Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheXFilesMiniseriesE04HomeAgain

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Transcribed recent entry from Live-Action TV Back From The Dead page to episode YMMV as a Tear-Jerker.

Added DiffLines:

* TearJerker: The [[BackForTheDead return and death]] of Margaret Scully.
** Scully receives a phone call while in Philadelphia where she learns her mother suffers a coma-inducing heart attack. She, especially when the RNs roll Margaret's body out.
** Scully learns that her mother's last request is to speak with Charlie, her youngest child who the family's lost touch with. While she and Mulder stay at Margaret's bedside, Charlie calls Scully which [[HopeSpot stirs their mother awake.]] She says a single sentence to Mulder, pointing out his and Scully's given-up son, before she immediately flatlines.
---> '''Margaret Scully:''' My son...is named William, too!

Removed: 1032

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* CriticalResearchFailure: The episode is set in West Philadelphia and mentions the fictional Franklin Hospital therein - that much is fine, and possibly a subtle case of [[NoCelebritiesWereHarmed No Famous Counties Were Harmed]]. However, other facts are just wrong. Pennsbury High School is part of Pennsbury School District, ''not'' Central Bucks; in fact, Pennsbury High School is located on the Levittown / Fairless Hills border... in south-eastern Bucks County, no-where ''near'' central Bucks County or [[Film/{{Signs}} Doylestown]]. There also hasn't been a single Central Bucks School District for decades, due to overpopulation (there are, in fact, three - CB East, West, and North).
** Additionally, there is no possible way the first victim could have been found at 1800 ''South'' Walnut Street in West Philadelphia. Walnut Street runs east-west, and so 1800 Walnut Street is smack in the middle of downtown Center City in the ritzy Rittenhouse Square area, not the industrial wasteland the episode paints West Philly as.

Added: 4

Changed: 29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming: Scully and Mulder's conversation in the hospital:

to:

* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming: SugarWiki/HeartwarmingMoments: Scully and Mulder's conversation in the hospital:



'''Mulder''': ''(shrugs his shoulders and laughs)'' What else is new?

to:

'''Mulder''': ''(shrugs his shoulders and laughs)'' What else is new?new?
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* CriticalResearchFailure: The episode is set in West Philadelphia and mentions the fictional Franklin Hospital therein - that much is fine, and possibly a subtle case of [[NoCelebritiesWereHarmed No Famous Counties Were Harmed]]. However, other facts are just wrong. Pennsbury High School is part of Pennsbury School District, ''not'' Central Bucks; in fact, Pennsbury High School is located on the Levittown / Fairless Hills border... in south-eastern Bucks County, no-where ''near'' central Bucks County or [[{{Signs}} Doylestown]]. There also hasn't been a single Central Bucks School District for decades, due to overpopulation (there are, in fact, three - CB East, West, and North).

to:

* CriticalResearchFailure: The episode is set in West Philadelphia and mentions the fictional Franklin Hospital therein - that much is fine, and possibly a subtle case of [[NoCelebritiesWereHarmed No Famous Counties Were Harmed]]. However, other facts are just wrong. Pennsbury High School is part of Pennsbury School District, ''not'' Central Bucks; in fact, Pennsbury High School is located on the Levittown / Fairless Hills border... in south-eastern Bucks County, no-where ''near'' central Bucks County or [[{{Signs}} [[Film/{{Signs}} Doylestown]]. There also hasn't been a single Central Bucks School District for decades, due to overpopulation (there are, in fact, three - CB East, West, and North).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Additionally, there is no possible way the first victim could have been found at 1800 ''South'' Walnut Street in West Philadelphia. Walnut Street runs east-west, and so 1800 Walnut Street is smack in the middle of downtown Center City in the ritzy Rittenhouse Square area, not the industrial wasteland the episode paints West Philly as.

to:

** Additionally, there is no possible way the first victim could have been found at 1800 ''South'' Walnut Street in West Philadelphia. Walnut Street runs east-west, and so 1800 Walnut Street is smack in the middle of downtown Center City in the ritzy Rittenhouse Square area, not the industrial wasteland the episode paints West Philly as.as.
* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming: Scully and Mulder's conversation in the hospital:
-->'''Scully''': Back in the day, did we ever come across the ability to just wish someone back to life?\\
'''Mulder''': I invented it. When you were in the hospital, like this.\\
'''Scully''': You're a dark wizard, Mulder.\\
'''Mulder''': ''(shrugs his shoulders and laughs)'' What else is new?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CriticalResearchFailure: The episode is set in West Philadelphia and mentions the fictional Franklin Hospital therein - that much is fine, and possibly a subtle case of [[NoCelebritiesWereHarmed No Famous Counties Were Harmed]]. However, other facts are just wrong. Pennsbury High School is part of Pennsbury School District, ''not'' Central Bucks; in fact, Pennsbury High School is located on the Levittown / Fairless Hills border... in south-eastern Bucks County, no-where ''near'' central Bucks County or [[{{Signs}} Doylestown]]. There also hasn't been a single Central Bucks School District for decades, due to overpopulation (there are, in fact, three - CB East, West, and North).

to:

* CriticalResearchFailure: The episode is set in West Philadelphia and mentions the fictional Franklin Hospital therein - that much is fine, and possibly a subtle case of [[NoCelebritiesWereHarmed No Famous Counties Were Harmed]]. However, other facts are just wrong. Pennsbury High School is part of Pennsbury School District, ''not'' Central Bucks; in fact, Pennsbury High School is located on the Levittown / Fairless Hills border... in south-eastern Bucks County, no-where ''near'' central Bucks County or [[{{Signs}} Doylestown]]. There also hasn't been a single Central Bucks School District for decades, due to overpopulation (there are, in fact, three - CB East, West, and North).North).
** Additionally, there is no possible way the first victim could have been found at 1800 ''South'' Walnut Street in West Philadelphia. Walnut Street runs east-west, and so 1800 Walnut Street is smack in the middle of downtown Center City in the ritzy Rittenhouse Square area, not the industrial wasteland the episode paints West Philly as.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CriticalResearchFailure: The episode is set in West Philadelphia and mentions the fictional Franklin Hospital therein - that much is fine, and possibly a subtle case of [[NoCelebritiesWereHarmed No Famous Counties Were Harmed]]. However, other facts are just wrong. Pennsbury High School is part of Pennsbury School District, ''not'' Central Bucks; in fact, Pennsbury High School is located on the Levittown / Fairless Hills border... in south-eastern Bucks County, no-where ''near'' central Bucks County or [[{{Signs}} Doylestown]]. There also hasn't been a single Central Bucks School District for decades, due to overpopulation (there are, in fact, three - CB East, West, and North).

Top