Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Webcomic / HowIBecameYours

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* OffModel: Not simply compared to the original character models, but heavily applies by simply comparing different shots of the same characters. In fact, the title page demonstrates the recurring issue of [[AmbiguouslyBrown Katara's skin tone]] varying wildly from page to page.
** Ty Lee looks quite different from her appearance in the series. To a lesser extent, so too does Sokka, but in his case it's more justified, as part of that is him just looking older and sporting a new haircut.
** At one point, instead of tracing Zuko, Diaz traces Ichigo from Bleach, and recolors him to look like Zuko. Even by the comics standards, this is jarring.

Changed: 184

Removed: 137

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
photobucket taken down


The comic enjoyed moderate popularity before certain members of the Avatar fandom got wind of it, and promptly saw to it that the artist was banned from Website/DeviantArt (the comic's former home) for recurring instances of art theft. Diaz's repeated denials of tracing and art theft [[ImplausibleDeniability in the face of overwhelming evidence (screenshots from the show and her drawings match up ]]''[[ImplausibleDeniability line for line]]'') did nothing to endear her to the fandom. She has sadly friends-locked the entire comic at her Website/MySpace page, however, you can view most of it on this Diaz fan's [[http://s762.photobucket.com/albums/xx265/ReneeLuvsZutara/ Photobucket account]].

[[http://howibecameyours-rehost.tumblr.com/ You can also see the whole comic in order on Tumblr with a bit better picture quality here.]]

to:

The comic enjoyed moderate popularity before certain members of the Avatar fandom got wind of it, and promptly saw to it that the artist was banned from Website/DeviantArt (the comic's former home) for recurring instances of art theft. Diaz's repeated denials of tracing and art theft [[ImplausibleDeniability in the face of overwhelming evidence (screenshots from the show and her drawings match up ]]''[[ImplausibleDeniability line for line]]'') did nothing to endear her to the fandom. She has sadly friends-locked the entire comic at her Website/MySpace page, however, you can view most of it on this Diaz fan's [[http://s762.photobucket.com/albums/xx265/ReneeLuvsZutara/ Photobucket account]].

[[http://howibecameyours-rehost.tumblr.com/ You can also see the whole comic in order on Tumblr with a bit better picture quality here.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RevengeFic: Against Mai, for [[ShipSinking sinking the artist's preferred ships]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Zuko discovers that his jealous wife Mai hid Katara's pregnancy from him by hiding the letters revealing the truth, [[WouldHurtAChild and murdered her unborn child]]. After disowning and humiliating Mai he runs away from the still-recovering Fire Nation and makes a beeline for Katara's 18th birthday ball, where the StarCrossedLovers joyfully reunite (Aang and Toph also hook up at this event). Unfortunately for them, hell hath no fury like a WomanScorned: Mai is not about to take this lying down, so she enlists the help of a firebending assassin named Sho.

to:

Zuko discovers that his jealous wife Mai hid Katara's pregnancy from him by hiding the letters revealing the truth, [[WouldHurtAChild and murdered her unborn child]]. After disowning and humiliating Mai Mai, he runs away from the still-recovering Fire Nation and makes a beeline for Katara's 18th birthday ball, where the StarCrossedLovers joyfully reunite (Aang and Toph also hook up at this event). Unfortunately for them, hell hath no fury like a WomanScorned: Mai is not about to take this lying down, so she enlists the help of a firebending assassin named Sho.

Added: 317

Removed: 544

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RecycledSoundtrack: During Katara and Zuko's conversation on the balcony, Katara very blatantly rips off "What Hurts the Most" by Mark Wills.
** Even more blatantly, while Zuko is pining for Katara in the first chapter, part of his inner dialogue contains lyrics straight out of "My Immortal" by Music/{{Evanescence}}.
** Aang lands on Toph's balcony, offers to take her flying, and asks "Do you trust me?" There aren't any lyrics written, but you can practically ''hear'' [[WesternAnimation/{{Aladdin}} "A Whole New World"]] in the background.


Added DiffLines:

* WaxingLyrical:
** During Katara and Zuko's conversation on the balcony, Katara very blatantly rips off "What Hurts the Most" by Mark Wills.
** Even more blatantly, while Zuko is pining for Katara in the first chapter, part of his inner dialogue contains lyrics straight out of "My Immortal" by Music/{{Evanescence}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Absolute Cleavage was renamed to Navel Deep Neckline. Only examples with context that fit the trope are kept.


* AbsoluteCleavage: Katara's blue dress during the fight with Mai combines this with her usual ImpossiblyLowNeckline. It's unclear how it stayed on her ''before'' she does a flip.

Added: 250

Removed: 243

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BladeEnthusiast: Just as in the show, Mai uses throwing knives as her main weapon, and is deadly with them. Unlike in the show, though, ''How I Became Yours'' doesn't have to adhere to network standards, so here her knives sometimes ''hit'' people.



* KnifeNut: Just as in the show, Mai uses throwing knives as her main weapon, and is deadly with them. Unlike in the show, though, ''How I Became Yours'' doesn't have to adhere to network standards, so here her knives sometimes ''hit'' people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpinOffspring: The whole point of ''Rise of the Agni Army''

to:

* SpinOffspring: The whole point of ''Rise of the Agni Army''Army''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RescueRomance: Sokka and Azula

to:

* RescueRomance: Sokka and AzulaAzula.

Added: 361

Removed: 354

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MomentOfWeakness: Surprisingly enough, this is played straight when [[spoiler:Azula, while regaining her bending powers]], is hit in the chest with a thrown knife and nearly killed. This proves that 1) [[TalkingIsAFreeAction talking isn't a free action]] and 2) mundane weapons, even seemingly unimpressive ones such as knives, are a threat to benders.


Added DiffLines:

* NotSoInvincibleAfterAll: Surprisingly enough, this is played straight when [[spoiler:Azula, while regaining her bending powers]], is hit in the chest with a thrown knife and nearly killed. This proves that 1) [[TalkingIsAFreeAction talking isn't a free action]] and 2) mundane weapons, even seemingly unimpressive ones such as knives, are a threat to benders.

Added: 354

Removed: 351

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MomentOfWeakness: Surprisingly enough, this is played straight when [[spoiler:Azula, while regaining her bending powers]], is hit in the chest with a thrown knife and nearly killed. This proves that 1) [[TalkingIsAFreeAction talking isn't a free action]] and 2) mundane weapons, even seemingly unimpressive ones such as knives, are a threat to benders.



* RealityEnsues: Surprisingly enough, this is played straight when [[spoiler:Azula, while regaining her bending powers]], is hit in the chest with a thrown knife and nearly killed. This proves that 1) [[TalkingIsAFreeAction talking isn't a free action]] and 2) mundane weapons, even seemingly unimpressive ones such as knives, are a threat to benders.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** At one point, instead of tracing Zuko, Diaz traces Ichigo from Bleach, and recolors him to look like Zuko. Even by the comics standards, this is jarring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
dewicking World Of Card Board Speech per trs


* WorldOfCardboardSpeech: Azula as she regains her bending.
-->'''Azula''': I have seen my life for what it was back then. A life that was so empty. And I'm not going to surrender this life for no one without a fight. And by gods I'm not going to let him go either... I love you Sokka...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DistantFinale: There is a brief epilogue taking place six years after the story, with the surviving main cast and their families.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse; this trope is when characters are of mixed heritage In Universe.


* ButNotTooForeign: HIBY supposedly takes place in Avatar's Far-East inspired world, but aside from a few token nods to the setting, it seems to take place more in renaissance-era France. Most of the female cast wear European-style dresses (with the exception of Mai and sometimes Toph), and the architecture is pretty obviously copy-pasted from European castles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheBeautifulElite: All of the heroes have high social rank and are very beautiful.

to:

* TheBeautifulElite: All of the heroes have high social rank and are very beautiful. Well, except Zuko, [[GoodScarsEvilScars obviously]].

Added: 269

Removed: 359

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Good Adultery Bad Adultery now requires two affairs, one presented as 'good' and one 'bad'


* GoodAdulteryBadAdultery: Fire Lord Zuko impregnating Katara and ''physically assaulting his betrothed (Mai)'' [[DisproportionateRetribution for getting upset about it]].
** SympatheticAdulterer: Zuko is intended to be a Pay Cheating unto Evil sense; not only is Mai villainized, but Zuko claims he never loved her, their marriage being retconned as arranged.


Added DiffLines:

* SympatheticAdulterer: Zuko impregnating Katara and assaulting his betrothed Mai when she gets upset about it is intended to be a Pay Cheating unto Evil sense; not only is Mai villainized, but Zuko claims he never loved her, their marriage being retconned as arranged.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Those Two Bad Guys is replaced by Bumbling Henchmen Duo with a slightly different definition, as per this thread.


* ThoseTwoBadGuys: Mai and Sho in the fourth chapter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 211

Removed: 211

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArrangedMarriage: In HIBY, Zuko's marriage to Mai is said to have been arranged by his father and her parents. This does not explicitly contradict the series proper, but no mention was ever made of that there.



* ArrangedMarriage: In HIBY, Zuko's marriage to Mai is said to have been arranged by his father and her parents. This does not explicitly contradict the series proper, but no mention was ever made of that there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Katara. The things she does the most in this fic? Whining. Being self-centered. Making even her unborn child's death all about her. Only caring about being Zuko's love interest. Wearing pretty dresses (which isn't bad in and of itself, but considering the canon setting, they're very out of place). The only scene in which she's ever seen using the ActionGirl skills that she worked so far for in the series? When [[spoiler:she bloodbends Mai to death]].

to:

** Katara. The things she does the most in this fic? Whining. Being self-centered. Making even her unborn child's death all about her. Only caring about being Zuko's love interest. Wearing pretty European-style dresses (which isn't bad in and of itself, but considering the canon setting, they're very out of place). The only scene in which she's ever seen using the ActionGirl skills that she worked so far for in the series? When [[spoiler:she bloodbends Mai to death]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The new temple of Air Nomads - potential plot for a good HiddenElfVillage story arc, or throw-away backstory that unceremoniously throws all of Aang's LastOfHisKind troubles into the trash heap?

to:

** The new temple of Air Nomads - -- potential plot for a good HiddenElfVillage story arc, or throw-away backstory that unceremoniously throws all of Aang's LastOfHisKind troubles into the trash heap?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HiddenElfVillage: During the TimeSkip between the end of the series and the beginning of this comic, Aang finds one of these, populated by Air Nomads. [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot Nothing more is said about this development]].

to:

* HiddenElfVillage: During the TimeSkip between the end of the series and the beginning of this comic, Aang finds one of these, populated by Air Nomads. Thus, the fourth elemental nation is not extinct after all. [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot Nothing more is said about this development]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I think this one is misuse; in the context of that conversation, nothing of what Mai says comes across as a Berserk Button in the strict sense.


* BerserkButton: Zuko has two that Mai pushes: insulting Katara and calling him a "[[RougeAnglesOfSatin chard]] monster".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KnifeNut: Just as in the show, Mai uses throwing knives as her main weapon, and is deadly with them.

to:

* KnifeNut: Just as in the show, Mai uses throwing knives as her main weapon, and is deadly with them. Unlike in the show, though, ''How I Became Yours'' doesn't have to adhere to network standards, so here her knives sometimes ''hit'' people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
YMMV trope


* PsychoExGirlfriend: What Mai was supposed to be, although she ended up [[UnintentionallySympathetic being one of the more sympathetic characters.]]

to:

* PsychoExGirlfriend: What Mai was supposed is written as dishonest and murderously jealous, causing Zuko to be, although she ended break up [[UnintentionallySympathetic being one of the more sympathetic characters.]]with her, and becomes completely unhinged after this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhamLine

to:

* WhamLineWhamLine:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LivingLieDetector: Just like in canon, Toph has this ability. Unlike in canon, Toph is 100% sure it works all the time, even when dealing with a woman who has demonstrated the ability to fool it in the past.

to:

* LivingLieDetector: Just like in canon, Toph has this ability. Unlike in canon, Toph is 100% sure it works all the time, even when dealing with a woman who has demonstrated the ability to fool it in the past. Maybe she's been practicing and improving it since?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DerailingLoveInterests: Poor Mai...

to:

* DerailingLoveInterests: Poor Mai...Mai falls victim to both this and SuddenSequelHeelSyndrome, revealing herself as a crazy jealous woman who [[spoiler:kills Katara's unborn child, and then tries to kill Katara herself, too]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This seems like misuse, since Azula does take a rather active part in the plot, and doesn't have any obvious duties that she is neglecting.


** Azula, at least, has the excuse that she's been stripped of her title, cast out of her country, and is now suffering from EasyAmnesia on top of that. It still doesn't make it less painful to watch her giggle like a helpless teenager.

Top