Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WesternAnimation / Soul

Go To

OR

Added: 1312

Changed: 4

Removed: 1297

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RealityEnsues:
** Joe falls into a manhole. In most media, an accident like that would be easily brushed off and PlayedForLaughs. In this film, such a fall sends Joe into a comatose state where he's barely clinging to life. Subverted in that once he's back in his body he's running around seemingly with no injuries, broken bones, or any negative effects, not even a mild discomfort or sore muscle. Shocking for someone who was literally on the brink of death earlier that day.
** [[spoiler: While getting out of a cab, Dorothea sees 22 in Joe's body wearing nothing but a hospital gown. Instead of brushing it off as a one-time thing, she immediately decides he's mentally unfit for the gig and hires someone else. It's only after Joe takes back his body and talks to her before the gig that she changes her mind.]]
** After playing with Dorothea, [[spoiler: Joe wonders what happens next, and she answers they do the same thing every night. Realizing it sounds too much like routine, Joe voices how he hoped fulfilling his dream would make him feel different for once. It's Dorothea who has to spell it out that sometimes, fulfilling your dream isn't going to make your life more exciting all at once. It's but a milestone, and sometimes, you may not realize you're already living a good life.]]



** The final piece of footage is Terry popping up from beneath the screen and saying "Oi! Movie’s over! Go home!"
** For the score, [[spoiler: we hear the full song of the rap group Joe was in.]]

to:

** The final piece of footage is Terry popping up from beneath the screen and saying "Oi! Movie’s Movie's over! Go home!"
** For the score, [[spoiler: we hear the full song of the rap group Joe was in.]]in]].


Added DiffLines:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome:
** Joe falls into a manhole. In most media, an accident like that would be easily brushed off and PlayedForLaughs. In this film, such a fall sends Joe into a comatose state where he's barely clinging to life. Subverted in that once he's back in his body he's running around seemingly with no injuries, broken bones, or any negative effects, not even a mild discomfort or sore muscle. Shocking for someone who was literally on the brink of death earlier that day.
** [[spoiler: While getting out of a cab, Dorothea sees 22 in Joe's body wearing nothing but a hospital gown. Instead of brushing it off as a one-time thing, she immediately decides he's mentally unfit for the gig and hires someone else. It's only after Joe takes back his body and talks to her before the gig that she changes her mind.]]
** After playing with Dorothea, [[spoiler: Joe wonders what happens next, and she answers they do the same thing every night. Realizing it sounds too much like routine, Joe voices how he hoped fulfilling his dream would make him feel different for once. It's Dorothea who has to spell it out that sometimes, fulfilling your dream isn't going to make your life more exciting all at once. It's but a milestone, and sometimes, you may not realize you're already living a good life.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AsHimself: An odd example, in which Creator/JohnRatzenberger has [[https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/pixar/images/c/cf/JR_In_Soul.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20210101213800 a non-speaking cameo role in an animated feature]].

to:

* AsHimself: An odd example, in which Creator/JohnRatzenberger Creator/JohnRatzenberger, Pixar's longtime "good luck charm", has [[https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/pixar/images/c/cf/JR_In_Soul.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20210101213800 a non-speaking cameo role in an animated feature]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AsHimself: An odd example, in which Creator/JohnRatzenberger has a non-speaking cameo role in an animated feature.

to:

* AsHimself: An odd example, in which Creator/JohnRatzenberger has [[https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/pixar/images/c/cf/JR_In_Soul.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20210101213800 a non-speaking cameo role in an animated feature.feature]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AsHimself: An odd example, in which Creator/JohnRatzenberger has a non-speaking cameo role in an animated feature.

Added: 61

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Moonwind states that [[spoiler: while his passion was Tetris, his main occupation is helping Lost Souls in "The Zone". This foreshadows that a passion & a purpose are not always the same thing]].

to:

** Moonwind states that [[spoiler: while his passion was Tetris, ''Videogame/{{Tetris}}'', his main occupation is helping Lost Souls in "The Zone". This foreshadows that a passion & a purpose are not always the same thing]].


Added DiffLines:

**Moonwind mentions ''Videogame/{{Tetris}}'' was his passion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Male calico cats are very rare but still possible. Besides, it's more likely Animal Gender Bender than Gender Blender Name.


* GenderBlenderName: The cat is consistently called "Mr. Mittens" by the hospital staff, who thus apparently assume it is male. However, since it is a calico cat (a cat with both red and black fur), it must be a female cat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguousEnding: It isn't clear if [[spoiler: Joe chose to join Dorothea's band or become a full-time teacher after getting his second chance at life [[TakeAThirdOption (assuming he did either of those things)]]. He only says that he is going to live]]

to:

* AmbiguousEnding: It isn't clear if [[spoiler: Joe chose to join Dorothea's band or become a full-time teacher after getting his second chance at life [[TakeAThirdOption (assuming he did either of those things)]]. He only says that he is going to live]]live]].
** This also applies to [[spoiler: 22. We don’t see where her soul ends up; just that she finally chooses to go to Earth.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AfterlifeAngst: This is how Joe makes it into the Great Before. Refusing to accept the fact that he's dead, he attempts to escape, only to accidentally wind up in the Great Before. He then spends a decent amount of the film time trying to get back to his body from said area. Luckily, it turned out to only be a Near-Death Experience for him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GenderBlenderName: The cat is consistently called "Mr. Mittens" by the hospital staff, who thus apparently assume it is male. However, since it is a calico cat (a cat with both red and black fur), it must be a female cat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Also, 22 has another design than the rest of the unborn souls.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AccidentalSuicide: Joe is excitedly talking on the phone about how he finally got a gig and narrowly (and obliviously) dodges a bunch of dangers. Then he accidentally falls to his death into a manhole, which sets off the movie's plot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a Creative License - History entry

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: At one point, Abraham Lincoln is mentoring 22 when she mentions that Lincoln is on the penny while Andrew Jackson is on the $20 bill. It is established early on that mentors guide new souls before moving on to the Great Beyond, so this is presumably taking place shortly after Lincoln's death. However, Lincoln's face was not minted on to the US penny until 44 years after his death in 1909, and Andrew Jackson's face wasn't featured on the $20 bill until 1928.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoubleMeaningTitle: Referring both to [[{{Soul}} the genre of music]], which is Joe's passion, and the spiritual type of soul, with most of the movie centering around Joe trying to reunite his soul with his body.

to:

* DoubleMeaningTitle: Referring both to [[{{Soul}} the genre of music]], which heavily intertwined with the jazz that is Joe's passion, and the spiritual type of soul, with most of the movie centering around Joe trying to reunite his soul with his body.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NotWhereTheyThought: When Joe falls off the conveyor belt leading to the Great Beyond after he's fallen to his death in a manhole, he ends up in the Great Before[[note]]Otherwise known as the You Seminar[[/note]]. He briefly mistakes it for heaven and hell, but one of the Jerrys tells him where he actually is.
-->'''Joe''': Uh, hey, uh, is this heaven?
-->'''Jerry''': ''(chuckles)'' No.
-->'''Joe''': ...Is it [[CensorshipBySpelling H-E-double hockey sticks]]?
-->'''Young souls''': [[EuphemismBuster Hell, hell, hell hell, hell!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheVoiceless: Despite Esther Chae being casted Miho, a bassist in Williams' band, she didn't actually utter a single word throughout the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:E]]

to:

[[folder:E]][[folder:E-I]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:E

to:

[[folder:E[[folder:E]]

Added: 367

Changed: 316

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[foldercontrol]]

[[folder:#-D]]



* EnfanteTerrible: When explaining how souls acquire their personality traits in the Great Before, a new soul is shown that has megalomaniacal, [[ManipulativeBastard manipulative]] and [[OpportunisticBastard opportunistic bastard]] traits, with Jerry [[BlackComedy laughing it off as Earth's problem]].

to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:E
* EnfanteTerrible: EnfantTerrible: When explaining how souls acquire their personality traits in the Great Before, a new soul is shown that has megalomaniacal, [[ManipulativeBastard manipulative]] and [[OpportunisticBastard opportunistic bastard]] traits, with Jerry [[BlackComedy laughing it off as Earth's problem]].



* FiveSecondForeshadowing: Doubles as a FreezeFrameBonus. [[spoiler: When Terry returns Joe and 22 to the Great Before, 22 can be seen with an Earth Pass before Jerry points it out.]]

to:

* FiveSecondForeshadowing: Doubles as a FreezeFrameBonus. [[spoiler: When [[spoiler:When Terry returns Joe and 22 to the Great Before, 22 can be seen with an Earth Pass before Jerry points it out.]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:J-Z]]




to:

[[/folder]]



->''[[TheStinger Oi! Page's over! Go home!]]''

to:

->''[[TheStinger -->''[[TheStinger Oi! Page's over! Go home!]]''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The shot of the stairway is inspired by Powell & Pressburger's classic ''Film/AMatterOfLifeAndDeath''.

Added: 1790

Changed: 53

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* AdultFear:
** Joe's mother discusses this when saying she doesn't want her son to become a full-time musician like his father. It would be one thing if she were younger, but she said that she brought in most of the bacon for the family with her seamstress job, and her fear is that when she dies, Joe won't have any way to support himself. Joe, asking 22 to speak for him, manages to convey that this may be his last chance to achieve his dreams and that he knows his mother cares about him, but he is an adult and able to take care of himself.
** The whole scene where Joe finally gets the gig of his dreams and is thrilled about it... only to have a nearly fatal accident. When he realizes that he is dead and that he was inches away from becoming a well-recognized jazz musician, his face is heartbreaking while seeing his life.
** The Jerrys have pre-adult fear with 22. They say that they want her to find her spark, but 22 resists every step of the way and causes trouble. She's the equivalent of a disobedient child that doesn't realize the consequences of her action; namely, she can't live or grow up. The Jerrys are so desperate that they rope in Joe to help her, mistaking him for a child psychologist.
** When Joe finally [[spoiler:plays with Dorothea Williams, he says that he should feel happy. This was his big dream. SO why is there a sense of ennui and anticlimax instead? Dorothea gently tells him that sometimes in life, when you get what you want, you realize that you were building it up as some grand goal to accomplish, like a fish not seeing the ocean while looking for it]].
** One Lost Soul is a hedge fund manager that obsessively focuses on making trades, staring at a computer screen with a miserable expression. Moonwind saves him and encourages him to find another purpose.



* AmbiguousEnding: It isn't clear if [[spoiler: Joe chose to join Dorothea's band or become a full-time teacher after getting his second chance at life [[TakeAThirdOption (assuming he did either of those things)]].]]

to:

* AmbiguousEnding: It isn't clear if [[spoiler: Joe chose to join Dorothea's band or become a full-time teacher after getting his second chance at life [[TakeAThirdOption (assuming he did either of those things)]].]] He only says that he is going to live]]



* WantingIsBetterThanHaving: After a lifetime of failures, close calls, and rejections, and spending the whole movie trying to make it back into his body, Joe finally [[spoiler: achieves his life long dream, plays with Dorothea Willaims in a show and gets hired to play with her quartet full time. Yet Joe still feels unfulfilled, and says that he expected it to feel different.]] Tying into the film's themes, this is because it's a worthwhile endeavor, but not the sole thing Joe should be living for.

to:

* WantingIsBetterThanHaving: After a lifetime of failures, close calls, and rejections, and spending the whole movie trying to make it back into his body, Joe finally [[spoiler: achieves his life long dream, plays with Dorothea Willaims Williams in a show and gets hired to play with her quartet full time. Yet Joe still feels unfulfilled, and says that he expected it to feel different.]] Tying into the film's themes, this is because it's a worthwhile endeavor, but not the sole thing Joe should be living for.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DayHurtsDarkAdjustedEyes: When 22 [[spoiler:in Joe's body]] and Joe [[spoiler:in the cat's body]] step out of the hospital into the blinding New York sun, 22 reacts in shock and shields her eyes due to sunlight being a completely foreign feeling to her. Joe, who's been blinded by sunlight many times, doesn't react at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseMedicine: We see that Joe's accident left him [[spoiler:in the hospital on a ventilator. Usually, the next-of-kin is notified about a loved one becoming comatose, and Joe had his phone with all of his contacts. Likely the paramedics and administrators should have called Joe's mother rather than leave him tethered to a ventilator for several hours with no one knowing where he is. (In fact, his mother might have gone easier on him on learning he nearly died and is being stubborn about playing despite his NearDeathExperience.) Instead, they don't seem to care when he successfully sneaks out of the hospital, with the doctor being more baffled that Joe has risen with no serious physical injuries and wants to make sure he doesn't have head trauma]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


MoodDissonance: Joe gets his big break playing for Dorothea Williams' quartet, makes his mother proud, and gets invited to join the band. However, since [[spoiler:he got there by angering 22 into giving up her Earth pass after she finally wanted to live, the whole thing rings hollow despite the triumphant tone, and Joe himself starts to have doubts after.]]

to:

* MoodDissonance: Joe gets his big break playing for Dorothea Williams' quartet, makes his mother proud, and gets invited to join the band. However, since [[spoiler:he got there by angering 22 into giving up her Earth pass after she finally wanted to live, the whole thing rings hollow despite the triumphant tone, and Joe himself starts to have doubts after.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RedundancyDepartmentOfRedundancy: When Terry announces to the two prime Jerrys that she's going after Joe, they both, in turn, tell her to do it quickly and quietly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

MoodDissonance: Joe gets his big break playing for Dorothea Williams' quartet, makes his mother proud, and gets invited to join the band. However, since [[spoiler:he got there by angering 22 into giving up her Earth pass after she finally wanted to live, the whole thing rings hollow despite the triumphant tone, and Joe himself starts to have doubts after.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ClingyMacguffin: New souls have a badge on their chest that tracks the traits and attributes they acquire over their development. Until it's completed and becomes an Earth Pass, it can't be removed from them for very long, always appearing back on their body in short order.

to:

* ClingyMacguffin: New souls have a badge on their chest that tracks the traits and attributes they acquire over their development. Until it's completed and becomes an Earth Pass, it can't be removed from them for very long, always appearing back on their body in short order.order, and destroying it creates an identical one just as quickly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HardTruthAesop: [[spoiler:It is entirely possible, and even quite likely, that you don't actually have a "purpose" in being alive or some grand reason you were put on this Earth--and even if you do have one, no one is going to just hand it to you. Whatever your reason for living, whether it's destiny or something you make on your own, you're gonna have to figure that out for yourself. Some people never figure out what their purpose is, and that's okay. Just enjoying life is reason enough to be alive.]] Though one could interpret your purpose in this endeavor is to just live life

to:

* HardTruthAesop: [[spoiler:It is entirely possible, and even quite likely, that you don't actually have a "purpose" in being alive or some grand reason you were put on this Earth--and even if you do have one, no one is going to just hand it to you. Whatever your reason for living, whether it's destiny or something you make on your own, you're gonna have to figure that out for yourself. Some people never figure out what their purpose is, and that's okay. Just enjoying life is reason enough to be alive.]] Though one could interpret your purpose in this endeavor is to just live lifelife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HardTruthAesop: [[spoiler:It is entirely possible, and even quite likely, that you don't actually have a "purpose" in being alive or some grand reason you were put on this Earth--and even if you do have one, no one is going to just hand it to you. Whatever your reason for living, whether it's destiny or something you make on your own, you're gonna have to figure that out for yourself. Some people never figure out what their purpose is, and that's okay. Just enjoying life is reason enough to be alive.]]

to:

* HardTruthAesop: [[spoiler:It is entirely possible, and even quite likely, that you don't actually have a "purpose" in being alive or some grand reason you were put on this Earth--and even if you do have one, no one is going to just hand it to you. Whatever your reason for living, whether it's destiny or something you make on your own, you're gonna have to figure that out for yourself. Some people never figure out what their purpose is, and that's okay. Just enjoying life is reason enough to be alive.]]]] Though one could interpret your purpose in this endeavor is to just live life

Top