Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WesternAnimation / TheGoodDinosaur

Go To

OR

Changed: 36

Removed: 438

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not an example with the revised definition of Furry Confusion; every member of a given species in this movie is either sapient or not.


* FriendToAllLivingThings: Forrest Woodbrush aka the Pet Collector.
* FurryConfusion: In particular is that birds seem to be non-anthropomorphic despite being dinosaurs, as well as the fact mammals can't talk so there are no qualms about hunting and eating them. And then there's also the fact pterosaurs are able to speak despite not being dinosaurs.
** And then there are the "chickens", which have clawed hands and long tails and look quite rather like an Oviraptor, but are portrayed as non-intelligent.

to:

* FriendToAllLivingThings: Forrest Woodbrush Woodbrush, aka the Pet Collector.
* FurryConfusion: In particular
Collector, is that birds seem to be non-anthropomorphic despite being dinosaurs, as well as the fact mammals can't talk so there are no qualms about hunting and eating them. And then there's also the fact pterosaurs are able to speak despite not being dinosaurs.
** And then there are the "chickens", which have clawed hands and long tails and look quite rather like an Oviraptor, but are portrayed as non-intelligent.
surrounded by small animals.



** Poppa Henry, Arlo's father, is a better example.

to:

%% ** Poppa Henry, Arlo's father, is a better example.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BaitTheDog: Thunderclap and the pterosaurs come off as rather goofy, as does their ramblings about “the storm”, but caring, and seem to be trying to help dinosaurs and critters injured in the storm. Then Thunderclap devours an adorable critter alive and they fight over it’s remains, and it becomes clear that they are very dangerous.

to:

* BaitTheDog: Thunderclap and the pterosaurs come off as rather goofy, as does their ramblings about “the storm”, but caring, and seem to be trying to help dinosaurs and critters injured in the storm. Then Thunderclap devours an adorable critter alive and they fight over it’s its remains, and it becomes clear that they are very dangerous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ToughArmoredDinosaur: Although none are seen, Nash mentions an encounter with a gang of outlaw ''Stegosaurus'' where one of them hits Nash in the leg with his spiky tail. Nash is no unable to feel anything in his toes.

to:

* ToughArmoredDinosaur: Although none are seen, Nash mentions an encounter with a gang of outlaw ''Stegosaurus'' where one of them hits Nash in the leg with his spiky tail. Nash is no now unable to feel anything in his toes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ToughArmoredDinosaur: Although none are seen, Nash mentions an encounter with a gang of outlaw ''Stegosaurus'' where one of them hits Nash in the leg with his spiky tail. Nash is no unable to feel anything in his toes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Seldom Seen Species is no longer a trope.


* SeldomSeenSpecies: The film features ''Ludodactylus'', ''Caulkicephalus'', ''Guidraco'', and ''Bison latifrons''. Thunderclap resembles a ''Nyctosaurus'', and there's a four-legged snake similar to ''Tetrapodophis''.[[note]]Interestingly, the genus was described two days after the US trailer's release.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateHistory: The movie is set in a world where [[WhatIf non-avian dinosaurs never became extinct]] and Jurassic dinosaurs like ''Apatosaurus'' and ''Stegosaurus'' coexist with Cretaceous dinosaurs like ''Triceratops'' and ''Parasaurolophus'' and even prehistoric mammals like the giant bison ''Bison latifrons'' that existed in the ice ages.

to:

* AlternateHistory: AlternateHistoryDinosaurSurvival: The movie is set in a world where [[WhatIf non-avian dinosaurs never became extinct]] and Jurassic dinosaurs like ''Apatosaurus'' and ''Stegosaurus'' coexist with Cretaceous dinosaurs like ''Triceratops'' and ''Parasaurolophus'' and even prehistoric mammals like the giant bison ''Bison latifrons'' that existed in the ice ages.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HandyMouth: Arlo and his family make up for their lack of hands by using their mouths to grab objects with while managing their farm.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HostileWeather: The storms that occur throughout this film show some of the worst qualities of big storms. There are powerful winds that dislocate a lot of debris and constant rain that cause large flash floods.

Added: 806

Changed: 1103

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseBiology: The very existence of humans and bison in a scenario where dinosaurs never became extinct. In fact the very reason why mammals evolved into larger and more diverse forms was to fill the empty niches left by the dinosaurs' extinction, though in the case of the bison it was probably to add non-sapient livestock to deal with the CarnivoreConfusion of civilized Tyrannosaurs eating civilized herbivore dinos.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseBiology: ArtisticLicenseBiology:
**
The very existence of humans and bison in a scenario where dinosaurs never became extinct. In fact the very reason why mammals evolved into larger and more diverse forms was to fill the empty niches left by the dinosaurs' extinction, though in the case of the bison it was probably to add non-sapient livestock to deal with the CarnivoreConfusion of civilized Tyrannosaurs eating civilized herbivore dinos.



* ArtisticLicensePaleontology: Apatosaurus went extinct ''before'' the meteor hit. Even with the AlternateHistory, Arlo should not exist. That said, other sauropods, namely the titanosaurs, did live all the way to the mass extinction, so with his generic CartoonCreature design Arlo can be Hand Waved as some kind of titanosaur.
** That, however, doesn't explain the T. rex family's encounter with "outlaw stegos", as Stegosaurus lived in the Jurassic: a ''full 80 million years before T. rex''.

to:

* ArtisticLicensePaleontology: ArtisticLicensePaleontology:
**
Apatosaurus went extinct ''before'' the meteor hit. Even with the AlternateHistory, Arlo should not exist. That said, other sauropods, namely the titanosaurs, did live all the way to the mass extinction, so with his generic CartoonCreature design Arlo can be Hand Waved as some kind of titanosaur.
** That, however, doesn't explain the T. rex ''T. rex'' family's encounter with "outlaw stegos", as Stegosaurus lived in the Jurassic: a ''full 80 million years before T. rex''.rex''.
** In a minor note, the scene in which the asteroid misses Earth shows a ''Parasaurolophus'' -- while they did live in Late Cretaceous, they lived only around 76 to 73 million years ago, 7 million years before the asteroid hit.

Added: 250

Changed: 99

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FauxAffablyEvil: The pterodactyls, especially Thunderclap.

to:

* FauxAffablyEvil: The pterodactyls, especially Thunderclap. They seem polite at first, but once they locate a tasty mammal, their savagery becomes very clear.


Added DiffLines:

* FreezeFrameBonus: When Arlo gets bitten by a gopher and falls into a lake, going frame-by-frame shows [[WesternAnimation/FindingDory Hank the septopus]] sitting camouflaged on the lakebed, a year before [[ProductionForeshadowing his actual debut]].

Added: 533

Changed: 191

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicensePaleontology: Apatosaurus went extinct ''before'' the meteor hit. Even with the AlternateHistory, Arlo should not exist.

to:

* ArtisticLicensePaleontology: Apatosaurus went extinct ''before'' the meteor hit. Even with the AlternateHistory, Arlo should not exist. That said, other sauropods, namely the titanosaurs, did live all the way to the mass extinction, so with his generic CartoonCreature design Arlo can be Hand Waved as some kind of titanosaur.
** That, however, doesn't explain the T. rex family's encounter with "outlaw stegos", as Stegosaurus lived in the Jurassic: a ''full 80 million years before T. rex''.
** The four-legged snake Spot fights is supposed to be a ''Tetrapodophis'', but is shown to more closely resemble a viper as opposed to the actual animal which was more lizardlike in appearance. It could be a descendant, given the AlternateHistory setting, though it does raise the question on why snakes would retain their legs if the mass extinction never happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HappilyAdopted: [[spoiler:Spot becomes adopted by a family of traveling cavemen, who quickly bond with him as he does with them, even teaching him how to walk on two legs.]]

to:

* HappilyAdopted: [[spoiler:Spot Spot becomes adopted by a [[spoiler:a family of traveling cavemen, who quickly bond with him as he does with them, even teaching him how to walk on two legs.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HappilyAdopted: [[spoiler:Spot becomes adopted by a family of traveling cavemen, who quickly bond with him as he does with them, even teaching him how to walk on two legs.]]

Added: 169

Changed: 199

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SharkFinOfDoom: Inverted, literally. The second time the pterosaurs appear, it's with their mouths sticking out of the clouds just like this trope, except upside down.

to:

* ShadowArchetype: Thunderclap is exactly what happened if Arlo forgot what fear is.
* SharkFinOfDoom: Inverted, literally. The second time the pterosaurs appear, it's with their mouths sticking out of the clouds just like this trope, except upside down.upside-down.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnimalTalk: Zigzagged. It's clear that humans and dinosaurs can't understand each other, but it's left ambiguous ''why'' they can't understand each other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Sauropod eggs were generally spherical, not shaped like oversized hens' eggs. Also, eggs that are tapered at one end are shaped that way so they won't roll far when disturbed as they lie on their sides; setting them fat-end-down negates the purpose of a tapered shape, and might even impede the embryonic dinosaur's ability to absorb oxygen.

Added: 343

Changed: 35

Removed: 345

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Commented out a zce.


* ArtisticLicenseAstronomy:
** No asteroid belt has asteroids anywhere near that densely packed. They're rarely if ever close enough to be seen from each other.
** We see the asteroid heat up and start to burn as it enters the Earth's atmosphere, but in the next shot, the wide one, it's suddenly far away from Earth again. Of course, RuleOfFunny.



* ArtisticLicensePhysics: On a realistic trajectory, the asteroid would have flown by in a hyperbolic/parabolic trajectory, due to Earth's gravity altering the trajectory of the asteroid.
* AxCrazy: Thunderclap.

to:

* ArtisticLicensePhysics: On a realistic trajectory, the asteroid would have flown by in a hyperbolic/parabolic trajectory, due to Earth's gravity altering the trajectory of the asteroid.
asteroid
* ArtisticLicenseSpace:
** No asteroid belt has asteroids anywhere near that densely packed. They're rarely if ever close enough to be seen from each other.
** We see the asteroid heat up and start to burn as it enters the Earth's atmosphere, but in the next shot, the wide one, it's suddenly far away from Earth again. Of course, RuleOfFunny.
%%*
AxCrazy: Thunderclap.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambiguating; deleting and renaming wicks as appropriate


* FaceOfAThug: Since TyrannosaurusRex are known for looking and being vicious, carnivorous creatures, Arlo was terrified when he ran into them. Luckily for him, they turn out to be {{Gentle Giant}}s.

to:

* FaceOfAThug: Since TyrannosaurusRex ''Tyrannosaurus rex'' are known for looking and being vicious, carnivorous creatures, Arlo was terrified when he ran into them. Luckily for him, they turn out to be {{Gentle Giant}}s.

Added: 224

Changed: 12

Removed: 64

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KingOfTheDinosaurs: Butch and his two children, Nash and Ramsey, are basically ''Tyrannosaurus'' cowboys. Butch in particular is depicted as a hardened, but loving father, and teaches Arlo not to let fear control his life.



* StockDinosaurs: What ordinarily would be a case of ArtisticLicensePaleontology is subverted by the premise of the film: [[WhatIf set in an alternate universe]], where the cataclysmic asteroid that forever changed life on Earth actually missed the planet completely and giant dinosaurs never became extinct. All named dinosaur characters belong to the well-known genera: Arlo and his family are ''Apatosaurus'', Forrest Woodbrush is a ''Styracosaurus'', the cattle rustlers are ''Velociraptor'', and the cattle rancher family are ''TyrannosaurusRex''. ''Parasaurolophus'' make cameo appearances in the opening, and the tie-in toy line features ''Stegosaurus'', ''Triceratops'', and ''Ankylosaurus'' (which were planned to appear in the movie, but were cut out during the revision). The pterosaurs on the other hand avert this, being based on obscure genera such as ''Guidraco'' and ''Caulkicephalus''. Deleted scenes also include the temporally misplaced Non-Dinosaur ''Dimetrodon'', but one possessing mammalian traits like fur and visible ears and serving as the setting's analog to wolves or coyotes.

to:

* StockDinosaurs: What ordinarily would be a case of ArtisticLicensePaleontology is subverted by the premise of the film: [[WhatIf set in an alternate universe]], where the cataclysmic asteroid that forever changed life on Earth actually missed the planet completely and giant dinosaurs never became extinct. All named dinosaur characters belong to the well-known genera: Arlo and his family are ''Apatosaurus'', Forrest Woodbrush is a ''Styracosaurus'', the cattle rustlers are ''Velociraptor'', and the cattle rancher family are ''TyrannosaurusRex''.''UsefulNotes/TyrannosaurusRex''. ''Parasaurolophus'' make cameo appearances in the opening, and the tie-in toy line features ''Stegosaurus'', ''Triceratops'', and ''Ankylosaurus'' (which were planned to appear in the movie, but were cut out during the revision). The pterosaurs on the other hand avert this, being based on obscure genera such as ''Guidraco'' and ''Caulkicephalus''. Deleted scenes also include the temporally misplaced Non-Dinosaur ''Dimetrodon'', but one possessing mammalian traits like fur and visible ears and serving as the setting's analog to wolves or coyotes.



* TyrannosaurusRex: Butch and his two children, Nash and Ramsey.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternativeForeignThemeSong: The ending theme for the Japanese release is [[http://i.xiami.com/song/1775969114 "Best Friend (Mother Earth version)"]] by Kiroro, a rerecorded version of one of their earlier songs.

to:

* AlternativeForeignThemeSong: The ending theme for the Japanese release is [[http://i.xiami.com/song/1775969114 [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8wwqp0ejpJ8 "Best Friend (Mother Earth version)"]] by Kiroro, a rerecorded version of one of their earlier songs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YouExclamation: Arlo says this twice to Spot when he is meeting him again until they befriend each other.

to:

* YouExclamation: Arlo says this twice to Spot when he is meeting him again until they befriend each other.other.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YouAreBetterThanYouThinkYouAre: What Arlo ultimately learns in the course of his adventure.

to:

* YouAreBetterThanYouThinkYouAre: What Arlo ultimately learns in the course of his adventure.adventure.
* YouExclamation: Arlo says this twice to Spot when he is meeting him again until they befriend each other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
quote "The Knight of Cerebus heralds a long-term tone shift in an episodic work and cannot exist within a single installment" unquote


* KnightOfCerebus: Thunderclap and the pterodactyls significantly darken the film’s mood whenever they show up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicensePaleontology: Apatosaurus went extinct ''before'' the meteor hit. Even with the AlternateHistory, Arlo should not exist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
...It literally does though.


** Earth doesn't rotate or move through space.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KnightOfCerberus: Thunderclap and the pterodactyls significantly darken the film’s mood whenever they show up.

to:

* KnightOfCerberus: KnightOfCerebus: Thunderclap and the pterodactyls significantly darken the film’s mood whenever they show up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Pterosaurs couldn't grasp things with their feet, and even if they could, they were far too light to be able to lift a juvenile Apatosaurus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AxCrazy: Thunderclap.


Added DiffLines:

* BaitTheDog: Thunderclap and the pterosaurs come off as rather goofy, as does their ramblings about “the storm”, but caring, and seem to be trying to help dinosaurs and critters injured in the storm. Then Thunderclap devours an adorable critter alive and they fight over it’s remains, and it becomes clear that they are very dangerous.


Added DiffLines:

* KnightOfCerberus: Thunderclap and the pterodactyls significantly darken the film’s mood whenever they show up.
* LargeHam: Thunderclap, especially when he starts ranting about the storm.

Added: 314

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The giant beetle dies instantly upon being beheaded by Spot...even though real-life insects lack blood pressure and don't bleed to death, and have accessory brains in their torsos. In fact, beheaded insects are known to live for days or even ''weeks'', only dying since they can't eat and succumb to starvation.



** And then there are the "chickens", which have clawed hands and long tails and look qite rather like an Oviraptor, but are portrayed as non-intelligent.

to:

** And then there are the "chickens", which have clawed hands and long tails and look qite quite rather like an Oviraptor, but are portrayed as non-intelligent.

Added: 154

Changed: 96

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And then there are the "chickens", which have clawed hands and long tails and look qite rather like an Oviraptor, but are portrayed as non-intelligent.



* PredatorsAreMean: Subverted by the ''T. rex'' family. Played straight, however, with Thunderclap's pterosaur flock and Bubbha's ''Velociraptor'' pack.

to:

* PredatorsAreMean: Subverted by the ''T. rex'' family.family, who farm non-sapient bison livestock and show no interest in eating other, civilized dinosaurs. Played straight, however, with Thunderclap's pterosaur flock and Bubbha's ''Velociraptor'' pack.

Top