Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / ThePeopleVOJSimpson

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CastingGag: Christian Clemenson is probably most well known to audiences for playing a lawyer on ''Series/BostonLegal''. However, his character on that show was a BunnyEarsLawyer with Asperger's syndrome who was usually a comical character. Here, he plays the coolheaded DeadpanSnarker Bill Hodgman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While the show has many other minor departures and alterations from its source material, "The Run of His Life" by Jeffrey Toobin, one of the more major ones may very well be the portrayal of Robert Kardashian. The show depicts him as a well-meaning, slightly naive and [[ConflictingLoyalty morally conflicted]] [[TrueCompanions loyal friend]] of Simpson's, while Toobin in his book views Kardashian as a frantic, obsessive sycophant clinging to media attention out of envy for his ex-wife Kris Jenner's success in the media. Of course, others have also taken issue with Toobin's book and argued that many of the details in his book are flat out wrong (including members of the prosecution team). The basics of Kardashian's character arc, coming to doubt Simpson's innocence during the trial and their friendship dissolving afterwards, are undoubtedly true. So this is one instance where the TV adaptation may actually be more true to real life than the source material was.

to:

** While the show has many other minor departures and alterations from its source material, "The ''The Run of His Life" Life: The People v. O. J. Simpson'' by Jeffrey Toobin, one of the more major ones may very well be the portrayal of Robert Kardashian. The show depicts him as a well-meaning, slightly naive and [[ConflictingLoyalty morally conflicted]] [[TrueCompanions loyal friend]] of Simpson's, while Toobin in his book views Kardashian as a frantic, obsessive sycophant clinging to media attention out of envy for his ex-wife Kris Jenner's success in the media. Of course, others have also taken issue with Toobin's book and argued that many of the details in his book are flat out wrong (including members of the prosecution team). The basics of Kardashian's character arc, coming to doubt Simpson's innocence during the trial and their friendship dissolving afterwards, are undoubtedly true. So this is one instance where the TV adaptation may actually be more true to real life than the source material was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Although he is acquitted of the murders, O.J. ends up being shunned by the Brentwood neighborhood and his golfing buddies, and in the latter case, he is no longer welcome at the Riviera Country Club. His party was attended by people he's never seen before, who just came for the novelty that the televised trial created around him. He also loses his friendship with Robert Kardashian. The final shot of the episode has him sadly looking at the statue of himself, reminiscing about his GloryDays as a football player, and realizing that he's all alone. And, of course, there's the knowledge that O.J. later did ultimately wind up in jail and sentenced to 33 years in prison for a different crime [[LaserGuidedKarma exactly 13 years after he was acquitted]].

to:

** Although he is acquitted of the murders, O.J. ends up being shunned by the Brentwood neighborhood and his golfing buddies, and in the latter case, he is no longer welcome at the Riviera Country Club. His party was attended by people he's never seen before, who just came for the novelty that the televised trial created around him. He also loses his friendship with Robert Kardashian. The final shot of the episode has him sadly looking at the statue of himself, reminiscing about his GloryDays as a football player, and realizing that he's all alone. And, of course, there's the knowledge that O.J. later did ultimately wind up in jail and sentenced to 33 years in prison for a different crime [[LaserGuidedKarma exactly 13 years after later to the day he was acquitted]].

Added: 135

Changed: 29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** F. Lee Bailey was later disbarred for attorney misconduct in Florida and Massachusetts, with Robert Shapiro testifying against him.



** The families of Nicole and Ron thoroughly believe O.J. was guilty and received no justice for the murder of their loved ones (though in the latter case, the Goldmans are seen thinking about pursuing additional criminal action, a nod to the eventual civil trial that would take place later in which O.J. got the pants sued off of him by the Goldmans).

to:

** The families of Nicole and Ron thoroughly believe O.J. was guilty and received no justice for the murder of their loved ones (though in the latter case, the Goldmans are seen thinking about pursuing additional criminal action, a nod to the eventual civil trial that would take place later in which O.J. got the pants sued off of him by the Goldmans).Goldmans and owed $33.5 million).



** Averted with Judge Lance Ito, who retired in 2015, after the trial made him a household name.

to:

** Averted with Judge Lance Ito, who retired in 2015, after the trial made him a household name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Averted with Judge Lance Ito, who retired in 2015, presided over 500 trials after trial made him a household name.

to:

** Averted with Judge Lance Ito, who retired in 2015, presided over 500 trials after the trial made him a household name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Averted with Judge Lance Ito, who retired in 2015, presided over 500 trials after trial made him a household name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Although he is acquitted of the murders, O.J. ends up being shunned by the Brentwood neighborhood and his golfing buddies, and in the latter case, he is no longer welcome at the Riviera Country Club. His party was attended by people he's never seen before, who just came for the novelty that the televised trial created around him. He also loses his friendship with Robert Kardashian. The final shot of the episode has him sadly looking at the statue of himself, reminiscing about his GloryDays as a football player, and realizing that he's all alone. And, of course, there's the knowledge that O.J. later did ultimately wind up in jail and sentenced to 33 years in prison for a different crime ''exactly 13 years after he was acquitted.''

to:

** Although he is acquitted of the murders, O.J. ends up being shunned by the Brentwood neighborhood and his golfing buddies, and in the latter case, he is no longer welcome at the Riviera Country Club. His party was attended by people he's never seen before, who just came for the novelty that the televised trial created around him. He also loses his friendship with Robert Kardashian. The final shot of the episode has him sadly looking at the statue of himself, reminiscing about his GloryDays as a football player, and realizing that he's all alone. And, of course, there's the knowledge that O.J. later did ultimately wind up in jail and sentenced to 33 years in prison for a different crime ''exactly [[LaserGuidedKarma exactly 13 years after he was acquitted.'' acquitted]].



* ConflictingLoyalty: Robert Kardashian is close friends with both O.J. and Nicole, and is initially O.J.'s staunchest supporter, but as the trial progresses, he increasingly doubts O.J.'s innocence, especially after DNA evidence is introduced. By the end of the series, Rob has ended his friendship with O.J., and according to the epilogue, they didn't speak with each other again before Rob's death in 2003.
* ConvictedByPublicOpinion: The finale makes it clear that O.J.'s family, friends, and neighbors all believe him to be guilty regardless of his verdict, and that much of the nation has effectively judged him guilty too.

to:

* ConflictingLoyalty: Robert Kardashian is close friends with both O.J. and Nicole, and is initially O.J.'s staunchest supporter, but as the trial progresses, he increasingly doubts O.J.'s innocence, especially after DNA evidence is introduced. By the end of the series, Rob has ended his friendship with O.J., and according to the epilogue, they didn't speak with to each other again before Rob's death in 2003.
* ConvictedByPublicOpinion: The finale makes it clear that O.J.'s family, friends, and neighbors all believe him to be guilty regardless of his verdict, acquittal, and that much of the nation has effectively judged him guilty too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Although he is acquitted of the murders, O.J. ends up being shunned by the Brentwood neighborhood and his golfing buddies, and in the latter case, he is no longer welcome at the Riviera Country Club. His party was attended by people he's never seen before, who just came for the novelty that the televised trial created around him. He also loses his friendship with Robert Kardashian. The final shot of the episode has him sadly looking at the statue of himself, reminiscing about his GloryDays as a football player, and realizing that he's all alone. And, of course, there's the knowledge that O.J. later did ultimately wind up in Jail and sentenced to 33 years in prison for a different crime ''exactly 13 years after he was acquitted.''

to:

** Although he is acquitted of the murders, O.J. ends up being shunned by the Brentwood neighborhood and his golfing buddies, and in the latter case, he is no longer welcome at the Riviera Country Club. His party was attended by people he's never seen before, who just came for the novelty that the televised trial created around him. He also loses his friendship with Robert Kardashian. The final shot of the episode has him sadly looking at the statue of himself, reminiscing about his GloryDays as a football player, and realizing that he's all alone. And, of course, there's the knowledge that O.J. later did ultimately wind up in Jail jail and sentenced to 33 years in prison for a different crime ''exactly 13 years after he was acquitted.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Although he is acquitted of the murders, O.J. ends up being shunned by the Brentwood neighborhood and his golfing buddies, and in the latter case, he is no longer welcome at the Riviera Country Club. His party was attended by people he's never seen before, who just came for the novelty that the televised trial created around him. He also loses his friendship with Robert Kardashian. The final shot of the episode has him sadly looking at the statue of himself, reminiscing about his GloryDays as a football player, and realizing that he's all alone. And, of course, there's the knowledge that O.J. later did ultimately wind up sentenced to 33 years in prison for a different crime.

to:

** Although he is acquitted of the murders, O.J. ends up being shunned by the Brentwood neighborhood and his golfing buddies, and in the latter case, he is no longer welcome at the Riviera Country Club. His party was attended by people he's never seen before, who just came for the novelty that the televised trial created around him. He also loses his friendship with Robert Kardashian. The final shot of the episode has him sadly looking at the statue of himself, reminiscing about his GloryDays as a football player, and realizing that he's all alone. And, of course, there's the knowledge that O.J. later did ultimately wind up in Jail and sentenced to 33 years in prison for a different crime. crime ''exactly 13 years after he was acquitted.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: For all parties involved:

to:

* BittersweetEnding: For all ''all'' parties involved:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Fuhrman retired from the LAPD during the trial, was charged with perjury, received three years’ probation, and paid a $200 fine.

to:

** Fuhrman Mark Furhman retired from the LAPD during the trial, was charged with perjury, received three years’ probation, and paid a $200 fine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Fuhrman retired from the LAPD during the trial, was charged with perjury, received three years’ probation, and paid a $200 fine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "100 Percent Not Guilty", Robert Shapiro tries to convince F. Lee Bailey to defend O.J. pro bono. Bailey responds by conspiring with Johnnie Cochran to let Cochran take over.

to:

** In "100 Percent % Not Guilty", Robert Shapiro tries to convince F. Lee Bailey to defend O.J. pro bono. Bailey responds by conspiring with Johnnie Cochran to let Cochran take over.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** O.J. himself too. He gets acquitted of murder, but is convicted by the court of public opinion and all of his friends abandon him afterward, including his best friend Robert. The title cards before the credits mention his civil trial with the Goldmans (which left him bankrupt), and his robbery trial after that (which actually did send him to prison).

to:

** O.J. himself too. He gets acquitted of murder, but is convicted by the court of public opinion and all of his friends abandon him afterward, including his best friend Robert. The title cards before the credits mention his civil trial with the Goldmans (which left him bankrupt), and his robbery trial in 2007 after that (which actually did send him to prison).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In one part of the case, Gil says to one of his political staff he'll be surprised if people are talking about this OJ Simpson case next year.


Added DiffLines:

** Marcia Clark ignores all of Darden's warnings to not use Fuhrman, casting Darden's concerns as being overblown every time.
** Chris Darden is SURE that Simpson trying on the gloves will be a big moment for the defense. To say it backfired horribly would be an understatement.
** When Clark and Darden hear of the Jury having decided the verdict in 4 hours, they speculate that maybe the jury didn't need much deliberation in light of all the evidence. Chris says "What if we won?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigotWithABadge: The Los Angeles Police Department's history of racism is weaponized by Simpson's defense team who put forth the theory that he was framed by police officers. Arguably the biggest blow to the prosecution's case is the revelation that the arresting officer, Mark Fuhrman, had a history of racist behavior, uttering racist epithets and admitting on tape to beating black suspects and planting evidence.

Added: 1848

Changed: 1542

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: The real-life Mark Fuhrman was much more complex than depicted. He indeed had a history of racism, which he himself even admitted to when he checked himself in for rehabilitation, and past acquaintances had complained that he had made racist remarks in the past. However, independent investigations discovered that, after said rehabilitation, he had a dearth of civilian complaints against him; he had successfully partnered with nonwhite cops (including a black female officer intentionally partnered with him to test to see if his racism continued) who considered him a friend and never felt uncomfortable with him; he had been called to Simpson's residence to answer a domestic disturbance call from Nicole and nevertheless did nothing to Simpson, and he had personally taken it upon himself to protect a black female witness who felt endangered (and befriended her as well; she would go on to defend his post-trial character). Even the infamous tapes were a product of him being paid to exaggerate a "police" style of speech. In the series, he's depicted as little more than a remorseless, two-faced racist who outright lied on the stand and ''owned Nazi memorabilia.''[[note]]In real life, to qualify for perjury, the lie has to be about something material to the trial; as many lawyers did not consider the race angle of the trial to be relevant, his lie about the use of the slur was considered by many professionals to not be perjury, as he was rightly embarrassed to admit it in front of a jury with many African-Americans.[[/note]]

to:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: HistoricalVillainUpgrade:
**
The real-life Mark Fuhrman was much more complex than depicted. He indeed had a history of racism, which he himself even admitted to when he checked himself in for rehabilitation, and past acquaintances had complained that he had made racist remarks in the past. However, independent investigations discovered that, after said rehabilitation, he had a dearth of civilian complaints against him; he had successfully partnered with nonwhite cops (including a black female officer intentionally partnered with him to test to see if his racism continued) who considered him a friend and never felt uncomfortable with him; he had been called to Simpson's residence to answer a domestic disturbance call from Nicole and nevertheless did nothing to Simpson, and he had personally taken it upon himself to protect a black female witness who felt endangered (and befriended her as well; she would go on to defend his post-trial character). Even the infamous tapes were a product of him being paid to exaggerate a "police" style of speech. In the series, he's depicted as little more than a remorseless, two-faced racist who outright lied on the stand and ''owned Nazi memorabilia.''[[note]]In real life, to qualify for perjury, the lie has to be about something material to the trial; as many lawyers did not consider the race angle of the trial to be relevant, his lie about the use of the slur was considered by many professionals to not be perjury, as he was rightly embarrassed to admit it in front of a jury with many African-Americans.[[/note]][[/note]]
** Downplayed with Johnny Cochran. While much of his actions and personality are a spot-on impression, at no point did he threaten Judge Ito that he would start another race riot (with the wanton loss of life and destruction of property that inevitably entails) unless he complied with Cochran's demands.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PowerWalk: The Dream Team perform a version of this when they first walk into the courtroom for OJ's trial, led by Johnny Cochran, and set to Above the Law's "Black Superman".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The People v. O.J. Simpson'' is the first season of the Creator/RyanMurphy-produced {{true crime}} {{anthology}} series ''Series/AmericanCrimeStory'', aired by Creator/{{FX|Networks}} in 2016.

Adapted from the non-fiction book ''The Run of His Life: The People v. O.J. Simpson'' by Jeffrey Toobin, it covers the infamous [[UsefulNotes/OJSimpson O.J. Simpson murder trial]] that spanned eleven months between [[UsefulNotes/TheNineties 1994 and 1995]].

to:

''The People v. O. J. Simpson'' is the first season of the Creator/RyanMurphy-produced {{true crime}} {{anthology}} series ''Series/AmericanCrimeStory'', aired by Creator/{{FX|Networks}} in 2016.

Adapted from the non-fiction book ''The Run of His Life: The People v. O. J. Simpson'' by Jeffrey Toobin, it covers the infamous [[UsefulNotes/OJSimpson O.J. Simpson Creator/OJSimpson murder trial]] trial that spanned eleven months between [[UsefulNotes/TheNineties 1994 and 1995]].



!! ''The People v. O.J. Simpson'' contains examples of the following tropes:

* TwentyFourHourPartyPeople: Heavily implied in the resolution. OJ has a "not guilty" party thrown at his house and he gradually noticed that, other than a select few like his immediate family, he didn't actually know anyone there.

to:

!! ''The People v. O. J. Simpson'' contains examples of the following tropes:

* TwentyFourHourPartyPeople: Heavily implied in the resolution. OJ O. J. has a "not guilty" party thrown at his house and he gradually noticed that, other than a select few like his immediate family, he didn't actually know anyone there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheWholeWorldIsWatching: Simpson's flight from the cops in a white Bronco is watched by millions of people. This is what inspires Johnny Cochrane to become his defense attorney when Simpson is accused of murder; Cochrane rightly assumes that the murder trial will get similarly large viewership numbers, and intends to use that publicity to present evidence of the LAPD's racism to an audience that might not have seen it otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Clark dismisses the Dream Team as a bunch of egotists who will implode, not understanding they know how to play the media game a lot better than her.

to:

** Clark dismisses the Dream Team O.J's lawyers as a bunch of egotists who will implode, not understanding they know how to play the media game a lot better than her. This is somewhat justified as before Cochran joined, the Dream Team's members did not inspire much in the way of confidence; Shapiro is more known for getting settlements than winning cases, Bailey's alcoholism had made him a laughing stock, Kardashian hadn't practiced law in years (Hodgman even states he had no idea he was a lawyer) and their hiring Alan Dershowitz, a well-known appeals expert, suggested they were convinced Simpson would be convicted. As the trial progresses, we see the folly of underestimating the Dream Team as they repeatedly run circles around the prosecution both in and outside of the courtroom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed YMMV pothole


** In-universe, the fear of appearing to be a white prosecution team out to convict a black man results in the DA's office inviting Christopher Darden to join them. The episode ends with O.J. wondering aloud "[[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments When did they get a black guy?]]". Then it's deconstructed when Darden confides in Marcia that being accused of this implies that he has no ability as an attorney himself, and that he "stole" the spot from a worthier person, just like how he was treated 20 years before when his classmates assumed he only got into college thanks to affirmative action. Later, after a (thoroughly avoidable) disaster for the prosecution, Darden explodes at Marcia for treating him like a token and not listening to him.

to:

** In-universe, the fear of appearing to be a white prosecution team out to convict a black man results in the DA's office inviting Christopher Darden to join them. The episode ends with O.J. wondering aloud "[[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments When "When did they get a black guy?]]".guy?". Then it's deconstructed when Darden confides in Marcia that being accused of this implies that he has no ability as an attorney himself, and that he "stole" the spot from a worthier person, just like how he was treated 20 years before when his classmates assumed he only got into college thanks to affirmative action. Later, after a (thoroughly avoidable) disaster for the prosecution, Darden explodes at Marcia for treating him like a token and not listening to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Honest prosectors wanting to put who they believe to be a murderer behind bars.
** A police force that while correct about arresting a murderer, is plagued with lots of corruption and racism.

to:

** Honest prosectors wanting to put who they believe to be a murderer behind bars.
bars, but who drop the ball due to a combination of arrogance and idealism.
** A police force that while correct about arresting wants to put who they believe to be a murderer, murderer in jail, but is plagued staffed with lots of corruption racist and racism.corrupt cops.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Changed: 374

Removed: 620

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HardTruthAesop:
** Celebrity and fame can blind and corrupt anybody. Robert, an otherwise decent guy, allows his own admiration of O.J. to blind him to his obvious guilt, until it is too late to leave the case, and his own children end up being consumed by it.
** You can't fight a broken system while participating in it. Marcia Clark and Chris Darden fail to bring O.J. to justice, despite their beliefs that they could help the bereaved families, and are lambasted in the media for supposed incompetence. Retiring and becoming college professors means that they can do more good while helping students and taking care of their health.

to:

* HardTruthAesop:
** Celebrity and fame can blind and corrupt anybody. Robert, an otherwise decent guy, allows his own admiration of O.J. to blind him to his obvious guilt, until it is too late to leave the case, and his own children end up being consumed by it.
**
HardTruthAesop: You can't fight a broken system while participating in it. Marcia Clark and Chris Darden fail to bring O.J. to justice, despite their beliefs that they could help the bereaved families, and are lambasted in the media for supposed incompetence. Retiring and becoming college professors means that they can do more good while helping students and taking care of their health.

Added: 59

Removed: 59

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Kris Jenner was pregnant when Nicole Brown was murdered.



** Kris Jenner was pregnant when Nicole Brown was murdered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Kris Jenner was pregnant when Nicole Brown was murdered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For O.J. He's acquitted, but all his friends have abandonned him and he's a pariah to everyone else.

to:

** For O.J. He's acquitted, but all his friends have abandonned abandoned him and he's a pariah to everyone else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ito is shown facepalming when he sees a TV parody of him. In real life Ito actually found the parodies of him very flattering[[note]]In a post-trial interview, a horrified Kardashian recalled an incident where Ito actually made the jury wait an extra ten minutes in the courtroom while he was in chambers showing the attorneys Jay Leno's latest "Dancing Itos" skit[[/note]]. This may be shorthand for Ito's post-trial reluctance to engage with the media; to this day, he regularly refuses interviews and is one of the few major figures in the Simpson case not to write a book or memoir about it.

to:

** Ito is shown facepalming when he sees a TV parody of him. In real life life, Ito actually found the parodies of him very flattering[[note]]In a post-trial interview, a horrified Kardashian recalled an incident where Ito actually made the jury wait an extra ten minutes in the courtroom while he was in chambers showing the attorneys Jay Leno's latest "Dancing Itos" skit[[/note]]. This may be shorthand for Ito's post-trial reluctance to engage with the media; to this day, he regularly refuses interviews and is one of the few major figures in the Simpson case not to write a book or memoir about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguousSituation: In episode 5, Johnnie Cochran is pulled over by a cop while taking his daughters to the movies. Cochran assumes he is being racially profiled and almost gets arrested when he gets into an argument with the officer, but the way the situation plays out actually leaves it ambiguous whether the incident was racially motivated or not. Cochran disputes the cop's assertion that he forgot to signal a turn, but before the cop can properly respond Cochran immediately goes into a rant about racial injustice. If the cop ''was'' acting in good faith all along, his subsequent response to Cochran's hostility is fully warranted.

to:

* AmbiguousSituation: In episode Episode 5, Johnnie Cochran is pulled over by a cop while taking his daughters to the movies. Cochran assumes he is being racially profiled and almost gets arrested when he gets into an argument with the officer, but the way the situation plays out actually leaves it ambiguous whether the incident was racially motivated or not. Cochran disputes the cop's assertion that he forgot to signal a turn, but before the cop can properly respond Cochran immediately goes into a rant about racial injustice. If the cop ''was'' acting in good faith all along, his subsequent response to Cochran's hostility is fully warranted.

Top