Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / SherlockHolmes

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mycroft also shows himself to be quite adept at disguises when he takes over a case for his brother in the heavily rewritten "The Mazarin Stone" (in reality, Jeremy Brett was far too ill to make more than a cameo appearance in the episode).

to:

** Mycroft also shows himself to be quite adept at disguises when he takes over a case for his brother in the heavily rewritten "The Mazarin Stone" (in reality, Jeremy Brett was far too ill to make more than a cameo appearance in the episode).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Mycroft also shows himself to be quite adept at disguises when he takes over a case for his brother in the heavily rewritten "The Mazarin Stone" (in reality, Jeremy Brett was far too ill to make more than a cameo appearance in the episode).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DisposableLoveInterest: In a bit of canon revisionism, Watson doesn't propose at the end of "The Sign of Four."

to:

* DisposableLoveInterest: In a bit of canon revisionism, Watson doesn't propose at the end of "The Sign of Four."Four" (although the attraction between Watson and Ms. Morstan is strongly hinted at).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The "Norwood Builder" is arguably improved by turning the titular character into an actual murderer who killed a tramp to provide a corpse so he could [[FakingTheDead fake his own death]] instead of, as Doyle wrote it, depicting Scotland Yard as bunch of idiots who mistake rabbit bones for those of a human!

to:

** The "Norwood Builder" is arguably improved by turning the titular character into an actual murderer who killed a tramp to provide a corpse so he could [[FakingTheDead fake his own death]] instead of, as Doyle wrote it, depicting Scotland Yard as a bunch of idiots who mistake rabbit bones for those of a human!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsSkill: We know Watson's a doctor, but the only time he uses his medical skills on-screen is in "The Greek Interpreter".

to:

* ChekhovsSkill: We know Watson's a doctor, but but, like in the only time he uses original stories, his medical skills on-screen is in "The Greek Interpreter".knowledge only makes rare appearances.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The "Norwood Builder" is arguably improved by turning the titular character into an actual murderer who killed a tramp to provide a corpse in order to [[FakingTheDead fake his own death]] instead of, as Doyle wrote it, depicting Scotland Yard as bunch of idiots who mistake rabbit bones for those of a human!

to:

** The "Norwood Builder" is arguably improved by turning the titular character into an actual murderer who killed a tramp to provide a corpse in order to so he could [[FakingTheDead fake his own death]] instead of, as Doyle wrote it, depicting Scotland Yard as bunch of idiots who mistake rabbit bones for those of a human!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The "Norwood Builder" is arguably improved by turning the titular character into an actual murderer who killed a tramp to provide a corpse to [[FakingTheDead fake his own death]] instead of, as Doyle wrote it, depicting Scotland Yard as bunch of idiots who mistake rabbit bones for those of a human!

to:

** The "Norwood Builder" is arguably improved by turning the titular character into an actual murderer who killed a tramp to provide a corpse in order to [[FakingTheDead fake his own death]] instead of, as Doyle wrote it, depicting Scotland Yard as bunch of idiots who mistake rabbit bones for those of a human!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The "Norwood Builder" is arguably improved by turning the titular character into an actual murderer who killed a tramp to provide a corpse so that he could [[FakingTheDead fake his own death]] instead of, as Doyle wrote it, depicting Scotland Yard as bunch of idiots who mistake rabbit bones for those of a human!

to:

** The "Norwood Builder" is arguably improved by turning the titular character into an actual murderer who killed a tramp to provide a corpse so that he could to [[FakingTheDead fake his own death]] instead of, as Doyle wrote it, depicting Scotland Yard as bunch of idiots who mistake rabbit bones for those of a human!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The titular "Norwood Builder" is an actual murderer, who killed a tramp to provide a corpse so that he could [[FakingTheDead fake his own death]], which didn't happen in Doyle's original story (arguably this improves the story since not even the dullest Scotland Yard detective would mistake rabbit bones for those of a human).

to:

** The titular "Norwood Builder" is arguably improved by turning the titular character into an actual murderer, murderer who killed a tramp to provide a corpse so that he could [[FakingTheDead fake his own death]], which didn't happen in Doyle's original story (arguably this improves the story since not even the dullest death]] instead of, as Doyle wrote it, depicting Scotland Yard detective would as bunch of idiots who mistake rabbit bones for those of a human).human!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The titular "Norwood Builder" is [[spoiler:an actual murderer, who killed a tramp to provide a corpse so that he could [[FakingTheDead fake his own death]]]], which didn't happen in Doyle's original story.

to:

** The titular "Norwood Builder" is [[spoiler:an an actual murderer, who killed a tramp to provide a corpse so that he could [[FakingTheDead fake his own death]]]], death]], which didn't happen in Doyle's original story.story (arguably this improves the story since not even the dullest Scotland Yard detective would mistake rabbit bones for those of a human).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationDistillation: Episodes run the spectrum from stringently faithful to the Conan Doyle originals, to barely resembling the stories they are based on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->WATSON: "What an attractive woman."
-->HOLMES: "Was she? I hadn't noticed."
-->''The Sign of Four''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the "The Copper Beeches", the final scene has Watson reading aloud from his account of the adventure that he and Holmes had just concluded. Then he turns to Holmes, who had earlier expressed criticism of Watson's writing, and sarcastically asks, "You don't think I put too much color and life into it, do you?" Holmes replies, "I leave all questions of literary style to your expertise!" before turning and looking directly into the camera with a hint of a smile.

to:

** In the "The Copper Beeches", the final scene has Watson reading aloud from his account of the adventure that he and Holmes had just concluded. Then he turns to Holmes, who had earlier expressed criticism of Watson's writing, and he sarcastically asks, "You don't think I put too much color and life into it, do you?" Holmes replies, "I leave all questions of literary style to your expertise!" before turning and looking directly into the camera with a hint of a smile.

Added: 569

Changed: 476

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BreakingTheFourthWall: In the episode "The Copper Beeches", the final scene has Watson reading aloud from his account of the adventure that he and Holmes had just concluded. Then he turns to Holmes, who had earlier expressed criticism of Watson's writing, and sarcastically asks, "You don't think I put too much color and life into it, do you?" Holmes replies, "I leave all questions of literary style to your expertise!" before turning and looking directly into the camera with a hint of a smile.

to:

* BreakingTheFourthWall: BreakingTheFourthWall
**
In the episode "The Copper Beeches", the final scene has Watson reading aloud from his account of the adventure that he and Holmes had just concluded. Then he turns to Holmes, who had earlier expressed criticism of Watson's writing, and sarcastically asks, "You don't think I put too much color and life into it, do you?" Holmes replies, "I leave all questions of literary style to your expertise!" before turning and looking directly into the camera with a hint of a smile.smile.
** In "The Final Problem", Watson speaks into the camera to address his final words to the audience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Holmes' frequent cries of "Mrs. HUDSON!" (though I suppose this might technically count as two words, but the emphasis is always on "Hudson").

to:

** Holmes' frequent cries of "Mrs. HUDSON!" (though I suppose this might technically count as two words, but words; however, the emphasis is always on "Hudson").
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OvershadowedByAwesome: Watson's a pretty intelligent, capable soldier, but he always stands in Holmes's shadow. In real life, this was one of the reasons David Burke left the show, as he felt that he didn't really do much of anything.

to:

* OvershadowedByAwesome: Watson's a pretty intelligent, capable soldier, but he always stands in Holmes's shadow. In real life, this was one of the reasons David Burke left the show, as he felt that he didn't really do much of anything.anything (which makes one wonder if Burke had any familiarity with the source material before accepting the role).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MsFanservice: In any story where a female plays a central role, she is invariably gorgeous, much to Watson's visible delight.

to:

* MsFanservice: In any story where a female plays a central role, she is invariably gorgeous, much to Watson's visible obvious delight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MsFanservice: In any story where a female plays a central role, she is invariably gorgeous, much to Watson's visible delight.

Added: 145

Removed: 43

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Holmes' frequent cries of "Mrs. HUDSON!"


Added DiffLines:

** Holmes' frequent cries of "Mrs. HUDSON!" (though I suppose this might technically count as two words, but the emphasis is always on "Hudson").
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Holmes' frequent cries of "Mrs. HUDSON!"


Added DiffLines:

* BreakingTheFourthWall: In the episode "The Copper Beeches", the final scene has Watson reading aloud from his account of the adventure that he and Holmes had just concluded. Then he turns to Holmes, who had earlier expressed criticism of Watson's writing, and sarcastically asks, "You don't think I put too much color and life into it, do you?" Holmes replies, "I leave all questions of literary style to your expertise!" before turning and looking directly into the camera with a hint of a smile.

Added: 1404

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*DrivenToMadness: During “The Last Vampyre”, Robert Ferguson is so horrified by events that [[spoiler:he carves a wooden stake to attack the corpse of John Stockton, a recently-deceased man rumoured to be descended from a family of vampires, who he blames for his family’s current situation]].



* UnreliableNarrator: The ending of “The Last Vampyre” suggests that Watson did this deliberately for this particular case; the original tale (“The Adventure of the Sussex Vampire”) just involved Jack Ferguson as a disturbed boy trying to poison his new sibling out of jealousy, but here [[spoiler:Jack is partially crippled and outright delusional, believing that he and his self-appointed “mentor” John Stockton are actual vampires. After Jack’s actions lead to the death of his infant half-brother, his father is DrivenToMadness and actually stakes Stockton’s corpse in the belief he was a true vampire, and Jack dies when he tries to fly off an old castle]]. As Holmes and Watson prepare to leave by train, Holmes asks if Watson will write up this case, and Watson’s words suggest that he will edit it to make it more palatable for the public.
* UrbanLegend: “The Last Vampyre” includes the historical detail that the family St.Clair, who lived in the area where the case is taking place, were rumoured to be vampires, and the last known descendant of the family, John Stockton, has moved back into the area.



** Averted to an extent with Moriarty. In "The Red-Headed League", Inspector Jones knows ''exactly'' what Holmes is getting at, when he starts to realize that it is one of Moriarty's scheme. But the Inspector also notes that Scotland Yard really doesn't know much about Moriarty or what he even looks like, only that "his name echoes and re-echoes throughout the underwold."

to:

** Averted to an extent with Moriarty. In "The Red-Headed League", Inspector Jones knows ''exactly'' what Holmes is getting at, when he starts to realize that it is one of Moriarty's scheme.schemes. But the Inspector also notes that Scotland Yard really doesn't know much about Moriarty or what he even looks like, only that "his name echoes and re-echoes throughout the underwold."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* EvilCounterpart: Not played so strongly with Holmes and Moriarty as in other adaptations - the closest we get to this idea is when Holmes tells Watson that Moriarty will do "what I should do. Engage a special train." In fact, Granada seems almost to stress Holmes's goodness in opposition to Moriarty's wickedness, quite different from [[Series/{{Sherlock}} other]] [[Film/SherlockHolmes2009 adaptations]].

to:

* EvilCounterpart: Not played so strongly with Holmes and Moriarty as in other adaptations - the closest we get to this idea is when Holmes tells Watson that Moriarty will do "what I should do. Engage a special train." In fact, Granada seems almost to stress Holmes's goodness in opposition to Moriarty's wickedness, quite different from [[Series/{{Sherlock}} other]] [[Film/SherlockHolmes2009 adaptations]].other adaptations.



* FourEyesZeroSoul: Wilson Kemp, once more. He is perhaps the creepiest villain in the entire series, what with his [[SlasherSmile constant grin]], [[GigglingVillain wicked snicker]], [[SuddenlyShouting sudden]] [[MoodSwinger outbursts of rage]], and a vocal delivery that has hints of Creator/PeterLorre.

to:

* FourEyesZeroSoul: Wilson Kemp, once more. He is perhaps the creepiest villain in the entire series, what with his [[SlasherSmile constant grin]], [[GigglingVillain wicked snicker]], [[SuddenlyShouting sudden]] [[MoodSwinger sudden outbursts of rage]], and a vocal delivery that has hints of Creator/PeterLorre.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalNameChange: The Duke of Holdernesse's wife from "The Priory School is named Francesca instead of Edith.


Added DiffLines:

* RevealingInjury: When Holmes and Watson meet Reuben Hayes in "The Priory School", Watson sees a set of scratches on Hayes' neck, the equivalent of three finger-tracks. When they find the dead schoolmaster, Watson examines his fingernails and confirms the skin under them is consistent with the scratch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The titular "Norwood Builder" is [[spoiler:an actual murderer, who killed a tramp to provide a corpse so that he could [[FakingTheDead Fake The Dead]]]], which didn't happen in Doyle's original story.

to:

** The titular "Norwood Builder" is [[spoiler:an actual murderer, who killed a tramp to provide a corpse so that he could [[FakingTheDead Fake The Dead]]]], fake his own death]]]], which didn't happen in Doyle's original story.



* HollywoodDarkness: In "The Empty House", the titular building is much more well lit than its ''pitch black'' book counterpart.

to:

* HollywoodDarkness: In "The Empty House", the titular building is much more well lit well-lit than its ''pitch black'' book counterpart.

Added: 195

Changed: 12

Removed: 185

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NiceHat: Guess what kind of hat Jeremy Brett's Holmes is best known for. It's the hat you're most likely to see in promotional and cover photos. Can you guess? A sharp, black top hat!



** Basically the gist of Holmes's remonstrance to Watson after Watson's attempted reconnaissance in "The Solitary Cyclist". The adaptation leaves out the line towards the end of the original story where Holmes admits that one observation Watson made during his recon (the mystery cyclist appearing to adjust his necktie) should've told him everything he needed to know about the case, and he also earlier admits that his own visit to the area wasn't much more successful.

to:

** Basically the The gist of Holmes's remonstrance to Watson after Watson's attempted reconnaissance in "The Solitary Cyclist". The adaptation leaves out the line towards the end of the original story where Holmes admits that one observation Watson made during his recon (the mystery cyclist appearing to adjust his necktie) should've told him everything he needed to know about the case, and he also earlier admits that his own visit to the area wasn't much more successful.


Added DiffLines:

* SignatureHeadgear: Guess what kind of hat Jeremy Brett's Holmes is best known for. It's the hat you're most likely to see in promotional and cover photos. Can you guess? A sharp, black top hat!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmartPeoplePlayChess: Dr. Roylett. His stepdaughter's fiance promises to try and improve his own chess game for his next visit to the estate.

to:

* SmartPeoplePlayChess: Dr. Roylett.Roylott. His stepdaughter's fiance promises to try and improve his own chess game for his next visit to the estate.



* WickedStepfather: Dr. Dr. Roylett in "The Speckled Band" who dominates his stepdaughters, kills one, and plots to kill the other so their marriages don't take away his portion of their mother's inheritance.

to:

* WickedStepfather: Dr. Dr. Roylett Grimesby Roylott in "The Speckled Band" who dominates his stepdaughters, kills one, and plots to kill the other so their marriages don't take away his portion of their mother's inheritance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BloodlessCarnage: When [[spoiler:Eduardo Lucas]] is stabbed in "The Second Stain", no blood comes out from being stabbed in the heart... onscreen at least.


Added DiffLines:

* FourIsDeath: When Ronald Adair is counting his money in "The Empty House", he's about to lay down a fourth coin when he is shot.

Added: 647

Changed: 277

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseBiology: From the original text, the "swamp adder" in "The Speckled Band." There was and is no snake with that common name, although the cobra is considered the most likely candidate.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseBiology: ArtisticLicenseBiology:
**
From the original text, the "swamp adder" in "The Speckled Band." There was and is no snake with that common name, although the cobra is considered the most likely candidate.candidate.
** The "Devil's Foot" plant was invented by Doyle.



* DiegeticSoundtrackUsage: The music box Holmes displays at the end of "The Adventure of the Creeping Man" plays the series theme.

to:

* DiegeticSoundtrackUsage: DiegeticSoundtrackUsage:
**
The music box Holmes displays at the end of "The Adventure of the Creeping Man" plays the series theme.theme.
** Holmes also scratches it out on his violin at one point.


Added DiffLines:

* YouCalledMeXItMustBeSerious: Holmes and Watson always use surnames with each other, as was customary at the time. The exception is in "The Devil's Foot". Holmes shouts "John!" when Watson brings him out of the hallucinations caused by the titular plant.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I removed an entry because the trope it was discussing is cut.


* RapunzelHair: Violet Hunter is very proud of hers in "The Copper Beeches". One reason she consults Holmes is that she finds her employer's demand that she cut it to be very odd.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ill Boy has been changed to Delicate And Sickly. Example does not fit criteria for trope.


* IllBoy: Percy Phelps, the client in "The Naval Treaty" is an old school friend of Watson's. Watson remembers him as a delicate boy, and when he becomes their client he's just recovering from a nervous breakdown that's lasted almost ten weeks.

Top