Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / TintinTintinInAmerica

Go To

OR

Added: 128

Removed: 128

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The comic starts with Tintin searching Al Capone. After a short confrontation, Al is never seen again.



* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The comic starts with Tintin searching Al Capone. After a short confrontation, Al is never seen again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
saved tintin's life not saved tintin's live


* AnimalWrongsGroup: An elderly woman on a train pulls the lever because she saw a [[PredatorsAreMean puma attack a deer]] and ''insists'' the conductor intervene. She ends up inadvertently saving Tintin's live since he was ChainedToARailway at the time.

to:

* AnimalWrongsGroup: An elderly woman on a train pulls the lever because she saw a [[PredatorsAreMean puma attack a deer]] and ''insists'' the conductor intervene. She ends up inadvertently saving Tintin's live life since he was ChainedToARailway at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWildWest: Apparently coexisting with 1930s Chicago. That being said, the redrawn version at least indicates that Tintin needs a two-day train journey to get there, whereas the original edition had it practically on Chigago's doorstep.

to:

* TheWildWest: Apparently coexisting with 1930s Chicago. That being said, the redrawn version at least indicates that Tintin needs a two-day train journey to get there, whereas the original edition had it practically on Chigago's Chicago's doorstep.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MobWar

to:

* MobWarMobWar: Played with; the mobs are initially battling each other, but near the end of the story most of them call a truce in an effort to get rid of Tintin once and for all.



* RandomEventsPlot: Not to the same extent as ''[[Recap/TintinTintinInTheCongo Tintin in the Congo]]'' but definitely compared to the later books.

to:

* RandomEventsPlot: Not to the same extent as ''[[Recap/TintinTintinInTheCongo ''[[Recap/TintinTintinInTheLandOfTheSoviets Land of the Soviets]]'' or '' [[Recap/TintinTintinInTheCongo Tintin in the Congo]]'' Congo]]'', as about half of the storyline is focused on Tintin's attempt to take down Bobby Smiles, but definitely compared to it still doesn't really have a coherent overall storyline, instead just being based around the later books.general theme of Tintin battling gangsters.



* TheWildWest: Apparently coexisting with 1930s Chicago.

to:

* TheWildWest: Apparently coexisting with 1930s Chicago. That being said, the redrawn version at least indicates that Tintin needs a two-day train journey to get there, whereas the original edition had it practically on Chigago's doorstep.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KarmaHoudini: Al Capone, assuming he had not been arrested offscreen.

to:

* KarmaHoudini: Al Capone, assuming he had not been arrested offscreen. In RealLife, Capone was tried and arrested for tax evasion while this story was still being serialised, so one can presume his fictional counterpart eventually followed suit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadCopIncompetentCop: Some of them actually make the Thompsons look halfway competant.

to:

* BadCopIncompetentCop: Some of them actually make the Thompsons look halfway competant.competent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ButNotTooBlack: When ''Tintin'' finally got marketed in the USA in the 1950s he was forced to change a few black extra's into white people. For instance: the man guarding the hotel after the Native Americans are being removed from their land was originally black, as were the woman and her crying baby whom Tintin incorrectly assumes is Snowy crying for help.

to:

* ButNotTooBlack: When ''Tintin'' finally got marketed in the USA in the 1950s he was forced to change a few black extra's extras into white people. For instance: the man guarding the hotel after the Native Americans are being removed from their land was originally black, as were the woman and her crying baby baby, whom Tintin incorrectly assumes is Snowy crying for help.

Added: 1514

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It's 1931 and having dealt with AlCapone's [[Recap/TintinTintinInTheCongo diamond smuggling operation in the Belgian Congo]] Tintin and Snowy head for Chicago to clean up {{Gangsterland}}. He almost at once runs afoul of Al Capone himself[[note]]Capone is the only real person to appear in the Tintin stories[[/note]] but manages to evade the mob boss only to find himself making an enemy of Capone's rival Bobby Smiles.

to:

It's 1931 and having dealt with AlCapone's UsefulNotes/AlCapone's [[Recap/TintinTintinInTheCongo diamond smuggling operation in the Belgian Congo]] Tintin and Snowy head for Chicago to clean up {{Gangsterland}}. He almost at once runs afoul of Al Capone himself[[note]]Capone is the only real person to appear in the Tintin stories[[/note]] but manages to evade the mob boss only to find himself making an enemy of Capone's rival Bobby Smiles.


Added DiffLines:

* ButNotTooBlack: When ''Tintin'' finally got marketed in the USA in the 1950s he was forced to change a few black extra's into white people. For instance: the man guarding the hotel after the Native Americans are being removed from their land was originally black, as were the woman and her crying baby whom Tintin incorrectly assumes is Snowy crying for help.


Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: UsefulNotes/AlCapone, who was still alive at the time this story was drawn. For obvious reasons Hergé had to let him escape. In Harry Thompson's "Tintin and Hergé: a double biography" Thompson wrote down a funny quote about this cameo: ''"We don't know what Al Capone ever thought of the album. He probably never read it, seeing that Hergé was never found on the bottom of a Belgian river with his [[CementShoes feet in a block of cement]]."''


Added DiffLines:

* NationalStereotypes: The USA is depicted as a country full of gangsters, skyscrapers and cowboys and Native Americans who apparently still roam the Wild West. When Tintin strucks oil countless American business people quickly appear out of nowhere to buy the ground from him. After informing them that it actually belongs to the Native Americans the business people quickly pay them a small fee, force them to leave immediately and build an entire city from scratch in a matter of 24 hours!


Added DiffLines:

* ShoutOut:
** The original 1931 story had a shout-out to Creator/MaryPickford near the end, when Tintin is speeching to a bunch of rich people. This was removed from the color version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CoversAlwaysLie: The Nelvana animated adaptation uses the same album cover, but no Native Americans appear in the story, probably due to political correctness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spoilers Off no spoiler tags on recap pages


* AnimalWrongsGroup: An elderly woman on a train pulls the lever because she saw a [[PredatorsAreMean puma attack a deer]] and ''insists'' the conductor intervene. [[spoiler: She ends up inadvertently saving Tintin's live since he was ChainedToARailway at the time.]]

to:

* AnimalWrongsGroup: An elderly woman on a train pulls the lever because she saw a [[PredatorsAreMean puma attack a deer]] and ''insists'' the conductor intervene. [[spoiler: She ends up inadvertently saving Tintin's live since he was ChainedToARailway at the time.]]



* DeusExMachina: Arguably uses this more than any other entry in the series. [[spoiler:Smiles' mooks using knockout gas instead of poison gas by mistake, the animal lover stopping the train, Tintin and Snowy being tossed off a cliff and landing on a branch conveniently next to a cave network, the cannery workers going on strike, Tintin mistakenly being tied to a set of wooden weights rather than real ones.]]

to:

* DeusExMachina: Arguably uses this more than any other entry in the series. [[spoiler:Smiles' Smiles' mooks using knockout gas instead of poison gas by mistake, the animal lover stopping the train, Tintin and Snowy being tossed off a cliff and landing on a branch conveniently next to a cave network, the cannery workers going on strike, Tintin mistakenly being tied to a set of wooden weights rather than real ones.]]



* MysteryMeat: Grynde Corp. make their tinned meat out of dogs, cats, rats and [[spoiler: nearly Tintin, until he escaped.]]

to:

* MysteryMeat: Grynde Corp. make their tinned meat out of dogs, cats, rats and [[spoiler: and nearly Tintin, until he escaped.]]



* [[spoiler:TickertapeParade: In Tintin's honor at the end, after he cleans up Chicago.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:TickertapeParade: TickertapeParade: In Tintin's honor at the end, after he cleans up Chicago.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmericansAreCowboys: Once Tintin leaves Chicago and its mobsters, pretty much every American he encounters in the countryside is a cowboy or some other kind of frontiersman. Somewhat justified, as the cowboy era was not long dead. The trope is PlayedWith in the same book, however: A city is built [[{{Boomtown}} overnight]] in an area that used to be pretty WildWest. The next morning, Tintin finds himself the only person in the city still wearing his cowboy outfit, and receives a chiding from a police officer who tells him to put on something proper.

to:

* AmericansAreCowboys: Once Tintin leaves Chicago and its mobsters, pretty much every American he encounters in the countryside is a cowboy or some other kind of frontiersman. Somewhat justified, as the cowboy era was not long dead. The trope is PlayedWith in the same book, however: A city BoomTown is built [[{{Boomtown}} overnight]] ''[[RidiculouslyFastConstruction overnight]]'' in an area that used to be pretty WildWest. The next morning, Tintin finds himself the only person in the city still wearing his cowboy outfit, and receives a chiding from a police officer who tells him to put on something proper.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It's 1931 and having dealt with AlCapone's [[Recap/TintinTintinInTheCongo diamond smuggling operation in the Belgian Congo]] Tintin and Snowy head for Chicago to clean up {{Gangsterland}}. He almost at once runs afoul of Al Capone himself[[hottip:*: Capone is the only real person to appear in the Tintin stories]] but manages to evade the mob boss only to find himself making an enemy of Capone's rival Bobby Smiles.

to:

It's 1931 and having dealt with AlCapone's [[Recap/TintinTintinInTheCongo diamond smuggling operation in the Belgian Congo]] Tintin and Snowy head for Chicago to clean up {{Gangsterland}}. He almost at once runs afoul of Al Capone himself[[hottip:*: Capone himself[[note]]Capone is the only real person to appear in the Tintin stories]] stories[[/note]] but manages to evade the mob boss only to find himself making an enemy of Capone's rival Bobby Smiles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarlyBirdCameo: Roberto Rastapopoulos in one panel.

to:

* EarlyBirdCameo: Roberto Rastapopoulos in one panel.panel in the recolored version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EarlyBirdCameo: Roberto Rastapopoulos in one panel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KarmaHoudini: Al Capone, assuming he had not been arrested offscreen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InexplicablyIdenticalIndividuals: The horses appearing in the story have pretty strange postures. And if you compare carefully, they all have just two or three different outlines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* WhatHappenedToTheMouse?: The comic starts with Tintin searching Al Capone. After a short confrontation, Al is never seen again.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse?: WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The comic starts with Tintin searching Al Capone. After a short confrontation, Al is never seen again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse?: The comic starts with Tintin searching Al Capone. After a short confrontation, Al is never seen again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmericansAreCowboys: Once Tintin leaves Chicago and its mobsters, pretty much every American he encounters in the countryside is a cowboy or some other kind of frontiersman. Somewhat justified, as the cowboy era was not long dead. The trope is PlayedWith in the same book, however: A city is built [[{{Boomtown}} overnight]] in an area that used to be pretty WildWest. The next morning, Tintin finds himself the only person in the city still wearing his cowboy outfit, and receives a chiding from a police officer who tells him to put on something proper.


Added DiffLines:

* ClimbSlipHangClimb: The Ellipse-Nelvana animated version adds this to a ledge-walking scene that had averted it in the book.
* CorruptCorporateExecutive: All over the place. Maurice Oyle is a prime example.


Added DiffLines:

* [[spoiler:TickertapeParade: In Tintin's honor at the end, after he cleans up Chicago.]]
* TheWildWest: Apparently coexisting with 1930s Chicago.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is the last Tintin book where Snowy is shown actually talking, and (though it's slightly ambiguous) Tintin seems to understand what he's saying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvilVersusEvil: Tintin is upset when the people most applauding him for taking on Al Capone are a rival group of gangsters led by Bobby Smiles.


Added DiffLines:

* PunnyName: Mr. Grynde and Grynde Corp., who make ''ground'' tinned meat.

Added: 288

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InjunCountry: A rather mixed example - the Blackfeet Indians are violent and gulible but they are also depicted as victims.

to:

* InjunCountry: A rather mixed example - the Blackfeet Indians are violent and gulible gullible but they are also depicted as victims.victims.
* InMediasRes: Because ''Tintin in the Congo'' was not available for so long but this story was, it came across as this. Al Capone referring to his previous clash with Tintin sounded more like a CrypticBackgroundReference to readers than referring back to an actual written prequel story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CowboyEpisode: It was based on [[{{Flanderization}} European stereotypes of the USA]] and features plenty of Wild West imagery despite being set in the 1930s.



* WretchedHive: Chicago is presented as such, and the US as a whole comes across as a CrapsackWorld.

to:

* WretchedHive: Chicago is presented as such, and the US as a whole comes across as a CrapsackWorld.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It's 1931 and having dealt with AlCapone's [[Recap/TintinTintinInTheCongo diamond smuggling operation in the Belgian Congo]] Tintin and Snowy head for Chicago to clean up {{Gangsterland}}. He almost at once runs afoul of Al Capone himself[[hottip:*: Capone is the only real peron to appear in the Tintin stories]] but manages to evade the mob boss only to find himself making an enemy of Capone's rival Bobby Smiles.

to:

It's 1931 and having dealt with AlCapone's [[Recap/TintinTintinInTheCongo diamond smuggling operation in the Belgian Congo]] Tintin and Snowy head for Chicago to clean up {{Gangsterland}}. He almost at once runs afoul of Al Capone himself[[hottip:*: Capone is the only real peron person to appear in the Tintin stories]] but manages to evade the mob boss only to find himself making an enemy of Capone's rival Bobby Smiles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeusExMachina: Arguably uses this more than any other entry in the series. [[spoiler: The animal lover stopping the train, the cannery workers going on strike, Tintin mistakenly being tied to a set of wooden weights rather than real ones.]]

to:

* DeusExMachina: Arguably uses this more than any other entry in the series. [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:Smiles' mooks using knockout gas instead of poison gas by mistake, the animal lover stopping the train, Tintin and Snowy being tossed off a cliff and landing on a branch conveniently next to a cave network, the cannery workers going on strike, Tintin mistakenly being tied to a set of wooden weights rather than real ones.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*TheManTheyCouldntHang: Tintin. ''Twice''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Basically, the USA gets [[{{Flanderization}} Flanderized]] to the point that it reads like an ...actually pretty amusing parody overall.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It's 1931 and having dealt with Al Capone's [[Recap/TintinTintinInTheCongo diamond smuggling operation in the Belgian Congo]] Tintin and Snowy head for Chicago to clean up {{Gangsterland}}. He almost at once runs afoul of Al Capone himself[[hottip:*: Capone is the only real peron to appear in the Tintin stories]] but manages to evade the mob boss only to find himself making an enemy of Capone's rival Bobby Smiles.

to:

It's 1931 and having dealt with Al Capone's AlCapone's [[Recap/TintinTintinInTheCongo diamond smuggling operation in the Belgian Congo]] Tintin and Snowy head for Chicago to clean up {{Gangsterland}}. He almost at once runs afoul of Al Capone himself[[hottip:*: Capone is the only real peron to appear in the Tintin stories]] but manages to evade the mob boss only to find himself making an enemy of Capone's rival Bobby Smiles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnimalWrongsGroup: An elderly woman on a train pulls the lever because she saw a puma attack a deer and ''insists'' the conductor intervene. [[spoiler: She ends up inadvertently saving Tintin's live since he was ChainedToARailway at the time.]]

to:

* AnimalWrongsGroup: An elderly woman on a train pulls the lever because she saw a [[PredatorsAreMean puma attack a deer deer]] and ''insists'' the conductor intervene. [[spoiler: She ends up inadvertently saving Tintin's live since he was ChainedToARailway at the time.]]

Top