Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Macbeth1971

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Applicability}}: Film scholars have interpreted this version's violence, brutality and cynicism as being responses not just to the Manson Family murders - but also the Vietnam War and the assassination of Martin Luther King.
* BestKnownForTheFanservice: The film was highly remembered for the ScrubbingOffTheTrauma scene happening while Lady Macbeth is naked - although GodivaHair covers everything, and the context makes it decidedly un-sexy, making this more accurately "Best Known For The Fan Disservice".

to:

* {{Applicability}}: Film scholars have interpreted this version's violence, brutality and cynicism as being responses not just to the Manson Family murders - but also the Vietnam War UsefulNotes/TheVietnamWar and the assassination of Martin Luther King.UsefulNotes/MartinLutherKingJr.
* BestKnownForTheFanservice: The film was is highly remembered for the ScrubbingOffTheTrauma scene happening while Francesca Annis's Lady Macbeth is being naked - although with GodivaHair covers everything, and for the context makes it decidedly un-sexy, making this more accurately "Best Known For The Fan Disservice"."out damned spot" mad scene. It's probably supposed to be FanDisservice as her NakedNutter freakout underscores her madness, but then again, she's awfully good-looking.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VindicatedByHistory: The film was dismissed at the time it was released, being seen as a lot of senseless violence that evoked the Manson Family murders and cheap nudity for the sake of {{Fanservice}}. Francesca Annis too was seen as a horrendous miscasting as Lady Macbeth, being thought too young and "a better fit for ''Series/MelrosePlace''", in one critic's words. Over time the film has been seen in a better light, and Francesca Annis's performance too is seen as a refreshing take on Lady Macbeth's more ObviouslyEvil image - opting for a BitchInSheepsClothing, LightIsNotGood take.

to:

* VindicatedByHistory: The film was dismissed at the time it was released, being seen as a lot of senseless violence that evoked the Manson Family murders and cheap nudity for the sake of {{Fanservice}}. {{Fanservice}}, in addition to Francesca Annis too was being seen as a horrendous miscasting as Lady Macbeth, being thought too young and for the role. This sentiment actually lingered on for quite some time, as a critic in a 2002 review described Annis as "a better fit for ''Series/MelrosePlace''", in one critic's words.''Series/MelrosePlace''". Over time the film has been seen in a better light, and Francesca Annis's performance too is seen as a refreshing take on Lady Macbeth's more ObviouslyEvil image - opting for a BitchInSheepsClothing, LightIsNotGood take.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope renamed and redefined per TRS


* BestKnownForTheFanservice: The film was highly remembered for the OutDamnedSpot scene happening while Lady Macbeth is naked - although GodivaHair covers everything, and the context makes it decidedly un-sexy, making this more accurately "Best Known For The Fan Disservice".

to:

* BestKnownForTheFanservice: The film was highly remembered for the OutDamnedSpot ScrubbingOffTheTrauma scene happening while Lady Macbeth is naked - although GodivaHair covers everything, and the context makes it decidedly un-sexy, making this more accurately "Best Known For The Fan Disservice".

Added: 222

Removed: 220

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrowningMomentOfAwesome: Banquo saving his son by aiming and shooting an arrow across the river at his son's assailant. Sadly, this requires him to turn his back on his ''own'' assailant, and he is killed as a result.


Added DiffLines:

* SugarWiki/MomentOfAwesome: Banquo saving his son by aiming and shooting an arrow across the river at his son's assailant. Sadly, this requires him to turn his back on his ''own'' assailant, and he is killed as a result.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CrowningMomentOfAwesome: Banquo saving his son by aiming and shooting an arrow across the river at his son's assailant. Sadly, this requires him to turn his back on his ''own'' assailant, and he is killed as a result.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: When Macbeth goes to see the Weird Sisters on the subject of Macduff, he finds them all naked and in the cmpany of many, equally naked witches. It is the only time these witches appear, so it just causes the question of who they are?

to:

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: When Macbeth goes to see the Weird Sisters on the subject of Macduff, he finds them all naked and in the cmpany company of many, equally naked witches. It is the only time these witches appear, so it just causes the question of who they are?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: The added ending with Donalbain going to visit the witches could be interpreted cynically - with the possibility that the CycleOfRevenge will continue. Or you could look at it more positively, with Donalbain going to punish the witches for their role in his father's death and preventing them from causing any more destruction to the kingdom.

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: The added ending with Donalbain going to visit the witches could be interpreted cynically - with the possibility that the CycleOfRevenge will continue. Or you could look at it more positively, with Donalbain going to punish the witches for their role in his father's death and preventing them from causing any more destruction to the kingdom.kingdom, however the historical Donalbain's ascension to the throne leaves little room for this interpretation unfortunately.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BestKnownForTheFanservice: The film was highly remembered for the OutDamnedSpot scene happening while Lady Macbeth is naked - although GodivaHair covers everything, and the context makes it decidedly un-sexy, making this more accurately "Best Known For The Fandisservice".

to:

* BestKnownForTheFanservice: The film was highly remembered for the OutDamnedSpot scene happening while Lady Macbeth is naked - although GodivaHair covers everything, and the context makes it decidedly un-sexy, making this more accurately "Best Known For The Fandisservice".Fan Disservice".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BestKnownForTheFanservice: The film was highly remembered for the OutDamnedSpot scene happening while Lady Macbeth is naked - although GodivaHair covers everything, and the context makes it decidedly un-sexy.

to:

* BestKnownForTheFanservice: The film was highly remembered for the OutDamnedSpot scene happening while Lady Macbeth is naked - although GodivaHair covers everything, and the context makes it decidedly un-sexy.un-sexy, making this more accurately "Best Known For The Fandisservice".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: When Macbeth goes to see the Weird Sisters on the subject of Macduff, he finds them all naked and in the cmpany of many, equally naked witches. It is the only time these witches appear, so it just causes the question of who they are?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jon Finch later starred in ''Literature/DeathOnTheNile'', getting engaged to a character played by Creator/OliviaHussey - who had famously played Juliet in ''Film/RomeoAndJuliet1968''.
** Jon Finch was also the first choice for Doyle in ''Series/TheProfessionals'', which went to Martin Shaw when he turned it down. Martin Shaw played Banquo in this version.

to:

** Jon Finch Creator/JonFinch later starred in ''Literature/DeathOnTheNile'', getting engaged to a character played by Creator/OliviaHussey - who had famously played Juliet in ''Film/RomeoAndJuliet1968''.
** Jon Finch was also the first choice for Doyle in ''Series/TheProfessionals'', which went to Martin Shaw Creator/MartinShaw when he turned it down. Martin Shaw played Banquo in this version.



* RealismInducedHorror: Roman Polanski drew on his childhood memories of the SS ransacking his house for the scene where Lady Macduff is murdered - and that makes it all the more harrowing.
** It is also worth remembering that this was Polanski's first film after a hiatus following the murder of his wife.

to:

* RealismInducedHorror: Roman Polanski Creator/RomanPolanski drew on his childhood memories of the SS ransacking his house for the scene where Lady Macduff is murdered - and that makes it all the more harrowing.
** It is also worth remembering that this was Polanski's first film after a hiatus following the murder of his wife.Creator/SharonTate.



* VindicatedByHistory: The film was dismissed at the time it was released, being seen as a lot of senseless violence that evoked the Manson Family murders and cheap nudity for the sake of {{Fanservice}}. Francesca Annis too was seen as a horrendous miscasting as Lady Macbeth, being thought too young and "a better fit for ''Series/MelrosePlace''", in one critic's words. Over time the film has been seen in a better light, and Francesca Annis's performance too is seen as a refreshing take on Lady Macbeth's more ObviouslyEvil image - opting for a BitchInSheepsClothing, LightIsNotGood take.

to:

* VindicatedByHistory: The film was dismissed at the time it was released, being seen as a lot of senseless violence that evoked the Manson Family murders and cheap nudity for the sake of {{Fanservice}}. Francesca Annis too was seen as a horrendous miscasting as Lady Macbeth, being thought too young and "a better fit for ''Series/MelrosePlace''", in one critic's words. Over time the film has been seen in a better light, and Francesca Annis's performance too is seen as a refreshing take on Lady Macbeth's more ObviouslyEvil image - opting for a BitchInSheepsClothing, LightIsNotGood take.take.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It is also worth remembering that this was Polanski's first film after a hiatus following the murder of SharonTate.

to:

** It is also worth remembering that this was Polanski's first film after a hiatus following the murder of SharonTate.his wife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It is also worth remembering that this was Polanski's first film after a hiatus following the murder of SharonTate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** At the time, the decision to make Lady Macbeth younger was seen as a controversial one - since she's usually depicted as middle-aged or older than her husband; taking historical fact into account, Macbeth was her second husband, suggesting she was older (although in Middle Age Britain, girls were married as young as twelve, so her being married twice and still being a young twentysomething is plausible). Over the years however, opinions have softened towards how she plays the character (see below).

to:

** At the time, the decision to make Lady Macbeth younger was seen as a controversial one - since she's usually depicted as middle-aged or older than her husband; taking historical fact into account, Macbeth was her second husband, suggesting and she was older (although in either his age or a decade younger (in Middle Age Britain, girls were married as young as twelve, so her being married twice and still being a young twentysomething is plausible). Over the years however, opinions have softened towards how she plays the character (see below).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Sadly Malcolm's role is downplayed, despite having a RADA graduate and talented actor in Stephan Chase.
* VindicatedByHistory: The film was dismissed at the time it was released, being seen as a lot of senseless violence that evoked the Manson Family murders and cheap nudity for the sake of {{Fanservice}}. Francesca Annis too was seen as a horrendous miscasting as Lady Macbeth, being thought too young and "a better fit for ''Series/MelrosePlace''. Over time the film has been seen in a better light, and Francesca Annis's performance too is seen as a refreshing take on Lady Macbeth's more Obviously Evil image - opting for a BitchInSheepsClothing, LightIsNotGood take.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Sadly Sadly, Malcolm's role is downplayed, despite having a RADA graduate and talented actor in Stephan Chase.
* VindicatedByHistory: The film was dismissed at the time it was released, being seen as a lot of senseless violence that evoked the Manson Family murders and cheap nudity for the sake of {{Fanservice}}. Francesca Annis too was seen as a horrendous miscasting as Lady Macbeth, being thought too young and "a better fit for ''Series/MelrosePlace''. ''Series/MelrosePlace''", in one critic's words. Over time the film has been seen in a better light, and Francesca Annis's performance too is seen as a refreshing take on Lady Macbeth's more Obviously Evil ObviouslyEvil image - opting for a BitchInSheepsClothing, LightIsNotGood take.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: The added ending with Donalbain going to visit the witches could be interpreted cynically - with the possibility that the CycleOfRevenge will continue. Or you could look at it more positively, with Donalbain going to punish the witches for their role in his father's death and preventing them from causing any more destruction to the kingdom.
* {{Applicability}}: Film scholars have interpreted this version's violence, brutality and cynicism as being responses not just to the Manson Family murders - but also the Vietnam War and the assassination of Martin Luther King.
* BestKnownForTheFanservice: The film was highly remembered for the OutDamnedSpot scene happening while Lady Macbeth is naked - although GodivaHair covers everything, and the context makes it decidedly un-sexy.
* BrokenBase:
** The FaceHeelDoorSlam in Macbeth's murder of Duncan. Some hate the change, finding it takes away any agency in what Macbeth does. Others find it an interesting way to play with the murder.
** At the time, the decision to make Lady Macbeth younger was seen as a controversial one - since she's usually depicted as middle-aged or older than her husband; taking historical fact into account, Macbeth was her second husband, suggesting she was older (although in Middle Age Britain, girls were married as young as twelve, so her being married twice and still being a young twentysomething is plausible). Over the years however, opinions have softened towards how she plays the character (see below).
* HilariousInHindsight:
** Jon Finch later starred in ''Literature/DeathOnTheNile'', getting engaged to a character played by Creator/OliviaHussey - who had famously played Juliet in ''Film/RomeoAndJuliet1968''.
** Jon Finch was also the first choice for Doyle in ''Series/TheProfessionals'', which went to Martin Shaw when he turned it down. Martin Shaw played Banquo in this version.
* NightmareFuel: The film has a BloodierAndGorier reputation for a reason!
** One of the earliest scenes has an execution victim leaping to his death by hanging, which is done by a chain.
** The aftermath of Duncan's murder, where the scapegoats are slaughtered. In this version, it looks like Lady Macbeth's fainting is for real because of it.
** A subtle scene is Lady Macbeth realising how much more bloodshed is going to happen because of the plan. The way Francesca Annis says "what's to be done?" suggests she's terrified at what'll happen.
** The massacre of Castle Macduff. Lady Macduff's conversation with her son is interrupted by screaming, and she then sees a serving girl being raped in the hallway. Her son is stabbed in front of her and she flees to another room, where she discovers the bodies of the rest of her children, and her estate in flames. We don't see how she dies, but [[NothingIsScarier we probably don't want to]].
* OvershadowedByControversy: The stories of the film's brutality and nudity were generating a buzz about just how gory or explicit it would be - especially an anecdote from set that producers were trying to get Roman Polanski to tone some of the violence down. Some viewers were then surprised that there was less {{Gorn}} than promised.
* RealismInducedHorror: Roman Polanski drew on his childhood memories of the SS ransacking his house for the scene where Lady Macduff is murdered - and that makes it all the more harrowing.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Sadly Malcolm's role is downplayed, despite having a RADA graduate and talented actor in Stephan Chase.
* VindicatedByHistory: The film was dismissed at the time it was released, being seen as a lot of senseless violence that evoked the Manson Family murders and cheap nudity for the sake of {{Fanservice}}. Francesca Annis too was seen as a horrendous miscasting as Lady Macbeth, being thought too young and "a better fit for ''Series/MelrosePlace''. Over time the film has been seen in a better light, and Francesca Annis's performance too is seen as a refreshing take on Lady Macbeth's more Obviously Evil image - opting for a BitchInSheepsClothing, LightIsNotGood take.

Top