Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Trivia / TheLegendOfRahAndTheMuggles

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReclusiveArtist: Aside from Stouffer's whereabouts (according to her website's FAQ, she lived somewhere in Camp Hill, Pennsylvania, later moving to Mechanicsburg), any attempt to contact her has resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her website with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.

to:

* ReclusiveArtist: Aside from Stouffer's general whereabouts (according to her website's FAQ, she lived somewhere in Camp Hill, Pennsylvania, later moving to Mechanicsburg), any attempt to contact her has resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her website with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.

Added: 384

Changed: 382

Removed: 168

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
If it's intentional then it's not the Streisand Effect.


* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a thousand copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, although unauthorized and/or used copies are available on Amazon and Ebay. [[BileFascination If you want to buy the original 1984 version]], however, good luck with that.

to:

* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less KeepCirculatingTheTapes:
** Fewer
than a thousand copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, although unauthorized and/or used copies are available on Amazon and Ebay. [[BileFascination If you want to buy the original 1984 version]], however, good luck with that.



* StreisandEffect: Nobody would have known about the book if Stouffer hadn't tried to sue Creator/JKRowling. [[note]] Although that was likely her intention. [[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StillbornFranchise: Stouffer claimed that she had written a whole series of books about the Muggles, as well as a screenplay for a planned animated film. There is no trace of them or proof of their existance anywhere, not even on the Internet.

to:

* StillbornFranchise: Stouffer claimed that she had written a whole series of books about the Muggles, as well as a screenplay for a planned animated film.film named "Rah and the Light". There is no trace of them or proof of their existance anywhere, not even on the Internet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a thousand copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, although unauthorized and/or used copies are available on Amazon. [[BileFascination If you want to buy the original 1984 version]], however, good luck with that.

to:

* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a thousand copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, although unauthorized and/or used copies are available on Amazon.Amazon and Ebay. [[BileFascination If you want to buy the original 1984 version]], however, good luck with that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While the titles of several other novels by N.K. Stouffer have floated around on the internet (namely: ''Silver Linings'', ''The Sovereign State of Troposonia'', ''The Myn'', ''The Land of the Nother-One'' and ''The Fat Frog''), because of their extremely limited print run and lack of distribution, there is no feasible way to purchase any of these books.

to:

** While the titles of several other novels by N.K. Stouffer have floated around on the internet (namely: ''Silver Linings'', ''The Sovereign State of Troposonia'', ''The Myn'', ''The Land of the Nother-One'' and ''The Fat Frog''), because of their extremely limited print run and run, lack of distribution, distribution and absence of info on the Internet, there is no feasible way to purchase any of these books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** While the titles of several other novels by N.K. Stouffer have floated around on the internet (namely: ''Silver Linings'', ''The Sovereign State of Troposonia'', ''The Myn'', ''The Land of the Nother-One'' and ''The Fat Frog''), because of their extremely limited print run and lack of distribution, there is no feasible way to purchase any of these books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StillbornFranchise: Stouffer claimed that she had written a whole series of books about the Muggles, as well as a screenplay for a planned animated film. Not a single specimen of such material has been witnessed by anyone, nor did they sit in one shelf, and there is no trace of them on the Internet.

to:

* StillbornFranchise: Stouffer claimed that she had written a whole series of books about the Muggles, as well as a screenplay for a planned animated film. Not a single specimen of such material has been witnessed by anyone, nor did they sit in one shelf, and there There is no trace of them or proof of their existance anywhere, not even on the Internet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ColbertBump: One of the rare case where ''the author'' bumps its own work, but for all the wrong reasons.

to:

* ColbertBump: One of the rare case where ''the author'' bumps its her own work, but for all the wrong reasons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a thousand copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, however unauthorized and/or used copies are available on Amazon. [[BileFascination If you want to buy the original 1984 version]], however, good luck with that.

to:

* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a thousand copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, however although unauthorized and/or used copies are available on Amazon. [[BileFascination If you want to buy the original 1984 version]], however, good luck with that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not Trivia tropes.


* DisneyOwnsThisTrope: Stouffer released a list of elements that Rowling allegedly plagiarized from her books. 90% of them are generic stuff you could find in any fantasy story.
** In the book itself, there is a page with a trademark notice for the terms she coined. They are: "Muggle, Muggles, Muggle-Bye, Muggledome, Muggleplication, Shadow Monsters, Nevil, Nevils, Nardles, Greeblies, Nadie (sic) and Neddie Spooners of the Deep, Winkle, Elders, Zyn, Rah"; all of them were trademarked ''after'' she sued Rowling.
* FrivolousLawsuit: Pretty much the only reason anyone has ever heard of the book, if at all. Stouffer claimed that the Harry Potter books plagiarized numerous elements from this book and other books of hers (namely ''Larry Potter and his friend Lilly'' and ''Rah and Myn''). Her lawsuit was laughed out of court as she presented obviously fabricated evidence (for example, a word that was retroactively added in the original manuscript [[EpicFail not only in a different font, but]] [[FontAnachronism said font wasn't invented until much after the book was originally published!]]), claimed that J.K. Rowling could get access to her material when in fact she couldn't (Stouffer never published outside of the United States), and showed [[CriticalResearchFailure utter lack of knowledge]] [[CowboyBebopAtHisComputer about the franchise she was attacking]].
* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: Sometime after the lawsuit debacle, it was translated in Czech language by publisher Adonai. So far, it's the only known translation of the book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReclusiveArtist: Aside from Stouffer's whereabouts (according to her website's FAQ, she lived somewhere in Camp Hill, Pennsylvania, later moving to Mechanicsburg), any attempt to contact her has resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.

to:

* ReclusiveArtist: Aside from Stouffer's whereabouts (according to her website's FAQ, she lived somewhere in Camp Hill, Pennsylvania, later moving to Mechanicsburg), any attempt to contact her has resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page website with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a thousand copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, however unauthorized and/or used copies are available on Amazon. [[BileFascination If you want to buy the original version]], however, good luck with that.

to:

* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a thousand copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, however unauthorized and/or used copies are available on Amazon. [[BileFascination If you want to buy the original 1984 version]], however, good luck with that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: Sometime after the lawsuit debacle, it was translated in Czech language by publisher Adonai. So far, it's the only known translation of the book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Mechanicsburg is where the Rah trademarks were registered, so I searched "Nancy Stouffer Mechanicsburg, PA" on Bing and I can say that she's still alive, and that she has a hometown.


* ReclusiveArtist: Stouffer's whereabouts are very hazy (According to her website's FAQ, she lived somewhere around Camp Hill PA), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle. It's not known whether she is still alive as of August 2020.

to:

* ReclusiveArtist: Aside from Stouffer's whereabouts are very hazy (According (according to her website's FAQ, she lived somewhere around in Camp Hill PA), and Hill, Pennsylvania, later moving to Mechanicsburg), any attempt to contact her has resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle. It's not known whether she is still alive as of August 2020.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StreisandEffect: Nobody would have known about the book if Stouffer hadn't tried to sue Creator/JKRowling (Although possibly that was his intention)

to:

* StreisandEffect: Nobody would have known about the book if Stouffer hadn't tried to sue Creator/JKRowling (Although possibly Creator/JKRowling. [[note]] Although that was his intention) likely her intention. [[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StreisandEffect: Nobody would have known about the book if Stouffer hadn't tried to sue Creator/JKRowling.

to:

* StreisandEffect: Nobody would have known about the book if Stouffer hadn't tried to sue Creator/JKRowling.Creator/JKRowling (Although possibly that was his intention)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReclusiveArtist: Although the website [=RealMuggles=].com was still online before 2017, Stouffer's whereabouts are very hazy (According to her website's FAQ, she lived somewhere around Camp Hill PA), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle. It's not known whether she is still alive as of August 2020.

to:

* ReclusiveArtist: Although the website [=RealMuggles=].com was still online before 2017, Stouffer's whereabouts are very hazy (According to her website's FAQ, she lived somewhere around Camp Hill PA), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle. It's not known whether she is still alive as of August 2020.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Punctuation


* VanityPublishing: Twice, in fact. Ande Publishing Company, the author's own publishing company went bankrupt shortly after the first printing run. During the plagiarism controversy, US publisher Thurman House bought the rights to the book and did another printing run, hoping to [[NoSuchThingAsBadPublicity capitalize on the whole ordeal]]... and they ''also'' went bankrupt.

to:

* VanityPublishing: Twice, in fact. Ande Publishing Company, the author's own publishing company company, went bankrupt shortly after the first printing run. During the plagiarism controversy, US publisher Thurman House bought the rights to the book and did another printing run, hoping to [[NoSuchThingAsBadPublicity capitalize on the whole ordeal]]... and they ''also'' went bankrupt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Grammar


* StillbornFranchise: Stouffer claimed that she had wrote a whole series of books about the Muggles, as well as a screenplay for a planned animated film. Not a single specimen of such material has been witnessed by anyone, nor did they sit in one shelf, and there is no trace of them on the Internet.

to:

* StillbornFranchise: Stouffer claimed that she had wrote written a whole series of books about the Muggles, as well as a screenplay for a planned animated film. Not a single specimen of such material has been witnessed by anyone, nor did they sit in one shelf, and there is no trace of them on the Internet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReclusiveArtist: Although the website [=RealMuggles=].com was still online before 2017, Stouffer's whereabouts were very hazy (According to her FAQ, she lives somewhere around Camp Hill PA), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.

to:

* ReclusiveArtist: Although the website [=RealMuggles=].com was still online before 2017, Stouffer's whereabouts were are very hazy (According to her website's FAQ, she lives lived somewhere around Camp Hill PA), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle. It's not known whether she is still alive as of August 2020.

Changed: 88

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a thousand copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, however unauthorized and/or used copies are available on Amazon. [[SnarkBait If you want to]] [[BileFascination buy the]] ''[[BileFascination original]]'' [[BileFascination version]], however, good luck with that.

to:

* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a thousand copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, however unauthorized and/or used copies are available on Amazon. [[SnarkBait If you want to]] [[BileFascination If you want to buy the]] ''[[BileFascination original]]'' [[BileFascination the original version]], however, good luck with that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StreisandEffect: Nobody would have known about the book if Stouffer hadn't tried to sue Creator/JKRowling.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a hundred copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, however unauthorized and/or used copies are available on Amazon. [[SnarkBait If you want to]] [[BileFascination buy the]] ''[[BileFascination original]]'' [[BileFascination version]], however, good luck with that.

to:

* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a hundred thousand copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, however unauthorized and/or used copies are available on Amazon. [[SnarkBait If you want to]] [[BileFascination buy the]] ''[[BileFascination original]]'' [[BileFascination version]], however, good luck with that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReclusiveArtist: Although the website [=RealMuggles=].com was still online before 2017, Stouffer's whereabouts were very hazy (According to her FAQ, she lives somewhere in Pennsylvania), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.

to:

* ReclusiveArtist: Although the website [=RealMuggles=].com was still online before 2017, Stouffer's whereabouts were very hazy (According to her FAQ, she lives somewhere in Pennsylvania), around Camp Hill PA), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a hundred copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, however unauthorized copies can be bought on Amazon. [[SnarkBait If you want to]] [[BileFascination buy the]] ''[[BileFascination original]]'' [[BileFascination version]], however, good luck with that.

to:

* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a hundred copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, however unauthorized and/or used copies can be bought are available on Amazon. [[SnarkBait If you want to]] [[BileFascination buy the]] ''[[BileFascination original]]'' [[BileFascination version]], however, good luck with that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a hundred copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, although unauthorized copies can be bought on Amazon. [[SnarkBait If you want to]] [[BileFascination buy the]] ''[[BileFascination original]]'' [[BileFascination version]], however, good luck with that.

to:

* KeepCirculatingTheTapes: Less than a hundred copies of the book exist (although Stouffer claimed that [[BlatantLies it sold out 150,000 copies in three weeks]]), and getting your hands on one of the 2001-printed copies is quite hard, although however unauthorized copies can be bought on Amazon. [[SnarkBait If you want to]] [[BileFascination buy the]] ''[[BileFascination original]]'' [[BileFascination version]], however, good luck with that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DisneyOwnsThisTrope: Stouffer released a list of elements that Rowling allegedly plagiarized from her books. 90% of them are generic stuff you could find in any fiction story.

to:

* DisneyOwnsThisTrope: Stouffer released a list of elements that Rowling allegedly plagiarized from her books. 90% of them are generic stuff you could find in any fiction fantasy story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Website down now


* ReclusiveArtist: Although the website [=RealMuggles=].com is still online, Stouffer's whereabouts are very hazy (According to her FAQ, she lives somewhere in Pennsylvania), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.

to:

* ReclusiveArtist: Although the website [=RealMuggles=].com is was still online, online before 2017, Stouffer's whereabouts are were very hazy (According to her FAQ, she lives somewhere in Pennsylvania), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReclusiveArtist: Although the website {{=RealMuggles=}}.com is still online, Stouffer's whereabouts are very hazy (According to her FAQ, she lives somewhere in Pennsylvania), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.

to:

* ReclusiveArtist: Although the website {{=RealMuggles=}}.[=RealMuggles=].com is still online, Stouffer's whereabouts are very hazy (According to her FAQ, she lives somewhere in Pennsylvania), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReclusiveArtist: Although the website {{RealMuggles}}.com is still online, Stouffer's whereabouts are very hazy (According to her FAQ, she lives somewhere in Pennsylvania), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.

to:

* ReclusiveArtist: Although the website {{RealMuggles}}.{{=RealMuggles=}}.com is still online, Stouffer's whereabouts are very hazy (According to her FAQ, she lives somewhere in Pennsylvania), and any attempt to contact her resulted fruitless. This is understandable, as enraged Harry Potter fans flooded her chat page with death threats after the lawsuit debacle.

Top