Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheCuencaCrime

Go To

OR

Added: 239

Removed: 208

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BestKnownForTheFanservice: This is the movie where a man has his testicles tied to a roof beam. It is also the movie where a terribly thirsty man sucks milk from his terrified, lactating wife while in jail.


Added DiffLines:

* SignatureScene: Two very vicious ones. Everyone remembers this as the movie where a man has his testicles tied to a roof beam. It is also the movie where a terribly thirsty man sucks milk from his terrified, lactating wife while in jail.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
YMMV can't be played with.


* AdaptationDisplacement: Averted. There are two novels with the title ''El Crimen de Cuenca''. However, the first one (from 1932) has nothing to do with the case, and the second (from 1979) is based on the movie script, rather than the opposite.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Although ''El Cepa'' is evidently stupid and illiterate, it is ambiguous if he didn't know about his "murder" before the civil guards came to take him to La Osa, or he did, but kept his mouth shut because he feared retribution.
* EveryoneRemembersTheStripper: This is the movie where a man has his testicles tied to a roof beam. It is also the movie where a terribly thirsty man sucks milk from his terrified, lactating wife while in jail.

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Although ''El Cepa'' is evidently stupid and illiterate, it is ambiguous if he didn't know about his "murder" before the civil guards came to take him to La Osa, or he did, but kept his mouth shut because he feared retribution.
* EveryoneRemembersTheStripper: BestKnownForTheFanservice: This is the movie where a man has his testicles tied to a roof beam. It is also the movie where a terribly thirsty man sucks milk from his terrified, lactating wife while in jail.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ItWasHisSled: Grimaldos was alive the whole time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: By focusing almost entirely on Gregorio and León's relationship and torture, the movie misses on a more choral approach showing the motives and interpretations of other characters and how they reacted to the confirmation that the accussed were innocent. The suicides of Don Rufo and Isasa are told in the epilogue but not shown, even though both would make powerful images (Isasa died in his own home and his death was passed as a heart attack; Don Rufo [[FreakierThanFiction drowned himself in wine]]). Finally, the movie ends in 1926 but the legal proceedings continued until 1935, when all the surviving torturers [[TheBadGuyWins were found innocent]]. Taboada lived through the whole process and at one point met the exhonerated Gregorio and León in Madrid and got in a fight with them. [[KarmicDeath He met injustice soon after]] when he was executed during TheSpanishCivilWar.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: By focusing almost entirely on Gregorio and León's relationship and torture, the movie misses on a more choral approach showing the motives and interpretations of other characters and how they reacted to the confirmation that the accussed were innocent. The suicides of Don Rufo and Isasa are told in the epilogue but not shown, even though both would make powerful images (Isasa died in his own home and his death was passed as a heart attack; Don Rufo [[FreakierThanFiction drowned himself in wine]]). Finally, the movie ends in 1926 but the legal proceedings continued until 1935, when all the surviving torturers [[TheBadGuyWins were found innocent]]. Taboada lived through the whole process and at one point met the exhonerated Gregorio and León in Madrid and got in a fight with them. [[KarmicDeath He met injustice soon after]] when he was executed during TheSpanishCivilWar.the Spanish Civil War.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: By focusing almost entirely on Gregorio and León's relationship and torture, the movie misses on a more choral approach showing the motives and interpretations of other characters and how they reacted to the confirmation that the accussed were innocent. The suicides of Don Rufo and Isasa are told in the epilogue but not shown, even though both would make powerful images (Isasa died in his own home and his death was passed as a heart attack; Don Rufo [[FreakierThanFiction drowned himself in wine]]). Finally, the movie ends in 1926 but the legal proceedings continued until 1935, when all the surviving torturers [[TheBadGuyWins were found innocent]]. Taboada lived through the whole process and at one point met the exhonerated Gregorio and León in Madrid and got in a fight with them. [[KarmicDeath He met injustice soon after]] when he was executed during the SpanishCivilWar.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: By focusing almost entirely on Gregorio and León's relationship and torture, the movie misses on a more choral approach showing the motives and interpretations of other characters and how they reacted to the confirmation that the accussed were innocent. The suicides of Don Rufo and Isasa are told in the epilogue but not shown, even though both would make powerful images (Isasa died in his own home and his death was passed as a heart attack; Don Rufo [[FreakierThanFiction drowned himself in wine]]). Finally, the movie ends in 1926 but the legal proceedings continued until 1935, when all the surviving torturers [[TheBadGuyWins were found innocent]]. Taboada lived through the whole process and at one point met the exhonerated Gregorio and León in Madrid and got in a fight with them. [[KarmicDeath He met injustice soon after]] when he was executed during the SpanishCivilWar.TheSpanishCivilWar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StreisandEffect: Critics who ''don't'' like the film (or don't consider it a masterpiece) blame the attempted government censorship for its massive success. Miró herself was disappointed with the fame that the scandal brought to the movie, and would have preferred that it had been less successful so long as it was on its own merits, not as a reaction to an attempted persecution.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: By focusing almost entirely on Gregorio and León's relationship and torture, the movie misses on a more choral approach showing the motives and interpretations of other characters and how they reacted to the confirmation that the accussed were innocent. The suicides of Don Rufo and Isasa are told in the epilogue but not shown, even though they could make powerful images (Isasa died in his own home and his death was passed as a heart attack; Don Rufo [[FreakierThanFiction drowned himself in wine]]). Finally, the movie ends in 1926 but the legal proceedings about the case continued until 1935, when all the surviving torturers [[TheBadGuyWins were found innocent]]. Taboada lived through the whole process and at one point he met the exhonerated Gregorio and León in Madrid and got in a fight with them.

to:

* StreisandEffect: Critics who ''don't'' like the film (or don't consider it a masterpiece) blame the attempted government censorship for its massive success. Miró herself was disappointed with the fame that the scandal brought to the movie, and would have preferred that it had been less successful so long as it was on its own merits, not as a reaction to an attempted persecution.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: By focusing almost entirely on Gregorio and León's relationship and torture, the movie misses on a more choral approach showing the motives and interpretations of other characters and how they reacted to the confirmation that the accussed were innocent. The suicides of Don Rufo and Isasa are told in the epilogue but not shown, even though they could both would make powerful images (Isasa died in his own home and his death was passed as a heart attack; Don Rufo [[FreakierThanFiction drowned himself in wine]]). Finally, the movie ends in 1926 but the legal proceedings about the case continued until 1935, when all the surviving torturers [[TheBadGuyWins were found innocent]]. Taboada lived through the whole process and at one point he met the exhonerated Gregorio and León in Madrid and got in a fight with them.them. [[KarmicDeath He met injustice soon after]] when he was executed during the SpanishCivilWar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlayingAgainstType: If you are used to watching Hector Alterio playing Argentinian avuncular characters, you will never recognize him as the antagonist HangingJudge Isasa, who has [[HeReallyCanAct no trace of an Argentinian accent]].

to:

* PlayingAgainstType: If you are used to watching Hector Alterio playing Argentinian avuncular characters, you will never recognize him as the antagonist HangingJudge Isasa, who has [[HeReallyCanAct [[SugarWiki/HeReallyCanAct no trace of an Argentinian accent]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StreisandEffect: Critics who ''don't'' like the film (or don't consider it a masterpiece) blame the attempted government censorship for its massive success. Miró herself was disappointed with the fame that the scandal brought to the movie, and would have preferred that it had been less successful so long as it was on its own merits, not as a reaction for an attempted persecution.

to:

* StreisandEffect: Critics who ''don't'' like the film (or don't consider it a masterpiece) blame the attempted government censorship for its massive success. Miró herself was disappointed with the fame that the scandal brought to the movie, and would have preferred that it had been less successful so long as it was on its own merits, not as a reaction for to an attempted persecution.

Added: 840

Changed: -2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StreisandEffect: Critics who ''don't'' like the film (or don't consider it a masterpiece) blame the attempted government censorship for its massive success. Miró herself was disappointed with the fame that the scandal brought to the movie, and would have preferred that it had been less successful so long as it was on its own merits, not as a reaction for an attempted persecution.

to:

* StreisandEffect: Critics who ''don't'' like the film (or don't consider it a masterpiece) blame the attempted government censorship for its massive success. Miró herself was disappointed with the fame that the scandal brought to the movie, and would have preferred that it had been less successful so long as it was on its own merits, not as a reaction for an attempted persecution.persecution.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: By focusing almost entirely on Gregorio and León's relationship and torture, the movie misses on a more choral approach showing the motives and interpretations of other characters and how they reacted to the confirmation that the accussed were innocent. The suicides of Don Rufo and Isasa are told in the epilogue but not shown, even though they could make powerful images (Isasa died in his own home and his death was passed as a heart attack; Don Rufo [[FreakierThanFiction drowned himself in wine]]). Finally, the movie ends in 1926 but the legal proceedings about the case continued until 1935, when all the surviving torturers [[TheBadGuyWins were found innocent]]. Taboada lived through the whole process and at one point he met the exhonerated Gregorio and León in Madrid and got in a fight with them.

Added: 479

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RetroactiveRecognition: Pre-fame Guillermo Montesinos as ''El Cepa'' and Assumpta Serna as his ([[UglyGuyHotWife stunning]]) wife. A brief, non-speaking role in the latter case.
* ScrewedByTheNetwork: Released in August, at the time (1981) believed the worst month to release a movie. Still sold [[SleeperHit 3 million tickets]].

to:

* RetroactiveRecognition: Pre-fame Guillermo Montesinos as ''El Cepa'' and Assumpta Serna as his ([[UglyGuyHotWife stunning]]) wife. A brief, one shot, non-speaking role in the latter case.
* ScrewedByTheNetwork: Released in August, at the time (1981) believed the worst month to release a movie. Still sold [[SleeperHit 3 million tickets]].tickets]].
* SleeperHit: Despite (or because) its TroubledProduction, it was a box office record in Spain.
* StreisandEffect: Critics who ''don't'' like the film (or don't consider it a masterpiece) blame the attempted government censorship for its massive success. Miró herself was disappointed with the fame that the scandal brought to the movie, and would have preferred that it had been less successful so long as it was on its own merits, not as a reaction for an attempted persecution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlayingAgainstType: If you are used to watching Hector Alterio playing Argentinian avuncular characters, you will never recognize him as the antagonist HangingJudge Isasa, who has no trace of an Argentinian accent.

to:

* PlayingAgainstType: If you are used to watching Hector Alterio playing Argentinian avuncular characters, you will never recognize him as the antagonist HangingJudge Isasa, who has [[HeReallyCanAct no trace of an Argentinian accent.accent]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EveryoneRemembersTheStripper: This is the movie where a man has his testicles tied to a roof beam. It is also the movie where a terribly thirsty man sucks milk from his terrified, lactating wife while in jail.

to:

* EveryoneRemembersTheStripper: This is the movie where a man has his testicles tied to a roof beam. It is also the movie where a terribly thirsty man sucks milk from his terrified, lactating wife while in jail.jail.
* PlayingAgainstType: If you are used to watching Hector Alterio playing Argentinian avuncular characters, you will never recognize him as the antagonist HangingJudge Isasa, who has no trace of an Argentinian accent.
* RetroactiveRecognition: Pre-fame Guillermo Montesinos as ''El Cepa'' and Assumpta Serna as his ([[UglyGuyHotWife stunning]]) wife. A brief, non-speaking role in the latter case.
* ScrewedByTheNetwork: Released in August, at the time (1981) believed the worst month to release a movie. Still sold [[SleeperHit 3 million tickets]].

Added: 211

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationDisplacement: Averted. There are two novels with the title ''EL Crimen de Cuenca''. However, the first one (from 1932) has nothing to do with the case, and the second (from 1979) is based on the movie script, rather than the opposite.
* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Although ''El Cepa'' is evidently stupid and illiterate, it is ambiguous if he didn't know about his "murder" before the civil guards came to take him to La Osa, or he did, but kept his mouth shut because he feared retribution.

to:

* AdaptationDisplacement: Averted. There are two novels with the title ''EL ''El Crimen de Cuenca''. However, the first one (from 1932) has nothing to do with the case, and the second (from 1979) is based on the movie script, rather than the opposite.
* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Although ''El Cepa'' is evidently stupid and illiterate, it is ambiguous if he didn't know about his "murder" before the civil guards came to take him to La Osa, or he did, but kept his mouth shut because he feared retribution.retribution.
* EveryoneRemembersTheStripper: This is the movie where a man has his testicles tied to a roof beam. It is also the movie where a terribly thirsty man sucks milk from his terrified, lactating wife while in jail.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationDisplacement: Averted. There are two novels with the title ''EL Crimen de Cuenca''. However, the first one (from 1932) has nothing to do with the case, and the second (from 1979) is based on the movie script, rather than the opposite.
* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Although ''El Cepa'' is evidently stupid and illiterate, it is ambiguous if he didn't know about his "murder" before the civil guards came to take him to La Osa, or he did, but kept his mouth shut because he feared retribution.

Top