Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / TheWestWingS01E07TheStateDinner

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mandy acts like this when she realize the standoff in Idaho has resulted in the shooting of the negotiator she insisted they send.

to:

** Mandy acts like reacts this way when she realize the standoff in Idaho has resulted in the shooting of the negotiator she insisted they send.send. She ends up running out of the dinner to [[StressVomit throw up]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''C.J.:''' It's wine, you'll drink it!

to:

-->'''C.J.:''' It's wine, you'll drink it!it!
* YouAreNotAlone: The episode ends on a tragic version as Bartlet tells Harold Lewis on the tender ship that he'll stay on the radio as long as the signal holds out. Lewis is doomed by the hurricane, and all Bartlet can do is make sure he's not alone in his final hours.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sam is upset when Laurie turns up as the escort of one of the administration's key donors and the resulting tension between them causes a fight between them;

to:

** Sam is upset when Laurie turns up as the escort of one of the administration's key donors and the resulting tension between them causes results in a fight between them; major argument;



* JerkassHasAPoint: The Indonesian official doesn't seem like a particularly nice man and takes great pleasure in jerking Toby, Josh, Donna and the multiple translators they find to facilitate their conversation around. But he has pretty valid points in that it's both pretty arrogant for both the United States to lecture other countries about human rights abuses when it's own hands are hardly clean on that score, and that it's pretty arrogant for Toby on a personal level to turn around and expect an Indonesian official to do him a favour after writing a very confrontational speech insulting Indonesia and it's president at a state dinner that was supposed to be in their honour.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: The Indonesian official doesn't seem like a particularly nice man and takes great pleasure in jerking Toby, Josh, Donna and the multiple translators they find to facilitate their conversation around. But he has pretty valid points in that it's both pretty arrogant for both the United States to lecture other countries about human rights abuses when it's its own hands are hardly clean on that score, and that it's pretty arrogant for Toby on a personal level to turn around and expect an Indonesian official to do him a favour after writing a very confrontational speech insulting Indonesia and it's its president at a state dinner that was supposed to be in their honour.



'''Toby:'''... Please understand, that with so many people watching, with so much media coverage it was important for us to make clear that the United States, with it's commitment to human rights, has an obligation --\\

to:

'''Toby:'''... Please understand, that with so many people watching, with so much media coverage it was important for us to make clear that the United States, with it's its commitment to human rights, has an obligation --\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This episode is also notable for being the first appearance of the First Lady, Dr. Abigail Bartlet (Stockard Channing), as well as the first episode where Danny tries to flirt with C.J.

to:

This episode is also notable for being the first appearance of the First Lady, Dr. Abigail Bartlet (Stockard Channing), (Creator/StockardChanning), as well as the first episode where Danny tries to flirt with C.J.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DumbassHasAPoint: Not exactly 'dumb', in her defence, but Donna's failure to find a convenient translator for the meeting with the Indonesian official prompts some less-than-impressed reactions from Toby and Josh. But when they react snottily to the fact that she has to resort to a Portuguese translator talking to a White House kitchen hand who speaks Portuguese and Batak but not English, she irritably snaps back that while he might not speak English he does speak Portuguese and Batak, which are two languages neither Toby nor Josh can speak, "so I wouldn't look down your nose!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SarcasmFailure: Bartlet tries to lighten the mood when speaking to Signalman Harold Lewis aboard the ''USS Hickory'':
-->'''Bartlet:''' Can you tell us what's going on?\\
'''Lewis:''' We're looking at, I guess, 80 foot seas with winds up to 120 knots. Shipping solid green water over the bow, we've got a fire in the engine room, lost our running lights, may get run over by an aircraft carrier that can't see in the dark.\\
'''Barlet:''' ''(sits down wearily)'' Well I don't know, man. Sounds pretty bad, Harold, I think I'd ask for my money back... Harold?\\
'''Lewis:''' ...Yes, sir.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** President Bartlet, used to being the most powerful man in any room and the Leader of the Free World, finds himself powerless to do anything regarding a massive hurricane and a man being shot, and finds that all he can really do is bully some union and management officials into settling a potential strike action. On a less life-changing level, he's also incapable of getting the Indonesian President, a rather curt and unfriendly man, to contribute anything more than single-word responses to any attempt at conversation.

to:

** President Bartlet, used to being the most powerful man in any room and the Leader of the Free World, finds himself powerless to do anything regarding a massive hurricane and a man being shot, and finds that all he can really do is bully some union and management officials into settling a potential strike action.action and try to comfort the radio operator on a ship being hit hard by the storm. On a less life-changing level, he's also incapable of getting the Indonesian President, a rather curt and unfriendly man, to contribute anything more than single-word responses to any attempt at conversation.

Added: 3089

Changed: 1011

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Pride}}: Toby's self-righteousness borders on hubris in this episode. He is witheringly dismissive of Sam's attempt including more diplomatic language in the toast to the Indonesian President, and insists on making the language uncompromising in its condemnation of past Indonesian human rights abuses. Even when approaching the Indonesian aide to get help to release Toby's friend his attitude is blunt and commanding, as if he expects the official to meekly leap into action simply because he, Toby Ziegler, is standing before him demanding that it be so. Toby's subsequently left reeling when the Indonesian aide bluntly tells him to go to hell, reveals that he knows full well Toby was the one responsible for the insulting speech, points out that America's own history of human rights abuses means it doesn't have as much high ground on the issue as it likes to pretend, and storms off. Sam's alternative speech was presumably looking a lot better at that point.

to:

* {{Pride}}: Arrogance -- and having to face the results of it backfiring -- is something of a theme of this episode:
**
Toby's the worst culprit -- his self-righteousness practically borders on hubris in this episode. He is witheringly dismissive of Sam's attempt including more diplomatic language in the toast to the Indonesian President, and insists on making the language uncompromising in its condemnation of past Indonesian human rights abuses. Even when approaching the Indonesian aide to get help to release Toby's friend his attitude is blunt and commanding, as if he expects the official to meekly leap into action simply because he, Toby Ziegler, is standing before him demanding that it be so. Toby's subsequently left reeling when the Indonesian aide bluntly tells him to go to hell, reveals that he knows full well Toby was the one responsible for the insulting speech, points out that America's own history of human rights abuses means it doesn't have as much high ground on the issue as it likes to pretend, and storms off. Sam's alternative speech was presumably looking a lot better at that point.
** Despite his prior protests, Sam is clearly trying to 'save' Laurie from her life as a sex worker, despite her claims that she is content doing what she does and her oft-expressed wish that he'd just drop the subject. His high-handedness regarding her life and decisions comes back to haunt him when she shows up at the state dinner as the escort of a major Democratic donor; he's subsequently left reeling, and his hostile and bitter 'offer' to pay her to stop being a sex worker just drives a wedge between the two.
** Mandy's perhaps ill-advised attempts to operate on the level of policy rather than her usual area of media relations results in the negotiator she advises Bartlet to send in to the militia stand-off getting shot and ending up in critical condition, much to her horror.
** President Bartlet, used to being the most powerful man in any room and the Leader of the Free World, finds himself powerless to do anything regarding a massive hurricane and a man being shot, and finds that all he can really do is bully some union and management officials into settling a potential strike action. On a less life-changing level, he's also incapable of getting the Indonesian President, a rather curt and unfriendly man, to contribute anything more than single-word responses to any attempt at conversation.
** For that matter, the hurricane hitting the naval carrier group that was moved out of port precisely to ''avoid'' the hurricane is a perfect metaphor for the most powerful navy the world has ever seen belonging to the most powerful superpower nation the world has ever seen finding out the hard way that there are some events they can neither anticipate nor control.
** Even C.J. isn't entirely free from it this episode; while she has a point about the superficiality of the questions she's being fielded with, public relations is nevertheless a key part of her job, the whole point of a state dinner in the first place is in large part a public relations exercise, and her complaints and jabs to the fashion reporters therefore come off as a little snide and condescending.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mandy acts like this when she realize the standoff in Idaho has resulted in the death of the negotiator she insisted they send.

to:

** Mandy acts like this when she realize the standoff in Idaho has resulted in the death shooting of the negotiator she insisted they send.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Another subtle example occurs during Toby's meeting with the Indonesian official when trying to get his friend out of jail. In general, Toby is frequently shown to be blunt, borderline undiplomatic and even arrogant when meeting with political opponents when he's convinced he's in the right and victory is in his grasp. Throughout the episode, he's forthright and insistent in his opposition to the Indonesian regime, to the point of dismissiveness when Sam suggests more tactful language in the speech. And while not exactly rude to the Indonesian official he and Josh meet, he is blunt, forceful and unapologetic when the official points out that his friend broke Indonesian law (though to be completely fair to Toby on this one, the law broken was organising anti-government protests) when making his demands, acting like a man in control who expects to get his own way. So notice how, when the official reveals that he knows full well that Toby wrote the insulting speech about his president, Toby almost instantly switches from his previously authoritative and borderline arrogant attitude ("What we're talking about is you unlock the cell, you put him in a car, and you drive him to the border.") to offering a weak smile and a sudden, feeble attempt at diplomacy ("Please understand that with so many people watching, with so much media coverage, it was important for us to make clear that the United States, with its commitment to human rights, has an obligation..."). He clearly realises in that exact moment just how massively he's screwed up.
* {{Pride}}: Toby's self-righteousness borders on hubris in this episode. He is witheringly dismissive of Sam's attempt at a more diplomatic attempt at addressing Indonesian human rights abuses, and insists on making the language uncompromising in its condemnation. Even when approaching the Indonesian aide to get help to release Toby's friend his attitude is, while not exactly rude, very unapologetic and demanding, as if he expects the official to meekly leap into action simply because he, Toby Ziegler, is standing before him demanding that it be so. Toby's subsequently left reeling when the Indonesian aide bluntly tells him to go to hell, reveals that he knows full well Toby was the one responsible for the insulting speech, points out that America's own history of human rights abuses means it doesn't have as much high ground on the issue as it likes to pretend, and storms off. Sam's alternative speech was presumably looking a lot better at that point.

to:

** Another subtle example occurs during Toby's meeting with the Indonesian official when trying to get his friend out of jail. In general, Toby is frequently shown to be blunt, borderline undiplomatic and even arrogant when meeting with political opponents when he's convinced he's in the right and victory is in his grasp. Throughout the episode, he's forthright and insistent in his opposition to the Indonesian regime, to the point of dismissiveness when Sam suggests more tactful language in the speech. And while not exactly rude to the Indonesian official he and Josh meet, he is blunt, unapologetically forceful and unapologetic when the official points out that his friend broke Indonesian law (though to be completely fair to Toby on this one, the law broken was organising anti-government protests) commanding when making his demands, acting like a man fully in control who expects to get his own way. way against an easily-cowed opponent. So notice how, when the official reveals that he knows full well that Toby wrote the insulting speech about his president, Toby almost instantly switches from his previously authoritative and borderline arrogant attitude ("What we're talking about is you unlock the cell, you put him in a car, and you drive him to the border.") to offering a weak smile and a sudden, feeble attempt at diplomacy ("Please understand that with so many people watching, with so much media coverage, it was important for us to make clear that the United States, with its commitment to human rights, has an obligation..."). He clearly realises in that exact moment just how massively he's screwed up.
* {{Pride}}: Toby's self-righteousness borders on hubris in this episode. He is witheringly dismissive of Sam's attempt at a including more diplomatic attempt at addressing language in the toast to the Indonesian human rights abuses, President, and insists on making the language uncompromising in its condemnation. condemnation of past Indonesian human rights abuses. Even when approaching the Indonesian aide to get help to release Toby's friend his attitude is, while not exactly rude, very unapologetic is blunt and demanding, commanding, as if he expects the official to meekly leap into action simply because he, Toby Ziegler, is standing before him demanding that it be so. Toby's subsequently left reeling when the Indonesian aide bluntly tells him to go to hell, reveals that he knows full well Toby was the one responsible for the insulting speech, points out that America's own history of human rights abuses means it doesn't have as much high ground on the issue as it likes to pretend, and storms off. Sam's alternative speech was presumably looking a lot better at that point.

Added: 842

Changed: 324

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Jerkass}}: The Indonesian President is a very cold, terse and arrogant-seeming man who barely responds to Bartlet's polite attempts at conversation.
-->'''Bartlet:''' I can't decide whether that man is boring or rude but he's one or the other.

to:

* {{Jerkass}}: {{Jerkass}}:
**
The Indonesian President is a very cold, terse and arrogant-seeming man who barely responds to Bartlet's polite attempts at conversation.
-->'''Bartlet:''' --->'''Bartlet:''' I can't decide whether that man is boring or rude but he's one or the other.other.
** Toby's particularly blunt with his self-righteousness in this episode, being patronising and dismissive to Sam when he tries to lighten the language and remind Toby that the Indonesians are guests at the White House and arrogant towards the Indonesian official.
*** Sam's treatment of Laurie isn't that great either. He's repeatedly insulting about her job despite the fact that she's made it clear it's none of his business, takes the fact that she showed up at the state dinner with a client as a personal insult despite her protests that she didn't know she'd be there (though to be totally fair it could be embarrassing-to-catastrophic for him if their connection became known), and insults her by offering her money to stop being an escort.



** Another subtle example occurs during Toby's meeting with the Indonesian official when trying to get his friend out of jail. In general, Toby is frequently shown to be blunt, borderline undiplomatic and even arrogant when meeting with political opponents when he's convinced he's in the right and victory is in his grasp. Throughout the episode, he's forthright and insistent in his opposition to the Indonesian regime, to the point of dismissiveness when Sam suggests more tactful language in the speech. And while not exactly rude to the Indonesian official he and Josh meet, he is blunt, forceful and unapologetic when the official points out that his friend broke Indonesian law (though to be completely fair to Toby on this one, the law broken was organising anti-government protests) when making his demands, acting like a man in control who expects to get his own way. So notice how, when the official reveals that he knows full well that Toby wrote the insulting speech about his president, Toby almost instantly switches from his previously authoritative and borderline arrogant attitude ("What we're talking about is you unlock the cell, you put him in a car, and you drive him to the border.") to offering a weak smile and a sudden, feeble attempt at diplomacy ("Please understand that with so many people watching, with so much media coverage, it was important for us to make clear that the United States, with it's commitment to human rights, has an obligation..."). He clearly realises in that exact moment just how massively he's screwed up.

to:

** Another subtle example occurs during Toby's meeting with the Indonesian official when trying to get his friend out of jail. In general, Toby is frequently shown to be blunt, borderline undiplomatic and even arrogant when meeting with political opponents when he's convinced he's in the right and victory is in his grasp. Throughout the episode, he's forthright and insistent in his opposition to the Indonesian regime, to the point of dismissiveness when Sam suggests more tactful language in the speech. And while not exactly rude to the Indonesian official he and Josh meet, he is blunt, forceful and unapologetic when the official points out that his friend broke Indonesian law (though to be completely fair to Toby on this one, the law broken was organising anti-government protests) when making his demands, acting like a man in control who expects to get his own way. So notice how, when the official reveals that he knows full well that Toby wrote the insulting speech about his president, Toby almost instantly switches from his previously authoritative and borderline arrogant attitude ("What we're talking about is you unlock the cell, you put him in a car, and you drive him to the border.") to offering a weak smile and a sudden, feeble attempt at diplomacy ("Please understand that with so many people watching, with so much media coverage, it was important for us to make clear that the United States, with it's its commitment to human rights, has an obligation..."). He clearly realises in that exact moment just how massively he's screwed up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Another subtle example occurs during Toby's meeting with the Indonesian official when trying to get his friend out of jail. In general, Toby is frequently shown to be blunt, borderline undiplomatic and even arrogant when meeting with political opponents when he's convinced he's in the right and victory is in his grasp. Throughout the episode, he's forthright and insistent in his opposition to the Indonesian regime, to the point of dismissiveness when Sam suggests more tactful language in the speech. And while not exactly rude to the Indonesian official he and Josh meet, he is blunt, forceful and unapologetic when the official points out that his friend broke Indonesian law (though to be completely fair to Toby on this one, the law broken was organising anti-government protests) when making his demands, acting like a man in control who expects to get his own way. So notice how, when the official reveals that he knows full well that Toby wrote the insulting speech about his president, Toby almost instantly switches from his previously authoritative attitude ("What we're talking about is you unlock the cell, you put him in a car, and you drive him to the border.") to offering a weak smile and a sudden attempt at diplomacy ("Please understand that with so many people watching, with so much media coverage, it was important for us to make clear that the United States, with it's commitment to human rights, has an obligation..."). He clearly realises in that exact moment just how massively he's screwed up.
* {{Pride}}: Toby's self-righteousness borders on hubris in this episode. He is witheringly dismissive of Sam's attempt at a more diplomatic attempt at addressing Indonesian human rights abuses, insists on making the language uncompromising in its condemnation, and even when approaching the Indonesian aide to get help to release Toby's friend, his attitude is, while not exactly rude, nevertheless rather unapologetic and demanding, as if he expects the official to meekly leap into action simply because he, Toby Ziegler, is standing before him demanding that it be so. Toby's subsequently left reeling when the Indonesian aide bluntly tells him to go to hell, reveals that he knows full well Toby was the one responsible for the insulting speech, points out that America's own history of human rights abuses means it doesn't have as much high ground on the issue as it likes to pretend, and storms off. Sam's alternative speech was presumably looking a lot better at that point.

to:

** Another subtle example occurs during Toby's meeting with the Indonesian official when trying to get his friend out of jail. In general, Toby is frequently shown to be blunt, borderline undiplomatic and even arrogant when meeting with political opponents when he's convinced he's in the right and victory is in his grasp. Throughout the episode, he's forthright and insistent in his opposition to the Indonesian regime, to the point of dismissiveness when Sam suggests more tactful language in the speech. And while not exactly rude to the Indonesian official he and Josh meet, he is blunt, forceful and unapologetic when the official points out that his friend broke Indonesian law (though to be completely fair to Toby on this one, the law broken was organising anti-government protests) when making his demands, acting like a man in control who expects to get his own way. So notice how, when the official reveals that he knows full well that Toby wrote the insulting speech about his president, Toby almost instantly switches from his previously authoritative and borderline arrogant attitude ("What we're talking about is you unlock the cell, you put him in a car, and you drive him to the border.") to offering a weak smile and a sudden sudden, feeble attempt at diplomacy ("Please understand that with so many people watching, with so much media coverage, it was important for us to make clear that the United States, with it's commitment to human rights, has an obligation..."). He clearly realises in that exact moment just how massively he's screwed up.
* {{Pride}}: Toby's self-righteousness borders on hubris in this episode. He is witheringly dismissive of Sam's attempt at a more diplomatic attempt at addressing Indonesian human rights abuses, and insists on making the language uncompromising in its condemnation, and even condemnation. Even when approaching the Indonesian aide to get help to release Toby's friend, friend his attitude is, while not exactly rude, nevertheless rather very unapologetic and demanding, as if he expects the official to meekly leap into action simply because he, Toby Ziegler, is standing before him demanding that it be so. Toby's subsequently left reeling when the Indonesian aide bluntly tells him to go to hell, reveals that he knows full well Toby was the one responsible for the insulting speech, points out that America's own history of human rights abuses means it doesn't have as much high ground on the issue as it likes to pretend, and storms off. Sam's alternative speech was presumably looking a lot better at that point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Abbey:''' You know, one of the things that happens when I stay away too long, is that you forget that you don’t have to power to fix everything. You have a big brain. And a good heart. And an ego the size of Montana. You do, Jed. You don’t have the power to fix everything. But I do like watching you try.

to:

-->'''Abbey:''' --->'''Abbey:''' You know, one of the things that happens when I stay away too long, is that you forget that you don’t have to power to fix everything. You have a big brain. And a good heart. And an ego the size of Montana. You do, Jed. You don’t have the power to fix everything. But I do like watching you try.



** About the only things that go well are C.J gets to flirt with Danny a bit and Bartlet scares the hell out of the feuding trucking industry management and union representatives (although [[NoEnding we never find definitely out]] whether they managed to avoid the strike or not).

to:

** About the only things that go well are C.J gets to flirt with Danny a bit bit, Charlie's grandparents escape the hurricane, and Bartlet scares the hell out of the feuding trucking industry management and union representatives (although [[NoEnding we never find definitely out]] whether they managed to avoid the strike or not).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SlaveToPR: As C.J. wryly summarizes, while the White House has to handle a hurricane, negotiate an impending trucker strike that could cripple the country, oversee an FBI raid on an armed militia group, ''and'' host a state dinner for the President of Indonesia, the most important question she'll be asked by the press throughout the day is [[SkewedPriorities what the First Lady will be wearing]].

to:

* SlaveToPR: As C.J. wryly summarizes, while the White House has to handle monitor a hurricane, negotiate an impending trucker strike that could cripple the country, oversee an FBI raid on an armed militia group, ''and'' host a state dinner for the President of Indonesia, Indonesia all at the same time, the most important question she'll be asked by the press throughout the day is [[SkewedPriorities what the First Lady will be wearing]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SlaveToPR: As C.J. wryly summarizes, while the White House has to handle a hurricane, negotiate an impending trucker strike that could cripple the country, oversee an FBI raid on an armed militia group, ''and'' host a state dinner for the President of Indonesia, the most important question she'll be asked by the press throughout the day is [[SkewedPriorities what the First Lady will be wearing]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompletelyUnnecessaryTranslator: Donna sets up ''two'' translators who can translate from Batak to Portugeuse to English so Josh and Toby cand speak to Bambang. After taking several minutes to exchange pleasantries Bambang reveals he speaks perfect English.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CompletelyUnnecessaryTranslator: Donna sets up ''two'' translators who can translate from Batak to Portugeuse to English so Josh and Toby cand speak to Bambang. After taking several minutes to exchange pleasantries Bambang reveals he speaks perfect English.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Directed by Creator/ThomasSchlamme

Written by Creator/AaronSorkin & Creator/PaulRedford
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Another subtle example occurs during Toby's meeting with the Indonesian official when trying to get his friend out of jail. He's been forthright and insistent in his opposition to the Indonesian regime throughout the episode, even during the meeting he is blunt, forceful, unapologetic about his friend's crimes (by Indonesian standards, at least, since his friend was locked up for organising anti-government protests) and even arrogant when making his demands, and other episodes in general frequently note and demonstrate that Toby tends to be far from tactful when he's facing off with people opposing him when he's certain he's in the right. So notice how, when the official reveals that he knows full well that Toby wrote the insulting speech about his president, he almost instantly switches from commanding ("What we're talking about is you unlock the cell, you put him in a car, and drive him to the border.") to offering a weak smile and a sudden attempt at diplomacy ("Please understand that with so many people watching, with so much media coverage, it was important for us to make clear that the United States, with it's commitment to human rights, has an obligation..."). He clearly realises just how massively he's screwed up.

to:

** Another subtle example occurs during Toby's meeting with the Indonesian official when trying to get his friend out of jail. He's been In general, Toby is frequently shown to be blunt, borderline undiplomatic and even arrogant when meeting with political opponents when he's convinced he's in the right and victory is in his grasp. Throughout the episode, he's forthright and insistent in his opposition to the Indonesian regime throughout regime, to the episode, even during point of dismissiveness when Sam suggests more tactful language in the meeting speech. And while not exactly rude to the Indonesian official he and Josh meet, he is blunt, forceful, forceful and unapologetic about when the official points out that his friend's crimes (by friend broke Indonesian standards, at least, since his friend law (though to be completely fair to Toby on this one, the law broken was locked up for organising anti-government protests) and even arrogant when making his demands, and other episodes acting like a man in general frequently note and demonstrate that Toby tends control who expects to be far from tactful when he's facing off with people opposing him when he's certain he's in the right. get his own way. So notice how, when the official reveals that he knows full well that Toby wrote the insulting speech about his president, he Toby almost instantly switches from commanding his previously authoritative attitude ("What we're talking about is you unlock the cell, you put him in a car, and you drive him to the border.") to offering a weak smile and a sudden attempt at diplomacy ("Please understand that with so many people watching, with so much media coverage, it was important for us to make clear that the United States, with it's commitment to human rights, has an obligation..."). He clearly realises in that exact moment just how massively he's screwed up.

Added: 2226

Changed: 1849

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: A subtle example. When President Bartlet enters the room where the negotiations between the truckers union and management are taking place, everyone rises as is expected. When they move to sit down to continue the negotiations, Bartlet orders them to explain their positions while remaining standing. Normally, one of the first things Bartlet ever says whenever he enters a room and everyone stands is "Keep your seats." It's a clue of how extra-frustrated he is by the events of the episode.
* {{Pride}}: Toby's self-righteousness borders on hubris in this episode. He is witheringly dismissive of Sam's attempt at a more diplomatic attempt at addressing Indonesian human rights abuses, insists on making the language uncompromising in its condemnation, and even when approaching the Indonesian aide to get help to release Toby's friend, his attitude is borderline confrontational and demanding, as if he expects the official to meekly leap into action simply because he, Toby Ziegler, is standing before him demanding that it be so. Toby's subsequently left reeling when the Indonesian aide bluntly tells him to go to hell, reveals that he knows full well Toby was the one responsible for the insulting speech, points out that America's own history of human rights abuses means it doesn't have as much high ground on the issue as it likes to pretend, and storms off. Sam's alternative speech was presumably looking a lot better at that point.

to:

* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: OOCIsSeriousBusiness:
**
A subtle example. When President Bartlet enters the room where the negotiations between the truckers union and management are taking place, everyone rises as is expected. When they move to sit down to continue the negotiations, Bartlet orders them to explain their positions while remaining standing. Normally, one of the first things Bartlet ever says whenever he enters a room and everyone stands is "Keep your seats." It's a clue of how extra-frustrated he is by the events of the episode.
** Another subtle example occurs during Toby's meeting with the Indonesian official when trying to get his friend out of jail. He's been forthright and insistent in his opposition to the Indonesian regime throughout the episode, even during the meeting he is blunt, forceful, unapologetic about his friend's crimes (by Indonesian standards, at least, since his friend was locked up for organising anti-government protests) and even arrogant when making his demands, and other episodes in general frequently note and demonstrate that Toby tends to be far from tactful when he's facing off with people opposing him when he's certain he's in the right. So notice how, when the official reveals that he knows full well that Toby wrote the insulting speech about his president, he almost instantly switches from commanding ("What we're talking about is you unlock the cell, you put him in a car, and drive him to the border.") to offering a weak smile and a sudden attempt at diplomacy ("Please understand that with so many people watching, with so much media coverage, it was important for us to make clear that the United States, with it's commitment to human rights, has an obligation..."). He clearly realises just how massively he's screwed up.
* {{Pride}}: Toby's self-righteousness borders on hubris in this episode. He is witheringly dismissive of Sam's attempt at a more diplomatic attempt at addressing Indonesian human rights abuses, insists on making the language uncompromising in its condemnation, and even when approaching the Indonesian aide to get help to release Toby's friend, his attitude is borderline confrontational is, while not exactly rude, nevertheless rather unapologetic and demanding, as if he expects the official to meekly leap into action simply because he, Toby Ziegler, is standing before him demanding that it be so. Toby's subsequently left reeling when the Indonesian aide bluntly tells him to go to hell, reveals that he knows full well Toby was the one responsible for the insulting speech, points out that America's own history of human rights abuses means it doesn't have as much high ground on the issue as it likes to pretend, and storms off. Sam's alternative speech was presumably looking a lot better at that point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Pride}}: Toby's self-righteousness borders on hubris in this episode. He is witheringly dismissive of Sam's attempt at a more diplomatic attempt at addressing Indonesian human rights abuses, insists on making the language uncompromising in its condemnation, and even when approaching the Indonesian aide to get help to release Toby's friend, his attitude is borderline confrontational and demanding. Toby's subsequently left reeling when the Indonesian aide bluntly tells him to go to hell, reveals that he knows full well Toby was the one responsible for the insulting speech, points out that America's own history of human rights abuses means it doesn't have as much high ground on the issue as it likes to pretend, and storms off. Sam's alternative speech was presumably looking a lot better at that point.

to:

* {{Pride}}: Toby's self-righteousness borders on hubris in this episode. He is witheringly dismissive of Sam's attempt at a more diplomatic attempt at addressing Indonesian human rights abuses, insists on making the language uncompromising in its condemnation, and even when approaching the Indonesian aide to get help to release Toby's friend, his attitude is borderline confrontational and demanding.demanding, as if he expects the official to meekly leap into action simply because he, Toby Ziegler, is standing before him demanding that it be so. Toby's subsequently left reeling when the Indonesian aide bluntly tells him to go to hell, reveals that he knows full well Toby was the one responsible for the insulting speech, points out that America's own history of human rights abuses means it doesn't have as much high ground on the issue as it likes to pretend, and storms off. Sam's alternative speech was presumably looking a lot better at that point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HoistByHisOwnPetard: Maybe if Toby had taken Sam's advice and used the milder speech instead, the Indonesian official might have let Toby's friend out of jail.

to:

* HoistByHisOwnPetard: Maybe if Toby had taken Sam's advice and used the milder speech instead, the Indonesian official might have let helped get Toby's friend out of jail.

Top