Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TalentlessNana

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This gets rectified in the second big arc, set after TimeSkip, where the conflict is "Semi-Superpowered Nazis Vs. League of Supervillains/Rebels".

to:

** This gets rectified in the second big arc, set [[spoiler:set after TimeSkip, where the conflict is "Semi-Superpowered Nazis Vs. League of Supervillains/Rebels".]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BaseBreakingCharacter: It is impossible for Nana to find middle ground. Her betrayal of Nakajima in the first episode earned her a large base of hate. Although her relationship with Michiru, her FreudianExcuse, and CharacterDevelopment gave her sympathy, Nakajima's role in her transformation into a villain didn't help much.Her HeelFaceTurn and her TheAtoner, in particular, divided readers over whether she had truly suffered enough punishment and deserved to be forgiven.

to:

* BaseBreakingCharacter: It is impossible for Nana to find middle ground. Her betrayal of Nakajima in the first episode earned her a large base of hate. Although her relationship with Michiru, her FreudianExcuse, and CharacterDevelopment gave her sympathy, Nakajima's role in her transformation into a villain didn't help much.Her HeelFaceTurn and her TheAtoner, in particular, divided readers over whether she had truly suffered enough punishment and deserved to be forgiven.forgiven--and still others felt that her becoming a more moral character actively detracted from what initially made her a unique protagonist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: A few fans have expressed this about Kaori of all people, reasoning being that if she hadn’t taken the poisoned contacts it could of let to some interesting developments such as Nana killing someone personally close to her and one of the last things she said to her best friend before Nana killed her was to go die. The possible guilt from that and a legitimate grudge against Nana for killing someone so close to another character would of led to interesting development, especially if other students began to suspect her instead due to the last message she sent to Kirira, her bullying ways and the fact that she can teleport giving her easy ways to kill anyone from anywhere, would draw accusations with an opportunity for Nana to exploit and manipulate Kaori into gaining her trust if she defends her by “reading her mind”. Also the fact that the story introduces another teleporting girl later on, people felt like Kaori would have fit the role while already being an established character.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: A few fans have expressed this about Kaori of all people, reasoning being that if she hadn’t [[spoiler: taken the poisoned contacts it could of let to some interesting developments such as Nana killing someone personally close to her and one of the last things she said to her best friend before Nana killed her was to go die. The possible guilt from that and a legitimate grudge against Nana for killing someone so close to another character would of led to interesting development, especially if other students began to suspect her instead due to the last message she sent to Kirira, her bullying ways and the fact that she can teleport giving her easy ways to kill anyone from anywhere, would draw accusations with an opportunity for Nana to exploit and manipulate Kaori into gaining her trust if she defends her by “reading her mind”.mind”, leading into character development. Also the fact that the story introduces another teleporting girl later on, people felt like Kaori would have fit the role while already being an established character. ]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: A few fans have expressed this about Kaori of all people, reasoning being that if she hadn’t taken the poisoned contacts it could of let to some interesting developments such as Nana killing someone personally close to her and one of the last things she said to her best friend before Nana killed her was to go die. The possible guilt from that and a legitimate grudge against Nana for killing someone so close to another character would of led to interesting development, especially if other students began to suspect her instead due to the last message she sent to Kirira, her bullying ways and the fact that she can teleport giving her easy ways to kill anyone from anywhere, would draw accusations with an opportunity for Nana to exploit and manipulate Kaori into gaining her trust if she defends her by “reading her mind”. Also the fact that the story introduces another teleporting girl later on, people felt like Kaori would have fit the role while already being an established character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Woolseyism}}: The french title for the series is simple "Talentless", which really fits for a FirstEpisodeTwist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BaseBreakingCharacter: It is impossible for Nana to find middle ground. Her betrayal of Nakajima in the first episode earned her a large base of hate. Although her relationship with Michiru, her FreudianExcuse, and CharacterDevelopment gave her sympathy, Nakajima's role in her transformation into a villain didn't help much.Her heelfaceturn and her theatoner, in particular, divided readers over whether she had truly suffered enough punishment and deserved to be forgiven.

to:

* BaseBreakingCharacter: It is impossible for Nana to find middle ground. Her betrayal of Nakajima in the first episode earned her a large base of hate. Although her relationship with Michiru, her FreudianExcuse, and CharacterDevelopment gave her sympathy, Nakajima's role in her transformation into a villain didn't help much.Her heelfaceturn HeelFaceTurn and her theatoner, TheAtoner, in particular, divided readers over whether she had truly suffered enough punishment and deserved to be forgiven.

Top