Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheAdventuresOfElmoInGrouchland

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FridgeBrilliance: The one song that is not in the movie's soundtrack is Huxley's song: "Make it Mine!" Yes, Huxley is that greedy enough that he won't even share his own song with the soundtrack makers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

*UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Zoe uses Elmo's blanket without asking, after he has gone to the trouble of cheering her up when she couldn't go to the zoo. While Elmo goes too far in declaring she isn't his friend for ripping the blanket, he is faulted for wanting to keep his comfort item to himself. At no point, does the movie seem to think Zoe is in the wrong for not giving Elmo back his blanket when he asks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeartwarmingInHindsight: During his interview on Matt Vogel's podcast "Below the Frame", fellow Muppet performer Eric Jacobson revealed that he assisted Frank Oz in performing Bert (a role for which he went uncredited), to which Vogel remembers that he assisted Steve Whitmire in performing Ernie. Around the time the film was released, Jacobson began taking over Oz as Bert (and Grover) until he became his full-time performer beginning in 2002. And while Vogel doesn't perform Ernie, in 2017, he did take over as another one of Whitmire's famous characters: [[Franchise/TheMuppets Kermit the Frog]].

to:

* HeartwarmingInHindsight: During his interview on Matt Vogel's podcast "Below the Frame", fellow Muppet performer Eric Jacobson revealed that he assisted Frank Oz in performing Bert (a role for which he went uncredited), to which Vogel remembers that he assisted Steve Whitmire in performing Ernie. Around the time the film was released, Jacobson began taking over Oz as Bert (and Grover) until he became his full-time performer beginning in 2002. And while Vogel doesn't perform Ernie, in 2017, he did would take over as another one of Whitmire's famous characters: [[Franchise/TheMuppets Kermit the Frog]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeartwarmingInHindsight: During his interview on Matt Vogel's podcast "Below the Frame", fellow Muppet performer Eric Jacobson revealed that he assisted Frank Oz in performing Bert (a role for which he went uncredited), to which Vogel remembers that he assisted Steve Whitmire in performing Ernie. Around the time the film was released, Jacobson began taking over Oz as Bert (and Grover) until he became his full-time performer beginning in 2002. And while Vogel didn't replace Whitmire as Ernie, in 2017, he did take over as another one of Whitmire's famous characters: [[Franchise/TheMuppets Kermit the Frog]].

to:

* HeartwarmingInHindsight: During his interview on Matt Vogel's podcast "Below the Frame", fellow Muppet performer Eric Jacobson revealed that he assisted Frank Oz in performing Bert (a role for which he went uncredited), to which Vogel remembers that he assisted Steve Whitmire in performing Ernie. Around the time the film was released, Jacobson began taking over Oz as Bert (and Grover) until he became his full-time performer beginning in 2002. And while Vogel didn't replace Whitmire as doesn't perform Ernie, in 2017, he did take over as another one of Whitmire's famous characters: [[Franchise/TheMuppets Kermit the Frog]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeartwarmingInHindsight: During his interview on Matt Vogel's podcast "Below the Frame", fellow Muppet performer Eric Jacobson revealed that he assisted Frank Oz in performing Bert (a role for which he went uncredited), to which Vogel remembers that he assisted Steve Whitmire in performing Ernie. Around the time the film was released, Jacobson began taking over Oz as Bert (and Grover) until he became his full-time performer beginning in 2002.

to:

* HeartwarmingInHindsight: During his interview on Matt Vogel's podcast "Below the Frame", fellow Muppet performer Eric Jacobson revealed that he assisted Frank Oz in performing Bert (a role for which he went uncredited), to which Vogel remembers that he assisted Steve Whitmire in performing Ernie. Around the time the film was released, Jacobson began taking over Oz as Bert (and Grover) until he became his full-time performer beginning in 2002. And while Vogel didn't replace Whitmire as Ernie, in 2017, he did take over as another one of Whitmire's famous characters: [[Franchise/TheMuppets Kermit the Frog]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Huxley trying to crush Elmo [[ItMakesSenseInContext with a giant stamp]]. The film's target audience was scared of Huxley and legitimately worried about Elmo, leading to the Bert and Ernie scenes to reassure the audience.

to:

** Huxley trying to crush Elmo [[ItMakesSenseInContext with a giant stamp]]. The film's target initial test audience was scared of Huxley and legitimately worried about Elmo, leading to the Bert and Ernie scenes being made in order to reassure the audience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenAesop: Elmo has a blanket, and an argument over whether his friend Zoe should play with it leads to it landing in Grouchland and being stolen by a kleptomaniac hoarder named Huxley. At one point, the Queen of Trash says that Elmo's clinginess over his blanket makes him "sound like Huxley", which ties into the anti-greed moral. However, Elmo's and Huxley's behaviours were fundamentally different -- Huxley was taking other people's belongings and saying they were his, while Elmo's blanket really ''was'' his.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheProblemWithLicensedGames: The UsefulNotes/GameBoyColor game is extremely easy, even on Hard ([[GoddamnedBoss except for Huxley's Chopper]]), and to accompany with the game's low difficulty, it's also [[ItsShortSoItSucks extremely short]], being only 8 levels long.

to:

* TheProblemWithLicensedGames: The UsefulNotes/GameBoyColor Platform/GameBoyColor game is extremely easy, even on Hard ([[GoddamnedBoss except for Huxley's Chopper]]), and to accompany with the game's low difficulty, it's also [[ItsShortSoItSucks extremely short]], being only 8 levels long.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InformedWrongness: Elmo's attachment to his blanket in this film is presented as him being greedy as well as him refusing to share it with anyone else. However, Elmo's attachment to his blanket comes off less as him being greedy and more as him being a child attached to a security blanket, which is perfectly normal for a child, and not wanting to lose it or have it damaged by someone is also understandable. And Elmo did allow Zoe to hold his blanket for a couple of seconds, but Zoe's refusal to give back something that's not hers and getting into a tug of war over the blanket with Elmo, resulting in Elmo losing it, makes Zoe come off as more of the one being greedy instead of Elmo. [[note]] A Season 50 episode rectifies this issue when Rudy takes Julia's stuffed bunny Fluffster to play with. Julia, who is also autistic, doesn't take too kindly to it and begins throwing a tantrum. Alan explains to Rudy that Julia's bunny is a comfort item that helps her when she's scared or in a bad mood, so it's not for sharing. Rudy understands, as he has a comfort item of his own with his blanket, and apologizes for taking Julia's toy. [[/note]]

to:

* InformedWrongness: Elmo's attachment to his blanket in this film is presented as him being greedy as well as him refusing to share it with anyone else. However, Elmo's attachment to his blanket comes off less as him being greedy and more as him being a child attached to a security blanket, which is perfectly normal for a child, and not wanting to lose it or have it damaged by someone is also understandable. And Elmo did allow Zoe to hold his blanket for a couple of seconds, but Zoe's refusal to give back something that's not hers and getting into a tug of war over the blanket with Elmo, resulting in Elmo losing it, makes Zoe come off as more of the one being greedy instead of Elmo. [[note]] A Season 50 episode rectifies this issue when Rudy takes Julia's stuffed bunny Fluffster to play with. Julia, who is also autistic, doesn't take too kindly to it and begins throwing having a tantrum.meltdown. Alan explains to Rudy that Julia's bunny is a comfort item that helps her when she's scared or in a bad mood, so it's not for sharing. Rudy understands, as he has a comfort item of his own with his blanket, and apologizes for taking Julia's toy. [[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I don't know about you guys, but the portal scene used to give me the creeps when I was a kid.

Added DiffLines:

** While the portal scene does look bright and colorful, it can be pretty scary watching Elmo and his blanket get sucked down different paths. The background music and the bizarre animation of the two portals don't help either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InformedWrongness: Elmo's attachment to his blanket in this film is presented as him being greedy as well as him refusing to share it with anyone else. However, Elmo's attachment to his blanket comes off less as him being greedy and more as him being a child attached to a security blanket, which is perfectly normal for a child, and not wanting to lose it or have it damaged by someone is also understandable. And Elmo did allow Zoe to hold his blanket for a couple of seconds, but Zoe's refusal to give back something that's not hers and getting into a tug of war over the blanket with Elmo, resulting in Elmo losing it, makes Zoe come off as more of the one being greedy instead of Elmo. [[note]] A Season 50 episode rectifies this issue when Rudy takes Julia's stuffed bunny to play with. Julia doesn't take too kindly to it and begins throwing a tantrum. Alan explains to Rudy that Julia's bunny is a comfort item that helps her when she's scared or in a bad mood, so it's not for sharing. Rudy understands and apologizes for taking Julia's toy. [[/note]]

to:

* InformedWrongness: Elmo's attachment to his blanket in this film is presented as him being greedy as well as him refusing to share it with anyone else. However, Elmo's attachment to his blanket comes off less as him being greedy and more as him being a child attached to a security blanket, which is perfectly normal for a child, and not wanting to lose it or have it damaged by someone is also understandable. And Elmo did allow Zoe to hold his blanket for a couple of seconds, but Zoe's refusal to give back something that's not hers and getting into a tug of war over the blanket with Elmo, resulting in Elmo losing it, makes Zoe come off as more of the one being greedy instead of Elmo. [[note]] A Season 50 episode rectifies this issue when Rudy takes Julia's stuffed bunny Fluffster to play with. Julia Julia, who is also autistic, doesn't take too kindly to it and begins throwing a tantrum. Alan explains to Rudy that Julia's bunny is a comfort item that helps her when she's scared or in a bad mood, so it's not for sharing. Rudy understands understands, as he has a comfort item of his own with his blanket, and apologizes for taking Julia's toy. [[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The giant chicken is likewise a well-remembered character, particularly for his dim-witted personality and his performance by Dave Goelz (in one of his few ''Sesame Street''-related appearances).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Did Oscar simply fail to warn the others about Grouchland having a law against asking for help (aware that they were searching for somebody and it would come up), or had such a law passed in the time since Oscar was last there (implied to have been a long time ago, even though the trip is just a portal away in his trash can)?

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Did Oscar simply fail to warn the others about Grouchland having a law against asking for help (aware that they were searching for somebody and it would come up), or had such a law passed in the time since Oscar was last there (implied to have been a long time ago, even though the trip is just a portal away in his trash can)?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AudienceAlienatingPremise: Similar to ''Film/SesameStreetPresentsFollowThatBird'', parents didn't find taking their kids to see Elmo in theaters worth the money when they could just show it to them on television for no charge. Also, this was at the time when Elmo's popularity was subject to HypeBacklash to the point where he has been referred to as the "Little Red Menace" by detractors.

to:

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: Similar to ''Film/SesameStreetPresentsFollowThatBird'', parents didn't find taking their kids to see Elmo in theaters worth the money when they could just show it to them on television for no charge. Also, this was at the time when Elmo's popularity was subject to HypeBacklash to the point where he has been was referred to as the "Little Red Menace" by detractors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AudienceAlienatingPremise: Similar to ''Film/SesameStreetPresentsFollowThatBird'', parents didn't find taking their kids to see Elmo in theaters worth the money when they could just show it to them on television for no charge. Also, this was at the time when Elmo's popularity was being over-hyped to the point where he has been referred to as the "Little Red Menace" by detractors.

to:

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: Similar to ''Film/SesameStreetPresentsFollowThatBird'', parents didn't find taking their kids to see Elmo in theaters worth the money when they could just show it to them on television for no charge. Also, this was at the time when Elmo's popularity was being over-hyped subject to HypeBacklash to the point where he has been referred to as the "Little Red Menace" by detractors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Elmo’s friends rescue mission doesn’t really go anywhere and they spend most of the movie in jail. It doesn’t help that there were more scenes featuring them that got cut from the final product.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Elmo’s friends The Sesame Street residents’ rescue mission doesn’t really go anywhere and they spend most much of the movie in jail. It doesn’t help that there were more scenes featuring them that got cut from the final product.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InformedWrongness: Elmo's attachment to his blanket in this film is presented as him being greedy, as well as him refusing to share it with anyone else. However, Elmo having an attachment towards his blanket comes off as less of him being greedy and more as him being a child attached to a security blanket, which is perfectly normal for a child and not wanting to lose it or have it damaged by someone is also understandable. And Elmo did allow Zoe to hold his blanket for a couple of seconds, but Zoe's refusal to give back something that's not her belonging and getting into a tug of war over the blanket with Elmo, resulting in Elmo losing it, makes Zoe come off as more of the one being greedy instead of Elmo. [[note]] A Season 50 episode rectifies this issue when Rudy takes Julia's stuffed bunny to play with. Julia doesn't take too kindly to it and begins throwing a tantrum. Alan explains to Rudy that Julia's bunny is a comfort item that helps her when she's scared or in a bad mood, so it's not for sharing. Rudy understands and apologizes for taking Julia's toy. [[/note]]

to:

* InformedWrongness: Elmo's attachment to his blanket in this film is presented as him being greedy, greedy as well as him refusing to share it with anyone else. However, Elmo having an Elmo's attachment towards to his blanket comes off as less of as him being greedy and more as him being a child attached to a security blanket, which is perfectly normal for a child child, and not wanting to lose it or have it damaged by someone is also understandable. And Elmo did allow Zoe to hold his blanket for a couple of seconds, but Zoe's refusal to give back something that's not her belonging hers and getting into a tug of war over the blanket with Elmo, resulting in Elmo losing it, makes Zoe come off as more of the one being greedy instead of Elmo. [[note]] A Season 50 episode rectifies this issue when Rudy takes Julia's stuffed bunny to play with. Julia doesn't take too kindly to it and begins throwing a tantrum. Alan explains to Rudy that Julia's bunny is a comfort item that helps her when she's scared or in a bad mood, so it's not for sharing. Rudy understands and apologizes for taking Julia's toy. [[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Something tells me real-life examples are no longer allowed.


** In a meta-sense, this is the final feature-length Muppet film to feature the involvement of Creator/FrankOz and Caroll Spinney before Oz's semi-retirement in 2000 and Spinney's retirement in 2018 (and death the following year), along with the last Sesame Street film to feature Emilio Delgado and Bob [=McGrath=] before their deaths in 2022.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In a meta-sense, this is the final feature-length Muppet film to feature the involvement of Creator/FrankOz and Caroll Spinney before Oz's semi-retirement in 2000 and Spinney's retirement in 2018 (and death the following year), along with the last Sesame Street film to feature Emilio Delgado and Bob McGrath before their deaths in 2022.

to:

** In a meta-sense, this is the final feature-length Muppet film to feature the involvement of Creator/FrankOz and Caroll Spinney before Oz's semi-retirement in 2000 and Spinney's retirement in 2018 (and death the following year), along with the last Sesame Street film to feature Emilio Delgado and Bob McGrath [=McGrath=] before their deaths in 2022.

Top