History YMMV / CinderellaPhenomenon

* EvilIsSexy: [[spoiler:Hildyr, despite being a depraved WickedWitch, is quite beautiful.]]
** Though not ''completely'' evil, Varg is pretty good-looking in his own right. Justfied, as he is the [[spoiler:[[JekyllandHyde Hyde to Fritz's Jekyll]], and thus looks just like him.]]

** His route in Evermore also has Lucette [[UnfortunateImplications fail to find Waltz]] while gathering information about former witches being targeted by angry humans. Maybe he's just hard to track down because she doesn't know exactly where he lives, but given the information she's looking for and that he's not seen again in Fritz's route, [[KilledOffScreen maybe not]].

** His route in Evermore also has Lucette [[UnfortunateImplications fail to find Waltz]] while gathering information about former witches being targeted by angry humans. Maybe he's just hard to track down because she doesn't know exactly where he lives, but given the information she's looking for, and that he's not seen again in Fritz's route, [[KilledOffScreen maybe not]].

* TheWoobie: Poor Fritz has arguably the most bittersweet of the routes due [[spoiler: to how many of Lucette's loved ones are killed]], but he also gets the short end of the stick in just about everyone else's route too. [[spoiler: He's killed in Karma's, Disappears because no one knew was cursed in both Rumpel's and Rod's, and in Waltz's, he was thrown in prison until his curse could be broken because even he knew he couldn't be trusted. Then after he is pardoned, he's demoted from being Lucette's personal knight.]]

* TheWoobie: Poor Fritz has arguably the most bittersweet of the routes due [[spoiler: to how many of Lucette's loved ones are killed]], but he also gets the short end of the stick in just about everyone else's route too. [[spoiler: He's killed in Karma's, Disappears because no one knew was cursed in Rumpel's, and in Waltz's, he was thrown in prison until his curse could be broken because even he knew he couldn't be trusted. Then after he is pardoned, he's demoted from being Lucette's personal knight.]]

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: While there's no denying [[spoiler:Hildyr]] is a vile villain now, there's some justification in story for the madness displayed, as [[spoiler:during the Witch Hunt she felt [[BeingTorturedMakesYouEvil the death of every witch as if it were her own]]. But even then, it was only after the king at the time voiced approval of the Hunt that [[ThenLetMeBeEvil she started]] [[DisproportionateRetribution wrecking everything]] to save her own kind from the [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters humans]]]].

* TheWoobie: Poor Fritz has arguably the most bittersweet of the routes due [[spoiler: to how many of Lucette's loved ones are killed]], but he also gets the short end of the stick in just about everyone else's route too. [[spoiler: He's killed in Karma's, Disappears because no one knew was cursed in Rumpel's, and in Waltz's, he was thrown in prison until his curse could be broken because even he knew he couldn't be trusted. Then after he is pardoned, he's demoted from being Lucette's personal knight.]]

-->'''Lucette''': ''I will not collapse. I am stronger than that. Mother taught me how to be strong.''

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: While there's no denying [[spoiler:Hildyr]] is a vile villain now, there's some justification in story for her madness, as [[spoiler:during the Witch Hunt she felt [[BeingTorturedMakesYouEvil the death of every witch as if it were her own]]. But even then, it was only after the king at the time voiced approval of the Hunt that [[ThenLetMeBeEvil she started]] [[DisproportionateRetribution wrecking everything]] to save her own kind from the [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters humans]]]].

** [[spoilersHildyr has already crossed it in the past, but a very notable one in-story would be when she attacks Lucette in Fritz's route, or when she renders her an EmptyShell in Waltz's bad ending.]]

* CompleteMonster: [[spoiler:[[WickedWitch Hildyr]] is a witch who has a [[MisanthropeSupreme huge resentment towards humans]]. Prior to the main story, she murdered the ten-year-old daughter of her former friend, Delora, out of spite. She killed the then-king of Angielle, and became the first witch to kill a human. She forced his son to marry her after threatening to kill the woman he loves, raped him, then kept him away from their daughter for ''years'' under threat of taking her away from him completely. She proceeds to [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen use her new position as the Queen of Angellie]] to make it a living hell after she kickstarts the war of humans, fairies and witches alike. When a certain family refused to gave their son to Hildyr because he was a magically gifted witch, she murders them and then turns the son into her own apprentice. She is also [[AbusiveParents emotionally and mentally abusive]] towards her daughter, Lucette, brainwashing her and isolating her from the outside world. In one of the bad endings, Hildyr then tries to forcibly absorbs Lucette's magic power and does not hesitate to render her an EmptyShell when Lucette refuses to cooperate with her. She then use her daughter's current state to force her former apprentice to working with her again]].]]

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: While there's no denying Hildyr is a CompleteMonster now, there's some justification in story for her madness as during the Witch Hunt she felt [[BeingTorturedMakesYouEvil the death of every witch as if it were her own]], but even then, it was only after the king [[spoiler: at the time voiced approval of the Hunt]] that [[ThenLetMeBeEvil she started]] [[DisproportionateRetribution wrecking everything]] to save her own kind from the [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters humans]].
* CompleteMonster: [[WickedWitch Hildyr]] is [[spoiler:a witch who has a [[MisanthropeSupreme huge resentment towards humans]]. Prior to the main story, she murdered the ten-year-old daughter of her former friend, Delora, out of spite. She killed the then-king of Angielle, and became the first witch to kill a human. She forced his son to marry her after threatening to kill the woman he loves, raped him, then kept him away from their daughter for ''years'' under threat of taking her away from him completely. She proceeds to [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen use her new position as the Queen of Angellie]] to make it a living hell after she kickstarts the war of humans, fairies and witches alike. When a certain family refused to gave their son to Hildyr because he was a magically gifted witch, she murders them and then turns the son into her own apprentice]]. She is also [[AbusiveParents emotionally and mentally abusive]] towards her daughter, Lucette, brainwashing her and isolating her from the outside world. [[spoiler:In one of the bad endings, Hildyr then tries to forcibly absorbs Lucette's magic power and does not hesitate to render her an EmptyShell when Lucette refuses to cooperate with her. She then use her daughter's current state to force her former apprentice to working with her again]].
* EvilIsSexy: Hildyr, despite being a CompleteMonster, is quite beautiful.

** Hildyr has already crossed it in the past, but a very notable one in-story would be [[spoiler:when she attacks Lucette in Fritz's route, or when she renders her an EmptyShell in Waltz's bad ending.]]

** Alcaster crosses it in Karma's route when he [[spoiler:completely willingly and without emotion kills his own son.]] Made worse by Fritz still being very much broken up about [[spoiler: ''his'' death in Walts' route.]]
** Hildyr has already crossed it in the past, but a very notable one in-story would be [[spoiler:when she attacks Lucette in Fritz's route or when she renders her an EmptyShell in Waltz's bad ending.]]

* CompleteMonster: [[WickedWitch Hildyr]] is [[spoiler:a witch who has a [[MisanthropeSupreme huge resentment towards humans]]. Prior to the main story, she murdered the ten-year-old daughter of her former friend, Delora, out of spite. She killed the then-king of Angielle, and became the first witch to kill a human. She forced his son to marry her after threatening to kill the woman he loves, raped him, then kept him away from their daughter for ''years'' under threat of taking her away from him completely. She proceeds to [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen use her new position as the Queen of Angellie]] to make it a living hell after she kickstarts the war of humans, fairies and witches alike. When a certain family refused to gave their son to Hildyr because he was a magically gifted witch, she murders them and then turns the son into her own apprentice]]. She is also [[AbusiveParents emotionally and mentally abusive]] towards her daughter, Lucette, brainwashing her and isolating her from the outside world. [[spoiler:In one of the bad endings, Hildyr then tries to forcibly absorbs Lucette's magic power and does not hesitate to render her an EmptyShell when Lucette refuses to cooperate with her. She then use her daughter's current state to force her former apprentice to working with her again]]. Despite being good a long time ago, Hildyr commits her atrocities with her own free will and is motivated to do so by hatred towards humans at best and her sadistic whims at worst.

** AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: While there's no denying Hildyr is a CompleteMonster now, it is worth noting that during the Witch Hunt she felt [[BeingTorturedMakesYouEvil the death of every witch as if it were her own]], but even then, it was only after the king [[spoiler: at the time voiced approval of the Hunt]] that [[ThenLetMeBeEvil she started]] [[DisproportionateRetribution wrecking everything]] to save her own kind from the [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters humans]].

** [[AlternativeCharacterInterpretation While there's no denying]] Hildyr is a CompleteMonster now, it is worth noting that during the Witch Hunt she felt [[BeingTorturedMakesYouEvil the death of every witch as if it were her own]], but even then, it was only after the king [[spoiler: at the time voiced approval of the Hunt]] that [[ThenLetMeBeEvil she started]] [[DisproportionateRetribution wrecking everything]] to save her own kind from the [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters humans]].
** To a considerably lesser degree, Alcaster is this. Not only does he [[spoiler: [[AbusiveParents have his ''own son'' cursed]] to make him complicit in his coup plans, but he actively encourages Varg to take over, which would effectively erase Fritz's existence all together.]] On a general level, he believes ruling with fear is the best way to rule and praised Hildyr's reign over the "soft" rule of Lucette's father.

** [[AlternativeCharacterInterpretation While there's no denying]] Hildyr is a CompleteMonster now, it is worth noting that during the Witch Hunt she felt [[BeingTorturedMakesYouEvil the death of every witch as if it were her own]], but it was only after the king [[spoiler: at the time voiced approval of the Hunt]] that [[ThenLetMeBeEvil she started]] [[DisproportionateRetribution wrecking everything]] to save her own kind from the [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters humans]].

* CompleteMonster: [[WickedWitch Hildyr]] is [[spoiler:a witch who has a [[MisanthropeSupreme huge resentment towards humans]]. Prior to the main story, she murdered the ten-year-old daughter of her former friend, Delora, out of spite. She killed the then-king of Angellie, and became the first witch to kill a human. She forced his son to marry her after threatening to kill the woman he loves, raped him, then kept him away from their daughter for ''years'' under threat of taking her away from him completely. She proceeds to [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen use her new position as the Queen of Angellie]] to make it a living hell after she kickstarts the war of humans, fairies and witches alike. When a certain family refused to gave their son to Hildyr because he was a magically gifted witch, she murders them and then turns the son into her own apprentice]]. She is also [[AbusiveParents emotionally and mentally abusive]] towards her daughter, Lucette, brainwashing her and isolating her from the outside world. [[spoiler:In one of the bad endings, Hildyr then tries to forcibly absorbs Lucette's magic power and does not hesitate to render her an EmptyShell when Lucette refuses to cooperate with her. She then use her daughter's current state to force her former apprentice to working with her again]]. Despite being good a long time ago, Hildyr commits her atrocities with her own free will and is motivated to do so by hatred towards humans at best and her sadistic whims at worst.

EvilIsSexy: Hildyr, despite being a CompleteMonster, is quite beautiful.

DracoInLeatherPants: Varg has a considerable fanbase despite functioning as an antagonist through most of the game.

EvilIsSexy: Though not ''entirely'' evil, Varg has a considerable sized fanbase despite functioning as an antagonist through most of the game.

* CompleteMonster: [[WickedWitch Hildyr]] is [[spoiler:a witch who has a [[MisanthropeSupreme huge resentment towards humans]]. Prior to the main story, she murdered the ten-year-old daughter of her former friend, Delora, out of spite. When she met with the King of Angellie, she rapes him and then [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen uses her new position as the Queen of Angellie]] to make it a living hell after she kickstarts the war of humans, fairies and witches alike. When a certain family refused to gave their son to Hildyr because he was a magically gifted witch, she murders them and then turns the son into her own apprentice]]. She is also [[AbusiveParents emotionally and mentally abusive]] towards her daughter, Lucette, brainwashing her and isolating her from the outside world. [[spoiler:In one of the bad endings, Hildyr then tries to forcibly absorbs Lucette's magic power and does not hesitate to render her an EmptyShell when Lucette refuses to cooperate with her. She then use her daughter's current state to force her former apprentice to working with her again]]. Despite being good a long time ago, Hildyr commits her atrocities with her own free will and is motivated to do so by hatred towards humans at best and her sadistic whims at worst.

** Alcaster crosses it in [[spoiler:Karma's]] route when he [[spoiler:completely willingly and without emotion kills his own son.]]

** Hildyr has already crossed it in the past, but a very notable one in-story would be [[spoiler:when she attacks Lucette in Fritz's route or when she renders her an EmptyShell in Waltz's bad ending.]]

* CompleteMonster: [[WickedWitch Hildyr]] is a witch who has a [[MisanthropeSupreme huge resentment towards humans]]. Prior to the main story, she murdered the ten-year-old daughter of her former friend, Delora, out of spite. When she met with the King of Angellie, she rapes him and then [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen uses her new position as the Queen of Angellie]] to make it a living hell after she kickstarts the war of humans, fairies and witches alike. When a certain family refused to gave their son to Hildyr because he was a magically gifted witch, she murders them and then turns the son into her own apprentice. She is also [[AbusiveParents emotionally and mentally abusive]] towards her daughter, Lucette, brainwashing her and isolating her from the outside world. In one of the bad endings, Hildyr then tries to forcibly absorbs Lucette's magic power and does not hesitate to render her an EmptyShell when Lucette refuses to cooperate with her and then use her daughter's current state so that she could force her former apprentice to working with her again. Despite being a good witch a long time ago, Hildyr commits her atrocities with her own free will and is motivated to do so by hatred towards humans at best and her sadistic whims at worst.

* CompleteMonster: [[WickedWitch Hildyr]] is a witch who has a [[MisanthropeSupreme huge resentment towards humans]]. Prior to the main story, she murdered the ten-year-old daughter of her former friend, Delora, out of spite. When she met with the King of Angellie, she forcefully rapes him and then [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen uses her new position as the Queen of Angellie]] to make it a living hell after she kickstarts the war of humans, fairies and witches alike. When a certain family refused to gave their son to Hildyr because he was a magically gifted witch, she murders them with the exception of their son and then turns the son into her own apprentice. She is also [[AbusiveParents emotionally and mentally abusive]] towards her daughter, Lucette, brainwashing her and isolating her from the outside world. In one of the bad endings, Hildyr then tries to forcibly absorbs Lucette's magic power and does not hesitate to render her an EmptyShell when Lucette refuses to cooperate with her and then use her daughter's current state so that she could force her former apprentice to working with her again. Despite being a good witch a long time ago, Hildyr commits her atrocities with her own free will and is motivated to do so by hatred towards humans at best and her sadistic whims at worst.