Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / TheKnick

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*AccidentalMurder: Discussed when it comes to the deaths of surgery patients, since they are frequent. Even leaving aside legal exculpation, the patient was going to die anyway if they ''didn't'' get the surgery, so the surgeons shouldn't put the burden of their death on themselves if the surgery fails.
--->'''Doctor:''' It's a shame we couldn't save him.
--->'''Dr Thackery:''' He was already doomed when he entered. We were simply attempting to reverse his fate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 2571

Changed: 462

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeliberateValuesDissonance:
** A ton of it. Barrow is an enthusiastic racist and social Darwinist, while Gallinger is extremely resentful of Dr. Edwards on account of his color. The Knick's board are also casually sexist towards Miss Robertson, who has to present a signed copy of her father's proxy in order to participate in the meeting.

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance:
**
DeliberateValuesDissonance: A ton of it. Barrow it:
**The ambulance buggy is essentially a shakedown/injury chasing operation. Amongst other things, they mention hanging around damaged architecture to wait for it to break and hurt someone, and threaten to beat up ambulance drivers from other hospitals threatening to "steal their client."
**White immigrants from Ireland or Wales are frequently mentioned disparagingly by multiple classes, as unclean, uneducated, spreaders of disease, and more, although it's often reprimanded by more liberal thinkers present.
**The hospital gets bodies to practice techniques with on a case-by-case basis and are seen trawling sites of frequent death essentially praying for more.
--->'''Barrow:''' I've visited ''every'' indigent house, prison, and drunkard ward!
**In the first episode, a girl who can't be more than nine has to leave her mom's bedside to get to her 5 PM shift at the waistshirt factory. Despite this being a big day, she's bundled into a cab and they just have to rely that the cabbie will supervise her arrival correctly.
**Cocaine is understood as potent, but is used frequently as part of anesthetic and other solutions, casually referred to as such. To those mainly familiar with it as a party drug, it's quite unusual.
**Barrow
is an enthusiastic racist and social Darwinist, while Gallinger is extremely resentful of Dr. Edwards on account of his color. The
**The
Knick's board are also casually sexist towards Miss Robertson, who has to present a signed copy of her father's proxy in order to participate in the meeting.


Added DiffLines:

*EstablishingSeriesMoment: The first twenty minutes of the premiere. Dr Thack awakes in an opium den and goes directly to work, injecting himself in the toe vein with ''something'' on the way. He checks in to perform surgery before a hundred watching men alongside his mentor Dr. Christiansen, proudly announcing that with their new technique, they should be able to save the patient within one hundred seconds. Then the patient is wheeled in and we see she's a frightened young woman with a very pregnant belly, whose only words are, "Please, save my baby." One hundred ''very'' bloody seconds later, the mother and child are both dead, and the men immediately go to wash up. Despite Thack assuring Christiansen that "the procedure failed, not you," Christiansen goes into his office, lays down a white sheet on the couch, and blows his brains out. But then at his funeral, Thack makes a passionate argument that despite the cost, and even manner of his death, advancing medical science IS worth it. Then Thack attends a meeting of this prestigious hospital's board of directors and learn that they're operating at a $30,000 per year deficit. Medicine is complex, psychologically stressful, expensive, and its practitioners are flawed, but real lives are on the line, and if it means deaths might be prevented in the future, it IS worth it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BackAlleyDoctor: Edwards becomes one at the beginning of the series in order to take care of black patients the hospital turns away. He's able to do this ''in the hospital's own basement'' for weeks or months thanks largely due to the dismissiveness of his white colleagues. In a testament to his skill, he only loses one patient in that time despite subpar conditions.

to:

* BackAlleyDoctor: Edwards becomes one at the beginning of the series in order to take care of black patients the hospital turns away. He's able to do this away, operating ''in the hospital's own basement'' for weeks or months thanks largely due to the dismissiveness of his white colleagues. In a testament to his skill, he only loses one patient in that time despite subpar conditions.conditions and then only because the patient didn't follow his post-care instructions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BackAlleyDoctor: Edwards becomes one at the beginning of the series in order to take care of black patients the hospital turns away. He's able to perform secret operations ''in the hospital's basement'' for weeks or months thanks largely due to the dismissiveness of his white colleagues. In a testament to his skill, despite subpar conditions, he only loses one patient in that time.

to:

* BackAlleyDoctor: Edwards becomes one at the beginning of the series in order to take care of black patients the hospital turns away. He's able to perform secret operations do this ''in the hospital's own basement'' for weeks or months thanks largely due to the dismissiveness of his white colleagues. In a testament to his skill, despite subpar conditions, he only loses one patient in that time.time despite subpar conditions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BackAlleyDoctor: Edwards becomes one at the beginning of the series in order to take care of black patients the hospital turns away. His skill makes him quite successful and the dismissiveness of his white colleagues means he's able to carry on for quite a while before he's discovered.

to:

* BackAlleyDoctor: Edwards becomes one at the beginning of the series in order to take care of black patients the hospital turns away. His skill makes him quite successful and He's able to perform secret operations ''in the hospital's basement'' for weeks or months thanks largely due to the dismissiveness of his white colleagues means he's able colleagues. In a testament to carry on for quite a while before he's discovered. his skill, despite subpar conditions, he only loses one patient in that time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Blackface}}: In the seventh episode of the second season, a vaudeville duo performs in blackface to entertain the partygoers in a ball.

to:

* {{Blackface}}: In the seventh episode of the second season, a vaudeville duo performs in blackface to entertain the partygoers in a ball. Oddly, considering how progressive they otherwise are regarding their race, both Edwards and his wife seem delighted by the performance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BackAlleyDoctor: Edwards becomes one at the beginning of the series in order to take care of black patients the hospital turns away.

to:

* BackAlleyDoctor: Edwards becomes one at the beginning of the series in order to take care of black patients the hospital turns away. His skill makes him quite successful and the dismissiveness of his white colleagues means he's able to carry on for quite a while before he's discovered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BackAlleyDoctor: Edwards becomes one at the beginning of the series in order to take care of black patients, as he mostly finds himself ignored by his white coworkers and relegated to tasks far beneath his skill.

to:

* BackAlleyDoctor: Edwards becomes one at the beginning of the series in order to take care of black patients, as he mostly finds himself ignored by his white coworkers and relegated to tasks far beneath his skill.patients the hospital turns away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Its indeed affectionate as episode six shows when Thack calls Bertie, Bertie the wise when he makes a guess he considers excellent. He even sais "Bertie the wise indeed!"

to:

*** Its indeed affectionate affectionate, as episode six shows when Thack calls Bertie, Bertie the wise "the Wise" when he makes a guess he Thack considers excellent. He even sais says "Bertie the wise Wise indeed!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Episode 9 of season 2 begins and ends with a flashback of Thack meeting Robertson in Nicaragua, with Robertson offering Thack a job at the Knick.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BackAlleyDoctor: Edwards is one of those in order to take care of black people.
* BadassBookworm: Algernon Edwards is a highly competent surgeon, at the edge of technical innovation. He also is able to pick up a fight and knock his opponent down at least twice in the ongoing series.

to:

* BackAlleyDoctor: Edwards is becomes one at the beginning of those the series in order to take care of black people.
patients, as he mostly finds himself ignored by his white coworkers and relegated to tasks far beneath his skill.
* BadassBookworm: Algernon Edwards is a highly competent surgeon, at the edge of technical innovation. He also is able to pick up a fight and knock his opponent down on at least twice in the ongoing series.two separate occasions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Knick'' is a medical drama that premiered on Creator/{{Cinemax}} in August 2014, and is set in New York in 1900. It stars Creator/CliveOwen as Dr. John 'Thack' Thackery, the cocaine-addicted Chief of Surgery at the Knickerbocker Hospital in New York City, who succeeded his mentor and the previous chief, Dr. J.M. Christiansen (Creator/MattFrewer). It also stars Creator/AndreHolland as Dr. Algernon Edwards, a brilliant and accomplished black surgeon, who joins The Knick as assistant chief of surgery, over Thackery's objections and despite the personal disdain of much of the hospital's all-white staff. Thack's work is overseen by hospital administrator Herman Barrow (Creator/JeremyBobb), a highly competent bureaucrat whose well-informed racist Social Darwinist worldview takes a back seat to his ruthless pragmatism and air of politeness. Thack and Barrow also have to contend with the wishes of the socially-progressive Miss Cornelia Robertson (Creator/JulietRylance), who represents her father, Captain August Robertson (Grainger Hines), who is the financially-strapped hospital's primary benefactor.

to:

''The Knick'' is a medical drama that premiered on Creator/{{Cinemax}} in August 2014, and is set in New York in 1900. It stars Creator/CliveOwen as Dr. John 'Thack' Thackery, the cocaine-addicted Chief of Surgery at the Knickerbocker Hospital in New York City, who succeeded his mentor and the previous chief, Dr. J.M. Christiansen (Creator/MattFrewer). It also stars Creator/AndreHolland as Dr. Algernon Edwards, a brilliant and accomplished black surgeon, who joins The Knick as assistant chief of surgery, over Thackery's objections and despite the personal disdain of much of the hospital's all-white staff. Thack's work is overseen by hospital administrator Herman Barrow (Creator/JeremyBobb), a highly competent bureaucrat whose well-informed racist Social Darwinist worldview takes a back seat to his ruthless pragmatism and air of politeness. Thack and Barrow also have to contend with the wishes of the socially-progressive Miss Cornelia Robertson (Creator/JulietRylance), who represents her father, Captain August Robertson (Grainger Hines), (Creator/GraingerHines), who is the financially-strapped hospital's primary benefactor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Knick'' is a medical drama that premiered on Creator/{{Cinemax}} in August 2014, and is set in New York in 1900. It stars Creator/CliveOwen as Dr. John 'Thack' Thackery, the cocaine-addicted Chief of Surgery at the Knickerbocker Hospital in New York City, who succeeded his mentor and the previous chief, Dr. J.M. Christiansen (Creator/MattFrewer). It also stars Creator/AndreHolland as Dr. Algernon Edwards, a brilliant and accomplished black surgeon, who joins The Knick as assistant chief of surgery, over Thackery's objections and despite the personal disdain of much of the hospital's all-white staff. Thack's work is overseen by hospital administrator Herman Barrow (Creator/JeremyBobb), a highly competent bureaucrat whose well-informed racist Social Darwinist worldview takes a back seat to his ruthless pragmatism and air of politeness. Thack and Barrow also have to contend with the wishes of the socially-progressive Miss Cornelia Robertson (Juliet Rylance), who represents her father, Captain August Robertson (Grainger Hines), who is the financially-strapped hospital's primary benefactor.

to:

''The Knick'' is a medical drama that premiered on Creator/{{Cinemax}} in August 2014, and is set in New York in 1900. It stars Creator/CliveOwen as Dr. John 'Thack' Thackery, the cocaine-addicted Chief of Surgery at the Knickerbocker Hospital in New York City, who succeeded his mentor and the previous chief, Dr. J.M. Christiansen (Creator/MattFrewer). It also stars Creator/AndreHolland as Dr. Algernon Edwards, a brilliant and accomplished black surgeon, who joins The Knick as assistant chief of surgery, over Thackery's objections and despite the personal disdain of much of the hospital's all-white staff. Thack's work is overseen by hospital administrator Herman Barrow (Creator/JeremyBobb), a highly competent bureaucrat whose well-informed racist Social Darwinist worldview takes a back seat to his ruthless pragmatism and air of politeness. Thack and Barrow also have to contend with the wishes of the socially-progressive Miss Cornelia Robertson (Juliet Rylance), (Creator/JulietRylance), who represents her father, Captain August Robertson (Grainger Hines), who is the financially-strapped hospital's primary benefactor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Knick'' is a medical drama that premiered on Creator/{{Cinemax}} in August 2014, and is set in New York in 1900. It stars Creator/CliveOwen as Dr. John 'Thack' Thackery, the cocaine-addicted Chief of Surgery at the Knickerbocker Hospital in New York City, who succeeded his mentor and the previous chief, Dr. J.M. Christiansen (Creator/MattFrewer). It also stars [[Film/FortyTwo Andre Holland]] as Dr. Algernon Edwards, a brilliant and accomplished black surgeon, who joins The Knick as assistant chief of surgery, over Thackery's objections and despite the personal disdain of much of the hospital's all-white staff. Thack's work is overseen by hospital administrator Herman Barrow ([[Series/HouseOfCardsUK Jeremy Bobb]]), a highly competent bureaucrat whose well-informed racist Social Darwinist worldview takes a back seat to his ruthless pragmatism and air of politeness. Thack and Barrow also have to contend with the wishes of the socially-progressive Miss Cornelia Robertson (Juliet Rylance), who represents her father, Captain August Robertson (Grainger Hines), who is the financially-strapped hospital's primary benefactor.

Also in the mix are several supporting characters, including junior surgeons Dr. Everett Gallinger ([[Series/FlashGordon2007 Eric Johnson]]) and Dr. Bertram Chickering, Jr. (Michael Angarano), Nurse Lucy Elkins (Eve Hewson), midwife Sister Harriet ([[Film/GangsOfNewYork Cara Seymour]]), ambulance driver Tom Cleary (Chris Sullivan) and New York City health inspector Jacob Speight (David Fierro).

to:

''The Knick'' is a medical drama that premiered on Creator/{{Cinemax}} in August 2014, and is set in New York in 1900. It stars Creator/CliveOwen as Dr. John 'Thack' Thackery, the cocaine-addicted Chief of Surgery at the Knickerbocker Hospital in New York City, who succeeded his mentor and the previous chief, Dr. J.M. Christiansen (Creator/MattFrewer). It also stars [[Film/FortyTwo Andre Holland]] Creator/AndreHolland as Dr. Algernon Edwards, a brilliant and accomplished black surgeon, who joins The Knick as assistant chief of surgery, over Thackery's objections and despite the personal disdain of much of the hospital's all-white staff. Thack's work is overseen by hospital administrator Herman Barrow ([[Series/HouseOfCardsUK Jeremy Bobb]]), (Creator/JeremyBobb), a highly competent bureaucrat whose well-informed racist Social Darwinist worldview takes a back seat to his ruthless pragmatism and air of politeness. Thack and Barrow also have to contend with the wishes of the socially-progressive Miss Cornelia Robertson (Juliet Rylance), who represents her father, Captain August Robertson (Grainger Hines), who is the financially-strapped hospital's primary benefactor.

Also in the mix are several supporting characters, including junior surgeons Dr. Everett Gallinger ([[Series/FlashGordon2007 Eric Johnson]]) (Creator/{{Eric Johnson|Actor}}) and Dr. Bertram Chickering, Jr. (Michael Angarano), (Creator/MichaelAngarano), Nurse Lucy Elkins (Eve Hewson), midwife Sister Harriet ([[Film/GangsOfNewYork Cara Seymour]]), (Cara Seymour), ambulance driver Tom Cleary (Chris Sullivan) and New York City health inspector Jacob Speight (David Fierro).

Added: 197

Changed: 117

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheCorrupter: Thurman Drexler acts as this to Gallinger. While Gallinger was already an unpleasant Bigot Drexler’s the guy who introduces him to Eugenics and encourages him to become even worse.



* EveryoneHasStandards: Even before he accepts Edwards Thack is somewhat disturbed when Bunky threatens to lynch him, and also fights to save people during the race riot.
* EvilIsPetty: Gallinger's embrace of Eugenics is pretty much due to jealousy against Edwards; he even sabotages Edward's surgery to one up him.

to:

* EveryoneHasStandards: Even before he accepts Edwards Thack is somewhat disturbed when Bunky threatens to lynch him, and also fights to save people during the race riot.
riot. Clearly likewise is disgusted at the violence displayed by the mob and helps save innocent black people.
* EvilIsPetty: Gallinger's embrace of Eugenics is pretty much largely due to jealousy against Edwards; he even sabotages Edward's surgery to one up him.

Added: 314

Changed: 60

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EveryoneHasStandards: Even before he accepts Edwards Thack is somewhat disturbed when Bunky threatens to lynch him, and also fights to save people during the race riot.
* EvilIsPetty: Gallinger's embrace of Eugenics is pretty much due to jealousy against Edwards; he even sabotages Edward's surgery to one up him.



* GreenEyedMonster: Gallinger's resentment for Edwards springs largely from the fact that Edwards is BETTER than he is.

to:

* GreenEyedMonster: Gallinger's resentment for Edwards springs largely from the fact that Edwards is BETTER better than he is.



* NiceGuy: Bertie, Nurse Elkins, and Miss Robertson. Bertie, especially, who often concerns himself with apologizing obliquely for the conduct of Thack and Gallinger.

to:

* NiceGuy: Bertie, Nurse Elkins, and Miss Robertson. Bertie, especially, who often concerns himself with apologizing obliquely for the conduct of Thack and Gallinger.Gallinger and actually accepts Edwards from the beginning.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Badass Mustache and Badass Beard are being merged into Manly Facial Hair. Examples that don't fit or are zero-context are removed. To qualify for Manly Facial Hair, the facial hair must be associated with masculinity in some way. Please read the trope description before readding to make sure the example qualifies.


* BadassBeard: Not physically badass, but Dr. Christiansen is a pioneering surgeon and sports one of the most impressive arrangements of facial hair ever committed to film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Famous Last Words is getting dewicked per TRS


* FamousLastWords: In the second season's finale, [[spoiler:Thack]] says the following right before he dies on the operating table:
--> [[spoiler: '''Thack''']]: This is it. This is all we are.

Added: 84

Removed: 97

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeathOfAChild: [[spoiler:Poor little Lillian]] [[spoiler: And poor little Grace.]]



* InfantImmortality: Averted. [[spoiler:Poor little Lillian]] [[spoiler: And poor little Grace.]]

Top