Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Theatre / AidaJohnRice

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalJerkass: Radames is introduced less sympathetically than his operatic counterpart, treating the newly-enslaved Aida in a less than kind way (see DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything, below), though he soon goes through positive CharacterDevelopment as he falls in love with her.

to:

* AdaptationalJerkass: Radames is introduced less sympathetically than his operatic counterpart, treating the newly-enslaved Aida in a less than kind way (see DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything, below), way, though he soon goes through positive CharacterDevelopment as he falls in love with her.



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Rumours of it being filmed by Disney circulated in 2007, with Beyonce Knowles as Aida and Christina Aguilera as Amneris, but nothing more has ever been announced. Since the film was supposed to release in 2010 and hasn't started production, it's likely that it got swallowed up in DevelopmentHell.

to:

Rumours of it being filmed by Disney circulated in 2007, with Beyonce Knowles Music/{{Beyonce}} as Aida and Christina Aguilera Music/ChristinaAguilera as Amneris, but nothing more has ever been announced. Since the film was supposed to release in 2010 and hasn't started production, it's likely that it got swallowed up in DevelopmentHell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* TriangRelations: Type 8: Radames and Amneris as childhood friends/arranged marriage, Amneris and Aida as friends, Aida and Radames as lovers. On romantic feelings alone, towards the beginning it's a type 5 or 10, and by the end more of a type 4 (Amneris A, Radames B, Aida C in both cases).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChildhoodFriendRomance[=/=]ChildhoodMarriagePromise: Radames tells Amneris, "I've loved you since we were children" and they've apparently been betrothed since then.

to:

* ChildhoodFriendRomance[=/=]ChildhoodMarriagePromise: ChildhoodFriendRomance: Radames tells Amneris, "I've loved you since we were children" and they've apparently been betrothed since then.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FinalLoveDuet: "Elaborate Lives (Reprise)" for Radames and Aida. Or, probably actually "Enchantment Passing Through (Reprise)" sung as the two lovers are [[spoiler:dying from deprivation of light and air whilst being buried alive for treason]].

to:

* FinalLoveDuet: "Elaborate Lives (Reprise)" for Radames and Aida. Or, probably actually "Enchantment Passing Through (Reprise)" sung as the two lovers are [[spoiler:dying from deprivation loss of light and air oxygen whilst being buried alive for treason]].

Changed: 169

Removed: 203

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
There is no white guy/black girl drama. The reason Radames and Aida's relationship is forbidden is because their countries are at war (not for racial reasons, but to exploit their resources) and because she is a slave and he's already betrothed (to the princess).


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Due to Egypt having been crossroads and melting pot since time immemorial, the BlackGalOnWhiteGuyDrama does not really make sense historically.
* BlackGalOnWhiteGuyDrama: While the racial difference isn't mentioned often, it's brought up enough for the audience to know that this is the major reason why Aida and Radames relationship is forbidden.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Due to Egypt having been crossroads and melting pot since time immemorial, the BlackGalOnWhiteGuyDrama does not really make sense historically.
* BlackGalOnWhiteGuyDrama: While the racial difference isn't mentioned often, it's brought up enough for the audience to know that this is the major reason why Aida and Radames relationship is forbidden.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/u2223p28t3d2196012f326dt20081007222400.jpg]]

to:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/u2223p28t3d2196012f326dt20081007222400.org/pmwiki/pub/images/81hhdsqk4xl_sl1395.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:''[[TagLine The timeless love story.]]'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/pascalheadley_249.jpg]]

to:

[[quoteright:300:https://static.[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/pascalheadley_249.jpg]]
org/pmwiki/pub/images/u2223p28t3d2196012f326dt20081007222400.jpg]]

Changed: 1336

Removed: 834

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The title character, Aida, is the Princess of Nubia. Her country has been invaded by the neighboring Egyptians, and their captain, Radames, captures her with a group of women, and not recognizing her, brings them back to Egypt. Aida becomes a slave to Egyptian Princess Amneris, who is [[ArrangedMarriage betrothed]] to Radames. Another slave in the palace, Mereb, recognizes Aida and reveals her to the other captives, who beg her to lead them to freedom. Aida tries to deal with her feelings for Radames when she hears her father has been captured.

to:

The title character, Aida, is the Princess of Nubia. Her country has been invaded by the neighboring Egyptians, and their captain, Radames, captures her with a group of women, and not recognizing her, brings them back to Egypt. Aida becomes a slave to Egyptian Princess Amneris, who is [[ArrangedMarriage betrothed]] to Radames. Another slave in the palace, Mereb, recognizes Aida and reveals her to the other captives, who beg her to lead them to freedom. As time goes on, Aida tries to deal with her finds herself developing feelings for Radames Radames, a development which is further complicated when she hears her father has been captured.
father, the king of Nubia, is arrested.



As for the opera it's based on, the story is slightly different: Radames, an officer in the Egyptian army, wants to become the commander of the invasion of Nubia, so that he may request to marry his beloved Aida, a slave of the pharaoh's daughter Amneris. He doesn't know that Amneris is in love with him, or that Aida is the daughter of the Nubian king. Suspecting something between them, Amneris deceives Aida into revealing her love for Radames by claiming he died in the campaign against Nubia. Radames gets his wish and defeats Nubia, bringing in many hostages, including Aida's father. Seeing Aida's anguish, Radames uses up his one wish from the pharaoh to free the Nubian slaves instead of asking for Aida's hand, and the pharaoh publicly engages him to Amneris.

While attempting to meet Radames at a temple before the wedding proceeds, Aida is blackmailed by her father to get Radames to reveal where the Egyptian army will be passing through on its way to defeat the rebelling Nubians. Aida convinces Radames to run away with her and he tells her the secret of the army's route. Aida's father [[WhatAnIdiot chooses that moment to spring out of the bushes, announce that that's where they'll attack the Egyptians and reveal to Radames exactly who he is.]] Horrified, Radames refuses the chance to rule Nubia with Aida and surrenders to Amneris and the priests, who catch him as Aida and her father flee. He is condemned to be BuriedAlive, but Aida sneaks into his tomb before it gets sealed, since she [[TearJerker cannot choose between her love and her homeland.]] The curtain falls as she dies.

to:

As for The musical differs from the opera it's based on, in a few ways. Most notably, the story opera begins with Radames and Aida already in love, while the musical depicts their first meeting and the development of their relationship. The musical also has Radames betrothed to Amneris for nearly a decade; in the opera, he's unaware that she's in love with him and the engagement is slightly different: Radames, an officer in sprung on him to his complete surprise. Additionally, the opera has Radames sentenced to die for revealing the plans of the Egyptian army, wants to become the commander of the invasion of Nubia, so that he may request to marry his beloved and Aida, a slave of the pharaoh's daughter Amneris. He doesn't know that Amneris is in love with him, or that Aida is the daughter of the Nubian king. Suspecting something between them, Amneris deceives Aida into revealing her love for Radames by claiming he died in the campaign against Nubia. Radames gets his wish and defeats Nubia, bringing in many hostages, including Aida's father. Seeing Aida's anguish, Radames uses up his one wish from the pharaoh to free the Nubian slaves instead of asking for Aida's hand, and the pharaoh publicly engages him to Amneris.

While attempting to meet Radames at a temple before the wedding proceeds, Aida is blackmailed by her father to get Radames to reveal where the Egyptian army will be passing through on its way to defeat the rebelling Nubians. Aida convinces Radames to run
who had gotten away with her and he tells her the secret of the army's route. Aida's father [[WhatAnIdiot chooses that moment to spring out of the bushes, announce that that's where they'll attack the Egyptians and reveal to Radames exactly who he is.]] Horrified, Radames refuses the chance to rule Nubia with Aida and surrenders to Amneris and the priests, who catch him as Aida and her father flee. He is condemned to be BuriedAlive, but Aida sneaks sneaking into his tomb before it gets sealed, since she [[TearJerker cannot choose between her love so they can be TogetherInDeath; in the musical, the crime is helping the Nubian king escape, and her homeland.]] The curtain falls as she dies.
Aida fails to escape and is captured and sentenced along with him. Finally, there's the closing scene which changes the DownerEnding to a BittersweetEnding.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalNationality: In Verdi's opera, Aida and Amonasro are Ethiopian. The musical has them from Nubia instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The title character, Aida, is the Princess of Nubia. Her country has been invaded by the neighboring Egyptians, and their captain, Radames, captures her with a group of women, and not recognizing her, brings them back to Egypt. Aida becomes a slave to Egyptian Prince}} Amneris, who is [[ArrangedMarriage betrothed]] to Radames. Another slave in the palace, Mereb, recognizes Aida and reveals her to the other captives, who beg her to lead them to freedom. Aida tries to deal with her feelings for Radames when she hears her father has been captured.

to:

The title character, Aida, is the Princess of Nubia. Her country has been invaded by the neighboring Egyptians, and their captain, Radames, captures her with a group of women, and not recognizing her, brings them back to Egypt. Aida becomes a slave to Egyptian Prince}} Princess Amneris, who is [[ArrangedMarriage betrothed]] to Radames. Another slave in the palace, Mereb, recognizes Aida and reveals her to the other captives, who beg her to lead them to freedom. Aida tries to deal with her feelings for Radames when she hears her father has been captured.



* OddFriendship: Aida and Amneris. Though she technically owns Aida, Amenris treats her kindly, and the two are able to relate well to one another, due to the fact that, unknown to Amneris, they are both princesses. In one of her last lines in the show, Amneris strongly suggests that she considers Aida a loved one.

to:

* OddFriendship: Aida and Amneris. Though she technically owns Aida, Amenris Amneris treats her kindly, and the two are able to relate well to one another, due to the fact that, unknown to Amneris, they are both princesses. In one of her last lines in the show, Amneris strongly suggests that she considers Aida a loved one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Due to Egypt having been crossroads and melting pot since time immemorial, the BlackGalOnWhiteGuyDrama does not really make sense historically.

Added: 157

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FauxActionGirl: Maybe if Aida, who supposedly has skill with a sword, had done something during the climactic fight at the end, [[spoiler: Mereb wouldn't have died.]]

to:

* FauxActionGirl: Maybe if Aida, who supposedly has skill with a sword, had done something during the climactic fight at the end, [[spoiler: Mereb wouldn't have died.]]died]].
** [[FauxActionGirl Faux Action Guy]]: Same goes for Radames, the literal army general who also doesn't do much anything in the same big skirmish at the end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The word "princess" is not a trope.


The title character, Aida, is the {{Princess}} of Nubia. Her country has been invaded by the neighboring Egyptians, and their captain, Radames, captures her with a group of women, and not recognizing her, brings them back to Egypt. Aida becomes a slave to Egyptian {{Princess}} Amneris, who is [[ArrangedMarriage betrothed]] to Radames. Another slave in the palace, Mereb, recognizes Aida and reveals her to the other captives, who beg her to lead them to freedom. Aida tries to deal with her feelings for Radames when she hears her father has been captured.

to:

The title character, Aida, is the {{Princess}} Princess of Nubia. Her country has been invaded by the neighboring Egyptians, and their captain, Radames, captures her with a group of women, and not recognizing her, brings them back to Egypt. Aida becomes a slave to Egyptian {{Princess}} Prince}} Amneris, who is [[ArrangedMarriage betrothed]] to Radames. Another slave in the palace, Mereb, recognizes Aida and reveals her to the other captives, who beg her to lead them to freedom. Aida tries to deal with her feelings for Radames when she hears her father has been captured.


* SpoiledSweet: Amneris initially enjoys the many material possessions she is presented with, but is disturbed to learn where they come from and at what cost.
--> '''Amneris''': ''(while discussing Egypt's invasion plans with Zoser)'' So our Egyptian Armies just burst in and seize power!?!\\
'''Zoser''': Well, yes. But Your Highness, these wars have provided that beautiful necklace you are wearing.\\
'''Amneris''': ''(taking off said necklace and leaving it on the table)'' Suddenly, I don't find it that beautiful anymore.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


But in my heart I know it's rather sad...\\''

to:

But in my heart I know it's rather sad...\\''''\\



Is dismissed, inconsequential''

to:

Is dismissed, inconsequential''inconsequential''\\



So I'll flutter to deceive\\''

to:

So I'll flutter to deceive\\''deceive''\\

Added: 316

Changed: 825

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%% * TheFashionista: Amneris, who even has a super fun IAmSong about it.

to:

%% * TheFashionista: Amneris, who even has Amneris. Her first number is a super fun huge IAmSong about it.



%% * TheDitz: Amneris. She gets better.

to:

%% * TheDitz: Subverted with Amneris. She gets better.initially seems to be this, but later admits that she's really just playing the role people expect of her.



%% * TheHighQueen: Amneris becomes this at the end.
%% * IAmNotMyFather: Radames' lines in "Like Father Like Son" are all about this.
%% * IAmSong: "My Strongest Suit"

to:

%% * TheHighQueen: Amneris becomes this Pharaoh at the end.
%% * IAmNotMyFather: Radames' lines in "Like Father Like Son" are all about this.
%%
Radames is very, very determined that this is the case.
* IAmSong: "My Strongest Suit"



%% * IWantSong: "Fortune Favors the Brave"
* LikeFatherLikeSon: Cleverly murdered in the song of the same name, as though Radames fails at turning it into a TheVillainSucksSong, it's not so much InTheBlood as Zoser thought.

to:

%% * IWantSong: "Fortune Favors the Brave"
* LikeFatherLikeSon: Cleverly murdered in In the song of the same with this name, as though Zoser tries to convince Radames fails at turning it into a TheVillainSucksSong, it's not so much InTheBlood as Zoser thought.that this is the case, but Radames isn't buying it.



** Also, Amneris. It kicks into high gear during "I Know The Truth", where she sings about her realization that her upcoming marriage is a sham--as she's dressing for her wedding.
--->''I feel better when beguiling\\

to:

** Also, Amneris. It kicks into high gear during "I Know The Truth", where she sings about her realization that her upcoming marriage is a sham--as she's dressing for her wedding.
--->''I
Amneris.
--->'''Amneris''': ''I
feel better when beguiling\\



But in my heart i know it's sad...\\
So I'll flutter to deceive\\
No, you must believe, that one day you'll find a different\\

to:

But in my heart i I know it's rather sad...\\''
'''Aida''': ''That a life of great potential\\
Is dismissed, inconsequential''
'''Amneris''': ''And only ever seen as being cute.
\\
So I'll flutter to deceive\\
No,
deceive\\''
'''Aida''':''No,
you must believe, that one day you'll find a different\\you're bound to find\\



*** Kicks into high gear during "I Know The Truth", where she sings about her realization that her upcoming marriage is a sham -- as she's dressing for her wedding.



%% * VillainSong: "Another Pyramid"; though Zoser isn't the BigBad, he's clearly evil.
%% * VoiceoverLetter: Appropriately enough, "Radames' Letter."

to:

%% * VillainSong: "Another Pyramid"; though Zoser isn't the BigBad, he's clearly evil.
%%
Pyramid", "Like Father Like Son"
* VoiceoverLetter: Appropriately enough, "Radames' Letter."Letter"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Amneris''': ''(while discussing with Zoser Egypts military plans)'' So our Egyptian Armies just burst in and seize power!?!\\

to:

--> '''Amneris''': ''(while discussing Egypt's invasion plans with Zoser Egypts military plans)'' Zoser)'' So our Egyptian Armies just burst in and seize power!?!\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SparedByTheAdaptation: [[spoiler: Aida's father is killed in the opera, but escapes in the musical, with [[CanonForeigner Mereb]] killed instead.]]
* SpoiledSweet: Amneris, kind but enjoys the many material possessions she is presented, though after learning the innocent blood that was shed to provide it for her, she grows out of it.

to:

* SparedByTheAdaptation: [[spoiler: Aida's [[spoiler:Aida's father is killed in the opera, but escapes in the musical, with [[CanonForeigner Mereb]] killed instead.]]
* SpoiledSweet: Amneris, kind but Amneris initially enjoys the many material possessions she is presented, though after learning the innocent blood that was shed presented with, but is disturbed to provide it for her, she grows out of it.learn where they come from and at what cost.



'''Zoser''': Well, yes. But you're highness these wars have provided that beautiful necklace you are wearing.\\

to:

'''Zoser''': Well, yes. But you're highness Your Highness, these wars have provided that beautiful necklace you are wearing.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OddFriendship: Aida and Amneris, though she technically owns Aida, Amenris treats her kindly, and the two are able to relate well to one another, due to the fact that, unknown to Amneris, they are both princesses.

to:

* OddFriendship: Aida and Amneris, though Amneris. Though she technically owns Aida, Amenris treats her kindly, and the two are able to relate well to one another, due to the fact that, unknown to Amneris, they are both princesses.princesses. In one of her last lines in the show, Amneris strongly suggests that she considers Aida a loved one.

Top