Peter Pan
Peter, a late-twenties man-child and comic book artist living in the small town of Neverland Ohio, has three life goals: 1) NEVER GROW UP. 2) Have as much fun as humanly possible while doing as little work as possible. 3) Win the heart of his best friend, Wendy Darling.
- Fat Slob: Peter is noticeably overweight and, apart from a brief moment, quite a slob.
- Manchild: This version of Peter Pan may have grown older in body, but he hasn't matured any.
- O.O.C. Is Serious Business
- The Slacker
- The Stoner
Wendy Darling
Wendy is a woman in her late twenties who works for her family's newspaper as an advice columnist who wants more out her life than what Neverland can offer her. She is the oldest Darling child and runs Dear Darling.
- Not So Above It All: While generally the Only Sane Woman, she has her moments where she's just as goofy as the rest of them. She's also very easy to emotionally knock off-balance.
- Old Maid: She expresses concern about being this in an early episode. She's 27 and not even in a relationship.
- Only Sane Woman: Wendy is by far the most well-adjusted of all the characters, though admittedly that's not saying much.
John Darling
John is the middle Darling child, Assistant (to the) Editor-in-Chief of the Kensington Chronicle, and loves Neverland and never wants to leave.
- The Comically Serious: John has no sense of humor, and is frequently the funniest character because of it.
- Neat Freak
- Not So Above It All
- O.O.C. Is Serious Business
- Only Sane Man: John thinks he's this. In reality, he's no saner than anyone else, it's just that his eccentricities go in the opposite direction.
- Schedule Fanatic
- Spring Cleaning Fever
Michael Darling
Michael is the youngest Darling child, he runs the mail room at the Kensington Chronicle and loves Neverland.
- Cloudcuckoolander: Michael's not all there. His mind works in weird ways and he has a tendency towards Comically Missing the Point.
- Cannot Have Kids: According to the first episode of season 2.
- The Ditz
- Manchild: Much like Peter, he hasn't adjusted to adult life very well and acts extremely immature.
- Plucky Comic Relief
- The Slacker
- The Stoner
Lily Bagha
Lily is a rich, beautiful, ambitious business mogul who sticks around Neverland because of her love for Peter Pan.
James 'Jas' Hook
Jas is the CEO of JH Media and is the nemesis of Peter Pan, his childhood bully.
John Smee
Smee is Hook's out and proud assistant.
Billie Jukes
Billie is head lawyer of JH MEDIA handling all of its contracts both domestic and foreign.
- Gender Flip: The original Bill Jukes was a man.
- Iron Lady
George Darling
George Darling is the head of the Darling family, the father of Wendy, John, and Michael, and the Editor-in-Chief of the Kensington Chronicle.
Tinker Bell
Tink is Peter's fairy and is the only fairy in Neverland.
- Adaptation Relationship Overhaul: In the original book, Tinker Bell pretty much only cared about Peter and treated everyone else with indifference at best or disdain at worst. Here, she has a many more positive relationships with other characters — particularly Michael, with whom she gets on very well.
- Clingy Jealous Girl: As is the standard for her. She's perfectly fine with Peter having other friends, but she does not like it when someone tries to get into a romantic relationship with him.
- The Ghost: She never appears on-screen, because all the videos where she appears are shown from her point of view.
- P.O.V. Cam: All the videos in which she appears are seen exclusively through her eyes, which means she never actually appears on-camera despite having a large role in the series.
- The Unintelligible: Just like her classic incarnation, her voice sounds like ringing bells. The other characters understand her perfectly, though, it's just the audience that doesn't.
Mrs. Darling
The wife of George Darling and the mother of Wendy, John, and Michael.
