Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / MonkeyKingQuestForTheSutra

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Monkey King: Quest for The Sutra'' is a Hong Kong/Taiwanese television series adapted from [[Literature/JourneyToTheWest the novel of the same title]]. The series had Dicky Cheung reprising the role of Sun Wukong as he previously did in the [[Series/JourneyToTheWest1996 1996 adaptation]]. The series was first broadcast on TVB in 2002. The cast are as follows: Dicky Cheung as Sun Wukong, Edmond Leong as Tang Sanzang, Eric Kot as Zhu Bajie, and Sam Lee as Sha Wujing. The Twins (Charlene Choi and Gillian Chung) also feature prominently as heavenly fairies that either aid or hinder the main protagonists.

to:

''Monkey King: Quest for The Sutra'' is a Hong Kong/Taiwanese television series adapted from [[Literature/JourneyToTheWest the novel of the same title]]. The series had Dicky Cheung reprising the role of Sun Wukong as he previously did in the [[Series/JourneyToTheWest1996 1996 adaptation]]. The series was first broadcast on TVB in 2002. The cast are as follows: Dicky Cheung as Sun Wukong, Edmond Leong as Tang Sanzang, Eric Kot as Zhu Bajie, and Sam Lee Chan Sam as Sha Wujing. The Twins (Charlene Choi and Gillian Chung) also feature prominently as heavenly fairies that either aid or hinder the main protagonists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnachronisticSoundtrack: The opening credits is a ''rap'' song, performed by Dicky Cheung himself. Which plays in the background of several episodes.

to:

* AnachronisticSoundtrack: The opening credits is a ''rap'' song, performed by Dicky Cheung himself. In a show set in the Tang Dynasty. Which plays in the background of several episodes.



* LighterAndSofter: Definitely so compared to the novel. There are loads of gags in the series, and even some of the specific deviations from the novel (E.g.: The order of recruiting the disciples) are done so for laughs.

to:

* LighterAndSofter: Definitely so compared to the novel. There are loads of gags in the series, and even some of the specific deviations from the novel (E.g.: The order of recruiting the disciples) are done so for laughs. It's even more light-hearted than the [[Series/JourneyToTheWest1996 previous adaptation starring Cheung]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnachronisticSoundtrack: The opening credits is a ''rap'' song, performed by Dicky Cheung himself. Which plays in the background of several episodes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dosen't seem to be anymore it seems https://movie.douban.com/subject/1830577/


Note this twisted adaptation summarized so far is the most faithful this series has to the novel, and when the actual journey begins the various story-plots are completely different from the novel. Even the original purpose of retrieving the scriptures has gradually evolved into some quest against a universal evil threat named Heavenly Demon (Tian Mo). Given the critical responses by the reviewers, it is easily the most reviled adaptation of Journey to the West.

to:

Note this twisted adaptation summarized so far is the most faithful this series has to the novel, and when the actual journey begins the various story-plots are completely different from the novel. Even the original purpose of retrieving the scriptures has gradually evolved into some quest against a save-the-world plot dealing with a universal evil threat named Heavenly Demon (Tian Mo). Given As a result of these deviations, it was seen as the critical responses by the reviewers, it is easily the most reviled worst adaptation of Journey to the West.
West when it was airing, through opinions towards the series have significantly warmed in more recent years.

Changed: 264

Removed: 266

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbortedArc:
** One notable early part of the story was the fairy Zimei being in love with Nezha, as a parallel to fairy Zilan in love with Wukong. It was quickly dropped, perhaps cut due to length reasons, after Zimei and Nezha had their memories relating to the romance erased.

to:

* AbortedArc:
**
AbortedArc: One notable early part of the story was the fairy Zimei being in love with Nezha, as a parallel to fairy Zilan in love with Wukong. It was quickly dropped, perhaps cut due to length reasons, after Zimei and Nezha had their memories relating to the romance erased.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Probably the most noble and friendliest live-action adaptation of Sun Wukong to date. The early part of the series focused on [[EstablishingCharacterMoment emphasizing Sun Wukong's character]] as a NiceGuy.

to:

** Probably the most noble noblest and friendliest live-action adaptation of Sun Wukong to date. The early part of the series focused on [[EstablishingCharacterMoment emphasizing Sun Wukong's character]] as a NiceGuy.



*** Most (but not all) of his morally questionable acts like killing harmless people/demons were left out of the adaptation.

to:

*** Most (but not all) of his morally questionable acts like killing harmless people/demons were left out of the adaptation. Not only that, his mischievous ways was also toned down a little compared to the 1996/1998 HK Adaptation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Compared to the novel version, this adaptation's Sun Wukong is a lot more honorable and likable. The early part of the series focused on [[EstablishingCharacterMoment emphasizing Sun Wukong's character]] as a NiceGuy.

to:

** Compared to Probably the novel version, this adaptation's most noble and friendliest live-action adaptation of Sun Wukong is a lot more honorable and likable.to date. The early part of the series focused on [[EstablishingCharacterMoment emphasizing Sun Wukong's character]] as a NiceGuy.



*** Most of his morally questionable acts like killing harmless people/demons were left out of the adaptation.
** This adaptation's Tang Sanzang is easily the nicest live-action incarnation of the Holy Monk ever portrayed, so much so that his disciples tend to walk all over him.

to:

*** Most (but not all) of his morally questionable acts like killing harmless people/demons were left out of the adaptation.
** This Just like Wukong, this adaptation's Tang Sanzang is easily the nicest live-action incarnation of the Holy Monk ever portrayed, so much so that his disciples tend to walk all over him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheMillstone: Zimei's mischief in the early part of the show triggered or contributed to the downfall of the protagonists Sun Wukong and Zhu Bajie. She's partly responsible for Marshall Tianpeng's banishment to the earthly plane, and then she made yet another mistake by messing with the Books of Reincarnation, causing Tianpeng to reincarnate as a pig. Finally, she accidentally killed the peach trees he planted, pushing him further out of favour with the Heavenly Courts and therefore setting up Wukong's eventual rebellion.

to:

* TheMillstone: Zimei's mischief in the early part of the show triggered or contributed to the downfall of the protagonists Sun Wukong and Zhu Bajie. She's partly responsible for Marshall Tianpeng's banishment to the earthly plane, and then she made yet another mistake by messing with the Books of Reincarnation, causing Tianpeng to reincarnate as a pig. Finally, she accidentally killed the peach trees he Sun Wukong had planted, pushing him further out of favour with the Heavenly Courts and therefore setting up Wukong's eventual rebellion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InformedDeformity: Downplayed with Fairy Zimei. Marshall Tianpeng (who eventually became Zhu Bajie) showed absolutely no attraction to Zimei, and pointed out she looks "unattractively underage". The other characters also tend to see her as an annoying brat. While Zimei is Zilan's younger sister, in real life, Gillian Chung (Zimei) is actually more than a year older than Charlene Choi (Zilan).

to:

* InformedDeformity: Downplayed with Fairy Zimei. Marshall Tianpeng (who eventually became Zhu Bajie) showed absolutely no attraction to Zimei, and pointed out she looks "unattractively underage".her "underaged features" is a massive turnoff. The other characters also tend to see her as an annoying brat. While Zimei is Zilan's younger sister, in real life, Gillian Chung (Zimei) is actually more than a year older than Charlene Choi (Zilan).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InformedDeformity: Downplayed with Fairy Zimei. Marshall Tianpeng (who eventually became Zhu Bajie) showed absolutely no attraction to Zimei, and pointed out she looks "unattractively underage". The other characters in the show also deemed her as a bratty annoyance. While Zimei is Zilan's younger sister, in real life, Gillian Chung (Zimei) is actually more than a year older than Charlene Choi (Zilan).

to:

* InformedDeformity: Downplayed with Fairy Zimei. Marshall Tianpeng (who eventually became Zhu Bajie) showed absolutely no attraction to Zimei, and pointed out she looks "unattractively underage". The other characters in the show also deemed tend to see her as a bratty annoyance.an annoying brat. While Zimei is Zilan's younger sister, in real life, Gillian Chung (Zimei) is actually more than a year older than Charlene Choi (Zilan).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InformedAttractiveness: Fairy Zilan was described to be one of the most beautiful fairies on heaven.
* InNameOnly:

to:

* InformedAttractiveness: Fairy Zilan was described to be one of the most beautiful fairies (and also the most physically aggressive) on heaven.
* InNameOnly: InformedDeformity: Downplayed with Fairy Zimei. Marshall Tianpeng (who eventually became Zhu Bajie) showed absolutely no attraction to Zimei, and pointed out she looks "unattractively underage". The other characters in the show also deemed her as a bratty annoyance. While Zimei is Zilan's younger sister, in real life, Gillian Chung (Zimei) is actually more than a year older than Charlene Choi (Zilan).
* InNameOnly:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Wukong was made the guardian of the Peach trees and rebelled against Heaven by stealing and eating the Peaches of Immortality. In this adaptation, he became the Peach trees' gardener as punishment for stealing and eating the peaches. His rebellion only happened later on.

to:

** In the novel, Wukong was made the guardian of the Peach trees and rebelled against Heaven by stealing and eating the Peaches of Immortality. In this adaptation, he became the Peach trees' gardener as punishment for stealing and eating the peaches. His rebellion only happened later on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Wukong was made the guardian of the Peach trees and rebelled against Heaven by stealing and eating the Peaches of Immortality. In this adaptation, he became the Peach trees' gardener as punishment for stealing and eating the peaches. His rebellion only happened later on.


Added DiffLines:

* TheMillstone: Zimei's mischief in the early part of the show triggered or contributed to the downfall of the protagonists Sun Wukong and Zhu Bajie. She's partly responsible for Marshall Tianpeng's banishment to the earthly plane, and then she made yet another mistake by messing with the Books of Reincarnation, causing Tianpeng to reincarnate as a pig. Finally, she accidentally killed the peach trees he planted, pushing him further out of favour with the Heavenly Courts and therefore setting up Wukong's eventual rebellion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShipSinking: It looked as if Tang Sanzang was going to fall in love with Susu and vice versa. Susu then announced that she is leaving the group to pursue Buddhism elsewhere.

to:

* ShipSinking: It looked as if ShipTease: There are moments of this between Tang Sanzang was going to fall in love with and Susu, and even the disciples pointed it out in-universe. The [[ShipSinking ship sank]] when Susu and vice versa. Susu then announced that she is leaving the group to pursue Buddhism elsewhere.elsewhere, and Sanzang did not stop her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BroughtDownToNormal:
** [[spoiler:Wujing's ending. He choose to become a normal human and pursued a relationship with someone who looked exactly like his former love interest]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StraightMan: Sun Wukong, Sanzang, and Wujing are this to the buffoonish Zhu Bajie.

Added: 917

Changed: 333

Removed: 672

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Completely new stories and plotlines replaced most of the novel's plot after all the 3 main disciples were found.
** Sun Wukong in a love triangle between senior fairy Zilan and the White Bone Demoness takes a significant portion of the series, instead of focusing on the journey itself. Do we need to say anything more?
** Sun Wukong striking White Bone Demoness three times was left in, but the motivation for that was due to a lovers' quarrel (!!!) rather than Wukong's desire to protect his master. Not only that, Sanzang was barely involved in their quarrel.
** The protagonists' female love interests (or [[ShipTease ship-teased]] ones) are allowed to travel with them and maintain their relationships during the Journey, which completely violates the principles of a Buddhist monk!

to:

** Completely new stories and plotlines replaced most of the novel's plot after all the 3 main disciples were found.
** Sun Wukong in a love triangle between senior fairy Zilan and the White Bone Demoness takes a significant portion of the series, instead of focusing on the journey itself. Do we need to say anything more?
** Sun Wukong striking White Bone Demoness three times was left in, but the motivation for that was due to a lovers' quarrel (!!!) [[note]]See the InNameOnly trope in this page[[/note]] rather than Wukong's desire to protect his master. Not only that, Sanzang was barely involved in their quarrel.
** The protagonists' female love interests (or [[ShipTease ship-teased]] ones) are allowed to travel with them and maintain their relationships during the Journey, which completely violates the principles of a Buddhist monk!
quarrel.



** ... Overall, massive liberties with the source material were taken, and so there are way too many examples to list.

to:

** ... Overall, massive liberties were taken with the source material were taken, material, and so there are way too many examples to list.


Added DiffLines:

* InNameOnly:
** Completely original stories replaced most of the novel's plot after all the 3 main disciples were found, notable examples being the zombie infection episodes and the final story arc involving Tian Mo, but there's more.
** Sun Wukong, in a very out of character moment, is stuck in a love triangle between senior fairy Zilan and the White Bone Demoness, and that takes a significant portion of the series instead of focusing on the journey itself. Do we need to say anything more?
** In the novel, there's virtually zero romantic relationships involved with any of the 3 main disciples - They are Mahayana Buddhist monks after all. In this adaptation, all the protagonists including Sanzang had female love interests (or [[ShipTease ship-teased]] ones), and are allowed to travel with them and maintain their relationships during the Journey, which completely violates the principles of a Buddhist monk!

Top