share numerous details.
- Take one sip if:
- The villan of the story is a Humanoid Abomination.
- Take another if it's pale and hunched with long limbs and/or an abnormally large grinning mouth.
- The narrators tells us that they probably shouldn'tve done what they're about to do.
- Someone dies l.
- Someone in the story says cusses.
- The narrator mentions the antagonist's "creepy smile".
- The narrator's name is not revealed.
- The story is from the Claverhouse Email Series.
- The title is one word long.
- The villan of the story is a Humanoid Abomination.
- Take two sips if:
- David is narrating and he does an unnecessary accent.
- Finish your drink if it's Jive Turkey.
- The narrator is a patient in an insane asylum.
- The narrator interviews someone in an asylum.
- The narrator is a police officer.
- The title gives away a lot of the plot (for example "Being a Detective Ruined My Marriage" or "I Still Get Letters From My Dead Best Friend").
- The story is over forty minutes long.
- The story is under ten minutes long.
- The story has more than five narrators.
- The narrator mentions several real-life places.
- A character is named Sara, Josh, Chris, or Brian.
- David is narrating and he does an unnecessary accent.
- Take three sips if:
- This narrator says that they're posting the story on the internet because their doctor told them to.
- The story begins with the narrator and their family moving into a new house.
- The story features an evil clone.
- A copyrighted song plays (For example, "Hot n' Cold" by Katy Perry in "Box Fort" or "Barracuda" by Heart in "The Midnight Hike").
- It's pretty clear the narrator is going to die shortly after the story ends.
- The narrator mentions that the names of the people involved have been changed, or a beeping noise covers up locations or character's last names.
- The events of the story happened when the narrator was young and they're telling it years later.
- The narrator kills someone.
- Finish your drink if:
- The twist at the end reveals that nothing supernatural was going on at all, and everything can be explained as human-caused.
- Add a shot if it was written by C.K. Walker.
- The story features a And Then John Was a Zombie ending.
- The story features a The Fourth Wall Will Not Protect You ending.
- The twist at the end reveals that nothing supernatural was going on at all, and everything can be explained as human-caused.