Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / Castoff

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's not impossible that the explodey person had been Nico (Sage's friend), either.

to:

** It's not impossible that the explodey person had been Nico (Sage's friend), either. \n Especially that Nico ''did'' ask Sage to solve his emotional problem (grief after a LostLenore) and the [[WhenAllYouHaveIsAHammer main tool Sage seems to have had is the separation spell]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sage's scars (part of them, anyway), are caused by him [[ProfessorGuineaPig experimenting on himself]], but still.

to:

** Sage's scars (part of them, anyway), are caused by him [[ProfessorGuineaPig experimenting on himself]], but still. If anyone would volunteer for this sort of a thing, it's him.

Added: 86

Changed: 117

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Sage's scars (part of them, anyway), are caused by him [[ProfessorGuineaPig experimenting on himself]], but still.
** It's not impossible that the explodey person had been Nico (Sage's friend), either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Sage, the guy with a MadScientist approach to magic, would be curiosity in this arrangement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Possibly it was even Sage - powerful magic, he appears in Arianna's flashback shards, has scars on his hands, so has been through something dangerous, maybe an explosion.

Added: 131

Changed: 15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
WMG pages are Spoilers Off subpages


'''As a WMG subpage, all spoilers are unmarked [[Administrivia/SpoilersOff as per policy.]] Administrivia/YouHaveBeenWarned.'''
----



** Frankie is fifteen [[spoiler: i.e. was activated (became sentient?) fifteen years ago. Possibly he was just a regular robot before then]].
** And Vector is also fifteen, HappilyAdopted by mrs. Jacobs who later tearfully admits to having nobody else - she specifically says she lost her husband, but doesn't say when. Perhaps the magical orb latched itself to her unfulfilled dream of being a mother, creating a WonderChild?

to:

** Frankie is fifteen [[spoiler: i.e. was activated (became sentient?) fifteen years ago. Possibly he was just a regular robot before then]].
then.
** And Vector is also fifteen, HappilyAdopted by mrs.Mrs. Jacobs who later tearfully admits to having nobody else - she specifically says she lost her husband, but doesn't say when. Perhaps the magical orb latched itself to her unfulfilled dream of being a mother, creating a WonderChild?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* This appears to be Jossed, since Zera all but said he was adopted into a human family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Come to think about it, maybe the explodey person exploded ''because'' they were artificially given magic? And the titular "castoff" would be the magic not absorbed by their body, which went rouge, so to speak, and hit other people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* And a product of a MalignedMixedMarriage, given the FantasticRacism we've seen towards elves.

to:

* And a product of a MalignedMixedMarriage, given the FantasticRacism we've seen towards elves.elves.

[[WMG: The corpse of the staircase is not Arianna's brother]]
* ... but the person he's been framed for murdering. His "high treason" is supposed to have been assasination (one more reason for Arianna to not believe it). Maybe someone was killed, just not by Arianna's brother? And he got framed for it, then (as a convict) used for the dangerous magical experiment?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

As of [[https://castoff-comic.com/comic/614 this page]] we now tracking spells work by locking onto the trackee's aura, which is unique to a person. Lack of aura would make one untrackable. Arianna thinks this is the case with [[RidiculouslyHumanRobots Frankie]] but is puzzled as to why Vector or Rori would have none, and of course never has tried to track herself. This supports the "parts of a person" theory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Later on [[https://castoff-comic.com/comic/613 we learn]] Arianna read that spell in the book from mrs. Jacobs shop and she thinks the spell is faulty. Obviously, Zera must have learned it elsewhere - maybe his training said failure to track means death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
having an idea


* Arianna's brother. He died fifteen years ago, as far as she knows, executed for high treason she doesn't believe he would commit. But the medical report Zera's lieutenants found says something different (assuming it's not about Zera's sister, but Zera himself, who may or may not be Arianna's brother, or another fragment of Arianna's brother). Can we be sure her memories are accurate?

to:

* Arianna's brother. He died fifteen years ago, as far as she knows, executed for high treason she doesn't believe he would commit. But the medical report Zera's lieutenants found says something different (assuming it's not about Zera's sister, but Zera himself, who may or may not be Arianna's brother, or another fragment of Arianna's brother). Can we be sure her memories are accurate?accurate?

[[WMG: Arianna and Zera are both half-elves]]
* And a product of a MalignedMixedMarriage, given the FantasticRacism we've seen towards elves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


What's more, tracking spells don't work on them - Zera's spell for Arianna fails, and so do Arianna's spells for the other two ''and'' for Rori. Notably, Arianna doesn't interpret this as the boys having died (like Zera does), she just tracks someone else she thinks would be with them. So, since the boys are actually not dead, and neither is Arianna, tracking spell failing doesn't necessarily mean the tracked person is dead (and assuming so would be a ConverseError). It might be the most common cause, but not the only possible one. And if they are all the same person, then the tracking spell would be confused when one part of them is trying to track another (like tracking your own leg, only it appears to be on a different continent, and your kidney on yet another, and so on... confusing).

to:

What's more, tracking spells don't work on them - Zera's spell for Arianna fails, and so do Arianna's spells for the other two ''and'' for Rori. Notably, Arianna doesn't interpret this as the boys having died (like Zera does), she just tracks someone else she thinks would be with them. So, since the boys are actually not dead, and neither is Arianna, tracking spell failing doesn't necessarily mean the tracked person is dead (and assuming so would be a ConverseError).[[UsefulNotes/LogicalFallacies Converse Error]]). It might be the most common cause, but not the only possible one. And if they are all the same person, then the tracking spell would be confused when one part of them is trying to track another (like tracking your own leg, only it appears to be on a different continent, and your kidney on yet another, and so on... confusing).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Possibly, they are (were, before growing into people) the explodey person's emotions:
** Arianna, the RedIsViolent SirSwearsALot is their anger,
** Vector, the SupernaturalFearInducer is their fear,
** Frankie, the GenkiGuy is their joy,
** Marina, the motherly HealingHands lady is their compassion,
** Rori, TheGadfly with SuperSpeed is their excitement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Marina and Rori are over fifteen, but only a little - they may have been hit by the magical explosion shrapnel as a toddler and a baby, resectively.

to:

** Marina and Rori are over fifteen, but only a little - they may have been hit by the magical explosion shrapnel as a toddler and a baby, resectively.
respectively.

Added: 799

Changed: 856

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Specifically, the person in the prologue, the one who magically explodes into a bunch of colourful orbs. These orbs are seen to scatter in various directions, one of them enacting a meteor crash in front of the astonished mrs. Jacobs. This would explain why "fifteen years" recurrs in each of their cases:

to:

* Specifically, the person in the prologue, the one who magically explodes into a bunch of colourful orbs. These orbs are seen to scatter in various directions, one of them enacting a meteor crash in front of the astonished mrs. Jacobs. This would explain why "fifteen years" recurrs in each of their cases:so much:



What's more, tracking spells don't work on any of them - Zera's spell for Arianna fails, and so do Arianna's spells for the other two ''and'' for Rori. Notably, Arianna doesn't interpret this as the boys having died (like Zera does), she just tracks someone else she thinks would be with them. So, since the boys are actually not dead, and neither is Arianna, tracking spell failing doesn't necessarily mean the tracked person is dead (and assuming so would be a ConverseError). It might be the most common cause, but not the only possible one. And if they are all the same person, then the tracking spell would be confused when one part of them is trying to track another (like tracking your own leg, only it appears to be on a different continent, and your kidney on yet another, and so on... confusing).

to:

** Marina and Rori are over fifteen, but only a little - they may have been hit by the magical explosion shrapnel as a toddler and a baby, resectively.

What's more, tracking spells don't work on any of them - Zera's spell for Arianna fails, and so do Arianna's spells for the other two ''and'' for Rori. Notably, Arianna doesn't interpret this as the boys having died (like Zera does), she just tracks someone else she thinks would be with them. So, since the boys are actually not dead, and neither is Arianna, tracking spell failing doesn't necessarily mean the tracked person is dead (and assuming so would be a ConverseError). It might be the most common cause, but not the only possible one. And if they are all the same person, then the tracking spell would be confused when one part of them is trying to track another (like tracking your own leg, only it appears to be on a different continent, and your kidney on yet another, and so on... confusing).confusing).



We know that fifteen years back a magical experiment was conducted and it went bad (see: StuffBlowingUp). The experimentee might have been Arianna's brother, by the way, which explains her snooping and their Shroedinger's deaths. In any case, each member of the group (apart from Arianna, as far as we've seen) is unique in some magic-related way: Vector can teleport, Frankie is a sentient robot in a setting without those, Marina can heal in a setting without healing magic, Rori is impossibly (and, it seems, magically - her PowerGlows) fast. Maybe someone tried to improve magic, or give it to nonmagical lands like Ferrin? And the experiment created sort of magical golems, at least in some cases out of existing bodies (if Arianna and her brother died in the explosion, then the magic brought them back to life, they'd be revenants, Frankie might have been already built, but not activated, and so on).

to:

We know that fifteen years back a magical experiment was conducted and it went bad (see: StuffBlowingUp). The experimentee might have been Arianna's brother, by the way, which explains her snooping and their Shroedinger's deaths. In any case, each member of the group (apart from Arianna, as far as we've seen) is unique in some magic-related way: Vector can teleport, Frankie is a sentient robot in a setting without those, Marina can heal in a setting without healing magic, Rori is impossibly (and, it seems, magically - her PowerGlows) fast. Maybe someone tried to improve magic, or give it to nonmagical non-magical lands like Ferrin? And the experiment created sort of magical golems, at least in some cases out of existing bodies (if Arianna and her brother died in the explosion, then the magic brought them back to life, they'd be revenants, Frankie might have been already built, but not activated, and so on).on).



* Arianna's brother. He died fifteen years ago, as far as she knows, executed for high treason she doesn't believe he would commit. But the medical report Zera's lieutenants found says something different (assuming it's about Zera, who may or may not be Arianna's brother, or another fragment of Arianna's brother). Can we be sure her memories are accurate?

to:

* Arianna's brother. He died fifteen years ago, as far as she knows, executed for high treason she doesn't believe he would commit. But the medical report Zera's lieutenants found says something different (assuming it's not about Zera, Zera's sister, but Zera himself, who may or may not be Arianna's brother, or another fragment of Arianna's brother). Can we be sure her memories are accurate?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


What's more, tracking spells don't work on any of them - Zera's spell for Arianna fails, and so do Arianna's spells for the other two. Notably, Arianna doesn't interpret this as the boys having died (like Zera does), she just tracks someone else she thinks would be with them. So, since the boys are actually not dead, and neither is Arianna, tracking spell failing doesn't necessarily mean the tracked person is dead (and assuming so would be a ConverseError). It might be the most common cause, but not the only possible one. And if they are all the same person, then the tracking spell would be confused when one part of them is trying to track another (like tracking your own leg, only it appears to be on a different continent, and your kidney on yet another, and so on... confusing).

to:

What's more, tracking spells don't work on any of them - Zera's spell for Arianna fails, and so do Arianna's spells for the other two.two ''and'' for Rori. Notably, Arianna doesn't interpret this as the boys having died (like Zera does), she just tracks someone else she thinks would be with them. So, since the boys are actually not dead, and neither is Arianna, tracking spell failing doesn't necessarily mean the tracked person is dead (and assuming so would be a ConverseError). It might be the most common cause, but not the only possible one. And if they are all the same person, then the tracking spell would be confused when one part of them is trying to track another (like tracking your own leg, only it appears to be on a different continent, and your kidney on yet another, and so on... confusing).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


What's more, tracking spells don't work on any of them - Zera's spell for Arianna fails, and so do Arianna's spells for the other two. Notably, Arianna doesn't interpret this as the boys having died (like Zera does), she just tracks someone else she thinks would be with them. So, since the boys are actually not dead, and neither is Arianna, tracking spell failing doesn't necessarily mean the tracked person is dead. It might be the most common cause, but not the only possible one. And if they are all the same person, then the tracking spell would be confused when one part of them is trying to track another (like tracking your own leg, only it appears to be on a different continent, and your kidney on yet another, and so on... confusing).

to:

What's more, tracking spells don't work on any of them - Zera's spell for Arianna fails, and so do Arianna's spells for the other two. Notably, Arianna doesn't interpret this as the boys having died (like Zera does), she just tracks someone else she thinks would be with them. So, since the boys are actually not dead, and neither is Arianna, tracking spell failing doesn't necessarily mean the tracked person is dead.dead (and assuming so would be a ConverseError). It might be the most common cause, but not the only possible one. And if they are all the same person, then the tracking spell would be confused when one part of them is trying to track another (like tracking your own leg, only it appears to be on a different continent, and your kidney on yet another, and so on... confusing).



We know that fifteen years back a magical experiment was conducted and it went bad (see: StuffBlowingUp). The experimentee might have been Arianna's brother, by the way, which explains her snooping and their Shroedinger's deaths. In any case, each member of the group (apart from Arianna, as far as we've seen) is unique in some magic-related way: Vector can teleport, Frankie is a sentient robot in a setting without those, Marina can heal in a setting without healing magic, Rori is impossibly (and, it seems, magically - her PowerGlows) fast. Maybe someone tried to improve magic, or give it to nonmagical lands like Ferrin? And the experiment created sort of magical golems, at least in some cases out of existing bodies (if Arianna and her brother died in the explosion, then the magic brought them back to life, they may be {{The Revenant}}s, Frankie might have been already built, but not activated, and so on).

to:

We know that fifteen years back a magical experiment was conducted and it went bad (see: StuffBlowingUp). The experimentee might have been Arianna's brother, by the way, which explains her snooping and their Shroedinger's deaths. In any case, each member of the group (apart from Arianna, as far as we've seen) is unique in some magic-related way: Vector can teleport, Frankie is a sentient robot in a setting without those, Marina can heal in a setting without healing magic, Rori is impossibly (and, it seems, magically - her PowerGlows) fast. Maybe someone tried to improve magic, or give it to nonmagical lands like Ferrin? And the experiment created sort of magical golems, at least in some cases out of existing bodies (if Arianna and her brother died in the explosion, then the magic brought them back to life, they may they'd be {{The Revenant}}s, revenants, Frankie might have been already built, but not activated, and so on).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Alternatively, each of the protagonists is a specific magical power given flesh]]
We know that fifteen years back a magical experiment was conducted and it went bad (see: StuffBlowingUp). The experimentee might have been Arianna's brother, by the way, which explains her snooping and their Shroedinger's deaths. In any case, each member of the group (apart from Arianna, as far as we've seen) is unique in some magic-related way: Vector can teleport, Frankie is a sentient robot in a setting without those, Marina can heal in a setting without healing magic, Rori is impossibly (and, it seems, magically - her PowerGlows) fast. Maybe someone tried to improve magic, or give it to nonmagical lands like Ferrin? And the experiment created sort of magical golems, at least in some cases out of existing bodies (if Arianna and her brother died in the explosion, then the magic brought them back to life, they may be {{The Revenant}}s, Frankie might have been already built, but not activated, and so on).

Added: 415

Changed: 470

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


What's more, tracking spells don't work on any of them - Zera's spell for Arianna fails, and so do Arianna's spells for the other two. Notably, Arianna doesn't interpret this as the boys having died (like Zera does), she just tracks someone else she thinks would be with them.

to:

What's more, tracking spells don't work on any of them - Zera's spell for Arianna fails, and so do Arianna's spells for the other two. Notably, Arianna doesn't interpret this as the boys having died (like Zera does), she just tracks someone else she thinks would be with them. So, since the boys are actually not dead, and neither is Arianna, tracking spell failing doesn't necessarily mean the tracked person is dead. It might be the most common cause, but not the only possible one. And if they are all the same person, then the tracking spell would be confused when one part of them is trying to track another (like tracking your own leg, only it appears to be on a different continent, and your kidney on yet another, and so on... confusing).
[[WMG: The magical explodey person in the prologue is...]]
* Arianna's brother. He died fifteen years ago, as far as she knows, executed for high treason she doesn't believe he would commit. But the medical report Zera's lieutenants found says something different (assuming it's about Zera, who may or may not be Arianna's brother, or another fragment of Arianna's brother). Can we be sure her memories are accurate?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And Vector is also fifteen, HappilyAdopted by mrs. Jacobs who later tearfully admits to having nobody else - she specifically says she lost her husband, but doesn't say when. Perhaps the magical orb latched itself to her unfulfilled dream of being a mother, creating a WonderChild?

to:

** And Vector is also fifteen, HappilyAdopted by mrs. Jacobs who later tearfully admits to having nobody else - she specifically says she lost her husband, but doesn't say when. Perhaps the magical orb latched itself to her unfulfilled dream of being a mother, creating a WonderChild?WonderChild?
What's more, tracking spells don't work on any of them - Zera's spell for Arianna fails, and so do Arianna's spells for the other two. Notably, Arianna doesn't interpret this as the boys having died (like Zera does), she just tracks someone else she thinks would be with them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And Vector is also fifteen, HappilyAdopted by mrs. Jacobs who later tearfully admits to having nobody else - she specifically says she lost her husband, but doesn't say when. Perhaps the magical orb latched itself to her unfulfilled dream of being a mother?

to:

** And Vector is also fifteen, HappilyAdopted by mrs. Jacobs who later tearfully admits to having nobody else - she specifically says she lost her husband, but doesn't say when. Perhaps the magical orb latched itself to her unfulfilled dream of being a mother?mother, creating a WonderChild?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
my fingers have twisted on the keyboard :)


** And Vector is also fifteen, HappilyAdopted by mrs. Jabobs who later tearfully admits to having nobody else - she specifically says she lost her husband, but doesn't say when. Perhaps the magical orb latched itself to her unfulfilled dream of being a mother?

to:

** And Vector is also fifteen, HappilyAdopted by mrs. Jabobs Jacobs who later tearfully admits to having nobody else - she specifically says she lost her husband, but doesn't say when. Perhaps the magical orb latched itself to her unfulfilled dream of being a mother?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Each of the protagonists is just a fragment of a person]]
* Specifically, the person in the prologue, the one who magically explodes into a bunch of colourful orbs. These orbs are seen to scatter in various directions, one of them enacting a meteor crash in front of the astonished mrs. Jacobs. This would explain why "fifteen years" recurrs in each of their cases:
** If Arianna is the little girl snooping in the prologue (she would have been seven years old if it's indeed fifteen years prior to the plot), the explosion would plausibly make Zera think she must have died. She might have really been killed, then revived by the magical orb.
** Frankie is fifteen [[spoiler: i.e. was activated (became sentient?) fifteen years ago. Possibly he was just a regular robot before then]].
** And Vector is also fifteen, HappilyAdopted by mrs. Jabobs who later tearfully admits to having nobody else - she specifically says she lost her husband, but doesn't say when. Perhaps the magical orb latched itself to her unfulfilled dream of being a mother?

Top