General
- Practically every joke not related to horror movies is a sex gag that redefines "over the top".
Scary Movie
- A girl living with her drug-dealing father? Not funny. Having them talk about how cutting crack with baking powder will have people growing muffins out of their noses? Funny.
- Greg beating up Cindy while her friends and boyfriend do nothing? Not funny. Finishing her off with an elbow drop after telling the killer to bring it on? Hilarious.
- Brenda getting stabbed to death in a movie theater? Brutal. Brenda getting repeatedly stabbed by the patrons because she wouldn't shut up, her collapsing to the ground, with everyone applauding? Comedic gold!
- Cindy's sex scene crosses the line way more than twice in terms of both raunchiness (she gets stripped down to only her bra, and we get a close-up shot of her groin just before her panties are removed) and hilarity (with vagina-bats and a cum-geyser).
Scary Movie 2
- A white guy saying "nigger" usually won't score many laughs, but when said white guy is a priest and he's singing Mystikal's "Shake Your Ass" with a room full of middle-aged upper-class white yuppies, it's a riot!
- A Pedophile Priest having sex with an underage girl? Horrible. Said girl being a possessed demon child a la The Exorcist who's screaming "Fuck me!"? Somehow amusing.
- A parrot saying dirty words? Pretty funny. The parrot getting into a smacktalk argument with Shorty? Hysterical!
- Hanson getting aroused while dressing the turkey by licking it? Pure Squick. Hanson mounting the bird, humping it, having The Immodest Orgasm, and then serving it? Pure hilarity.
- Getting dragged under a bed by an animate clown doll?
Standard horror movie schtick. Being tough enough to beat the shit out of the doll? Badass. Lassoing the fleeing doll with one's six-foot-long prehensile Gag Penis and sodomizing it to death? That's this trope.Ray: Here's a little balloon animal! Dada-da-dada, da-dadada-da!
Scary Movie 3
- The President and his bodyguard succumb to paranoia and beat up a roomful of "aliens disguised as humans," a.k.a. handicapped people and Girl Scouts. And if that wasn't enough, the second line is definitely crossed when the bodyguard opens up an exit... by grabbing a shotgun and blasting through a giant picture of Mother Teresa.
- The scene of a policewoman trying to tell Tom that his wife is going to die. The part where he goes "She broke her wiener?". note
- Cody having his penis cut in half at birth? Sounds painful. It being sewn back on and that's why he pees up? Funny. His aunt who adopted him after his mother's death prioritizing Tivo over fixing it? Rolling on the floor hilarious.
- George putting on a tall, pointy hood after his rap battle in front of a predominantly black audience would simply be tasteless if it wasn't for him being completely oblivious to what he just did, and the horrified reactions of the other main characters present. And then he proceeds to dig himself deeper by doing a Nazi salute before getting chucked out a window.
Scary Movie 4
- Leslie Nielsen is probably the only person to make racist jokes in front of the entire UN Assembly in the fourth movie so insanely hilarious.
- Dr. Phil having to saw off his own foot? Rather painful. Dr. Phil realizing he sawed off the wrong foot, dooming both him and Shaq anyway? Black Comedy at its finest.Dr. Phil: I did it! We’re saved! What’s wrong?Shaq: (points at Dr. Phil nervously) Wrong foot.
