"Wish I could stop time in its place. Best day ever!"
- The Coffee Shop theme
is a pretty simple reggae track yet is catchy and memorable. - The Ice Fishing theme is also catchy, with its bouncy banjo.
- The Thin Ice theme is a quirky and fast chiptune tune.
- The baseline of DJ3K's Dance mix alone is upbeat and bouncy enough for the player to nod to. Mixing in more music tracks can make it more awesome.
- Operation Blackout's main theme helps convey the suspenseful and Spy-esque feeling that Herbert has finally won and that the island is now under his control.
- Some of the official lyrical songs, such as "Anchors Aweigh", "Ghosts Just Wanna Dance", and "Party in My Iggy", manage to be great pop songs.
- "It's Your Birthday" is the best birthday song you'll hear. "Gonna Be Epic", a 10th Anniversary song, feels like an Award-Bait Song, albeit upbeat and awesome.
- The University theme simply makes High School Rock!
- The Cole Plante remix of "Puffle Party (Gotta Have a Wingman)" is a hundred times better than the original, a powerful electronic music remix that completely transforms the cheery pop melody of the original.
- The Best of Year Mashups, mashing up each year's songs to a pop awesome song!
- "Puffle Shuffle" from "We Wish You a Merry Walrus" manages to mix crystal-like synths and ringing bells into a pop song to create a Christmas-y feeling.
- The Slime Battle theme from Club Penguin Island's Medieval Party is a bouncy and merry medieval-rock-sounding tune.
- "Perfect Day" from Club Penguin Island has a typical yet sweet Award-Bait Song feel, a slow yet uplifting feeling.
