History YMMV / HazbinHotel

** ''Vaggie Carmine AU'': Following episodes 6 and 7, stories where Vaggie is HappilyAdopted by Carmilla Carmine, often after [[spoiler:the latter finds her after Lute maims her instead of Charlie,]] began to spring up, both due to fans adoring the mentor/student bond and Vaggie being Carmine's daughter being a popular theory about her origins.

** ''Vaggie Carmine AU'': Following episodes 6 and 7, stories where Vaggie is HappilyAdopted by Carmilla Carmine, [[spoiler:often after the latter finds her after Lute maims her instead of Charlie,]] began to spring up, both due to fans adoring the mentor/student bond and Vaggie being Carmine's daughter being a popular theory about her origins.

** ''Vaggie Carmine AU'': Following episodes 6 and 7, stories where [[spoiler:Vaggie is HappilyAdopted by Carmilla Carmine, often after the latter finds her after Lute maims her instead of Charlie, began to spring up, both due to fans adoring the mentor/student bond and Vaggie being Carmine's daughter being a popular theory about her origins.]]

** Due to their large resemblance to each other and the presence of kids among them, as well as a comment by [[WordOfSaintPaul Faustisse]] about how Rosie "didn't die", many are convinced the inhabitants of Cannibal Town aren't Sinners, but ''Hellborn'' instead, specifically due to the rule that Sinners can't have children and that the children were likely born rather than damned. Nowhere in the series proper is it suggested though that they are anything other than Sinners, the children being Sinners too who implicitly died young and were damned for being cannibalistic. If anything their being Hellborn would just make it [[spoiler:''worse'' for Vaggie, as the reason she was mutilated by Lute was for showing mercy to a ''Sinner'', when the terms of the exterminations state that Hellborn are ''off limits'', meaning Vaggie would have been punished for ''following the rules'' rather than her proving better than other exorcists via an act of mercy.]] It also doesn't help that Rosie is an Overlord, a group comprised solely of Sinners as far as we know.[[labelnote:*]]Counterarguments include the fact that Vassago of the [[WebAnimation/HelluvaBoss Goetia]] was shown in the group shot of Overlords from Vaggie's story in the "Pilot", but Vassago isn't stated to be an Overlord in the series proper, and the "Pilot" itself already had EarlyInstallmentWeirdness regarding the presence of certain characters, like Blitzo and Loona's concept designs showing up in the studio watching Charlie's interview.[[/labelnote]]
* ContinuityLockout:

** Due to their large resemblance to each other and the presence of kids among them, many are convinced the inhabitants of Cannibal Town aren't Sinners, but ''Hellborn'' instead, specifically due to the rule that Sinners can't have children and that the children were likely born rather than damned. Nowhere in the series proper is it suggested though that they are anything other than Sinners, the children being Sinners too who implicitly died young and were damned for being cannibalistic. If anything their being Hellborn would just make it [[spoiler:''worse'' for Vaggie, as the reason she was mutilated by Lute was for showing mercy to a ''Sinner'', when the terms of the exterminations state that Hellborn are ''off limits'', meaning Vaggie would have been punished for ''following the rules'' rather than her proving better than other exorcists via an act of mercy.]] It also doesn't help that Rosie is an Overlord, a group comprised solely of Sinners as far as we know.[[labelnote:*]]Counterarguments include the fact that Vassago of the [[WebAnimation/HelluvaBoss Goetia]] was shown in the group shot of Overlords from Vaggie's story in the "Pilot", but Vassago isn't stated to be an Overlord in the series proper, and the "Pilot" itself already had EarlyInstallmentWeirdness regarding the presence of certain characters, like Blitzo and Loona's concept designs showing up in the studio watching Charlie's interview.[[/labelnote]]

* EveryoneIsSatanInHell: Being a show that takes place in Hell with the protagonist being the daughter of Lucifer, this backlash would inevitably happen. As soon as the first trailer appeared, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OUN4FdH1_VA several videos]] from [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=094Gtne9BHw conservative Christians accused the show]] of "glorifying Satanism" and presenting Satan as a good guy, in addition to mocking Christianity, in an animated series "clearly intended for viewing by young children."

** Vox is a cruel, exploitative CorruptCorporateExecutive who hypnotizes entire masses into buying his morally-questionable products, doesn't seem to care about his teammate and implicit boyfriend Valentino's sexual abuser habits, and he spitefully outright shrieks at Sir Pentious to grow and change as a person in the second episode for failing so quickly at a task. But he has a suave and charming personality, with a ''very'' smooth voice courtesy of Creator/ChristianBorle -- an effect that's heightened by how he seems to be the minder to Val's impulses -- and his exasperation at being forced to babysit his teammates when they're in a bad mood makes him come across as very human and relatable. It also helps that he has an ''intense'' obsessive rivalry with Alastor, but his insecure if stylish efforts to undermine the Radio Demon in their QuarrelingSong and the final outcome of that make Vox's efforts to outdo Al come across as nothing but ''cute''.