Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / TheOrvilleS2E5AllTheWorldIsABirthdayCake

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* VillainousFaceHold: The dentist who takes tooth extractions from Ed, Claire, and Talla pulls this trope so he can get at their mouths.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
still wouldn't work


** It wouldn't take advanced technology to discover the new "star" was a fake. The solar sail is deployed in close proximity to the planet, so the planet's orbit alone would cause it to appear in different positions in the night sky over the year, and even during the same night different telescopes would show it in different positions compared to the background stars, and thus far, far closer than the ruse is meant to suggest. (It really only ''needed'' to work long enough to confuse the Regorians into releasing Kelly and Bortus, but the protagonists think it will work a lot longer.)[[note]]Justified...dialogue indicates that the solar sail has integrated thrusters which allow it to continually reorient itself, as well as jammers that prevent the native technology from detecting it.[[/note]]

to:

** It wouldn't take advanced technology to discover the new "star" was a fake. The solar sail is deployed in close proximity to the planet, so the planet's orbit alone would cause it to appear in different positions in the night sky over the year, and even during the same night different telescopes would show it in different positions compared to the background stars, and thus far, far closer than the ruse is meant to suggest. They do attempt to {{handwave}} this with mentions that the sail is self-propelled and can reposition itself, but that really wouldn't stop the Regorians from eventually triangulating its real position. (It really only ''needed'' to work long enough to confuse the Regorians into releasing Kelly and Bortus, but the protagonists think it will work a lot longer.)[[note]]Justified...dialogue indicates that the solar sail has integrated thrusters which allow it to continually reorient itself, as well as jammers that prevent the native technology from detecting it.[[/note]])
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
misuse of Enforced Trope


* SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute: The new chief of security, Talla, is also a Xelayan, meaning she has the same strength that Alara did. She even has a similar hairstyle. Enforced in that Ed specifically requested a Xelayan for the position, so apparently he ''wanted'' another one just like the last one.

to:

* SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute: The new chief of security, Talla, is also a Xelayan, meaning she has the same strength that Alara did. She even has a similar hairstyle. Enforced in that Ed specifically requested a Xelayan for the position, so apparently he ''wanted'' another one just like the last one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute: The new chief of security, Talla, is also a Xelayan, meaning she has the same strength that Alara did. She even has a similar hairstyle. Justified in that Ed specifically requested a Xelayan for the position.

to:

* SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute: The new chief of security, Talla, is also a Xelayan, meaning she has the same strength that Alara did. She even has a similar hairstyle. Justified Enforced in that Ed specifically requested a Xelayan for the position.position, so apparently he ''wanted'' another one just like the last one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WrongfulAccusationInsurance: After the crew pulls off their con, Kelly and Bortus are released from the camps as their original "crime" is no longer such... despite the fact that they had just attempted to escape and killed or injured dozens of guards in the process.

to:

* WrongfulAccusationInsurance: After the crew pulls off their con, Kelly and Bortus are released from the camps as their original "crime" is no longer such... despite the fact that they had just attempted to escape and killed or injured dozens of guards in the process. {{Justified|Trope}} by the nature of their justice system being based on astrology. After Kelly and Bortus were caught, the astrological charts were altered, which meant that they were now blessed instead of cursed. In the process this retroactively justified their actions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ThenLetMeBeEvil: Bortus and Kelly justify their escape attempt with this. If they're gonna be seen as violent criminals, they'll be playing into their hands.

Added: 242

Changed: 688

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenPedestal: The Regorians are ecstatic to meet with the Orville at first. However, their opinion of the Orville (and the Union as a whole) quickly declines once they learn that the Union does not subscribe to the same astrology-based belief system that the Regorians do, and that they allow people that the Regorians deem to be dangerous criminals and major threats to society to simply walk around without any safety precautions.

to:

* BrokenPedestal: The Regorians are ecstatic to meet with the Orville ''Orville'' at first. However, their opinion of the Orville ''Orville'' (and the Union as a whole) quickly declines once they learn that the Union does not subscribe to the same astrology-based belief system that the Regorians do, and that they allow people that the Regorians deem to be dangerous criminals and major threats to society to simply walk around without any safety precautions.



* FantasticRacism: Something of a variation. The Regorians are RubberForeheadAliens who discriminate against people born under a specific stellar sign, thus cutting across class, ethnic, gender and family lines. We see a couple who are considered inferior and locked in a concenteation camp, but their daughter is considered superior and treated almost worshipfully, solely because of her birth date.

to:

* FantasticRacism: Something of a variation. The Regorians are RubberForeheadAliens who discriminate against people born under a specific stellar sign, thus cutting across class, ethnic, gender and family lines. We see a couple who are considered inferior and locked in a concenteation concentration camp, but their daughter is considered superior and treated almost worshipfully, solely because of her birth date.



* OrderIsNotGood: It's heavily implied that the Regorians came to this Astroligy-based belief system due to a desire to find somekind of order in the natural chaos of ther universe.

to:

* OrderIsNotGood: It's heavily implied that the Regorians came to this Astroligy-based Astrology-based belief system due to a desire to find somekind some kind of order in the natural chaos of ther their universe.



* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: The prejudice against an specific astrological sign was the result of a star in that constellation being swallowed by a black hole, around 3,000 years prior, and the Regorians witnessing the event. This doesn't take into consideration the interstellar distances and the time it would take for the light of the star to travel to Regor II. It would take hundreds if not thousands of years for the Regorians to notice the star had gone dark, and the dates of the star's destruction and the Regorians cultural change would not match.[[note]]Possibly justified as the dialogue is vague enough to interpret as "the light from the star's collapse into a black hole would have first arrived at this planet 3000 years ago".[[/note]]

to:

* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale: The prejudice against an a specific astrological sign was the result of a star in that constellation being swallowed by a black hole, around 3,000 years prior, and the Regorians witnessing the event. This doesn't take into consideration the interstellar distances and the time it would take for the light of the star to travel to Regor II. It would take hundreds if not thousands of years for the Regorians to notice the star had gone dark, and the dates of the star's destruction and the Regorians cultural change would not match.[[note]]Possibly justified as the dialogue is vague enough to interpret as "the light from the star's collapse into a black hole would have first arrived at this planet 3000 years ago".[[/note]]



* ShoutOut: When taking the landing party into custody, Chief Advisor Makkal refers to Talla as "the one with the ears," how many uninformed referred to Spock from ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries''.
** The music that plays while the Orville warps into the solar system sounds very much like ''Film/StarTrekIITheWrathOfKhan''.
* ShutUpGunshot: The concentration camp commander makes short order of Bortus's and Kelly's fight with the guards by firing his sidearm in the air, pointedly telling them that if they attempt that again, the next bullet will be in their brain.

to:

* ShoutOut: ShoutOut:
**
When taking the landing party into custody, Chief Advisor Makkal refers to Talla as "the one with the ears," how many uninformed referred to Spock from ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries''.
** The music that plays while the Orville ''Orville'' warps into the solar system sounds very much like ''Film/StarTrekIITheWrathOfKhan''.
* ShutUpGunshot: The concentration camp commander makes short order work of Bortus's and Kelly's fight with the guards by firing his sidearm in the air, pointedly telling them that if they attempt that again, the next bullet will be in their brain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenPedestal: The Regorians are ecstatic to meet with the Orville at first. However, their opinion of the Orville (and the Union as a whole) quickly declines once they learn that the Union does not subscribe to the same astrology-based belief system that the Regorians do, and that they allow people that the Regorians deem to be dangerous criminals and major threats to society to simply walk around without any safety precautions.


Added DiffLines:

* FlatEarthAtheist: This is essentially how the Regorians come to see the Union. The Prime Minister is utterly flummoxed that a group of people who live amongst the stars and thus "should understand their signifigance better than anybody" ''don't'' view the stars as the ultimte arbiters of fate and destiny.


Added DiffLines:

* OrderIsNotGood: It's heavily implied that the Regorians came to this Astroligy-based belief system due to a desire to find somekind of order in the natural chaos of ther universe.
-->'''Prime Minister:''' So you all just think the universe is chaos? No Order? No signifigance to anything? I wouldn't ''want'' to be part of a community that believes that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Most likely, the Regorians simply calculated their ages from the tooth sample and converted that age into the Regorian calendar, i.e. they determine a person is 42 years, 5 months, 3 weeks, and 2 days old, then go back that far in their own calendar and calculate their astrological sign.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It wouldn't take advanced technology to discover the new "star" was a fake. The solar sail is deployed in close proximity to the planet, so the planet's orbit alone would cause it to appear in different positions in the night sky over the year, and even during the same night different telescopes would show it in different positions compared to the background stars, and thus far, far closer than the ruse is meant to suggest. (It really only ''needed'' to work long enough to confuse the Regorians into releasing Kelly and Bortus, but the protagonists think it will work a lot longer.)

to:

** It wouldn't take advanced technology to discover the new "star" was a fake. The solar sail is deployed in close proximity to the planet, so the planet's orbit alone would cause it to appear in different positions in the night sky over the year, and even during the same night different telescopes would show it in different positions compared to the background stars, and thus far, far closer than the ruse is meant to suggest. (It really only ''needed'' to work long enough to confuse the Regorians into releasing Kelly and Bortus, but the protagonists think it will work a lot longer.))[[note]]Justified...dialogue indicates that the solar sail has integrated thrusters which allow it to continually reorient itself, as well as jammers that prevent the native technology from detecting it.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The music that plays while the Orville warps into the solar system sounds very much like ''Film/StarTrekIITheWrathOfKhan''.

Added: 467

Changed: 223

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FantasticRacism: Something of a variation. The Regorians are RubberForeheadAliens who discriminate against people born under a specific stellar sign known as "Giliacs", thus cutting across class, ethnic, and gender lines.

to:

* FantasticRacism: Something of a variation. The Regorians are RubberForeheadAliens who discriminate against people born under a specific stellar sign known as "Giliacs", sign, thus cutting across class, ethnic, and gender lines.and family lines. We see a couple who are considered inferior and locked in a concenteation camp, but their daughter is considered superior and treated almost worshipfully, solely because of her birth date.


Added DiffLines:

* VillainBall: The whole idea of the caste system is to keep Giliac away from the rest of society, which means that simply demanding that Kelly and Bortus leave the planet would be at least as effective as locking them up, with the added advantage that a) they wouldn't need to be fed, sheltered or guarded and b) it wouldn't risk antagonizing a far more powerful alien species. Despite this, the First Prefect stubbornly refuses to even consider letting them leave.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Shout-out: When taking the landing party into custody, Chief Advisor Makkal refers to Talla as "the one with the ears," how many uninformed referred to Spock from ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries''.

to:

* Shout-out: ShoutOut: When taking the landing party into custody, Chief Advisor Makkal refers to Talla as "the one with the ears," how many uninformed referred to Spock from ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Shout-out: When taking the landing party into custody, Chief Advisor Makkal refers to Talla as "the one with the ears," how many uninformed referred to Spock from ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries''.

Top